2 ms·
> I suspect a fair number of the complainers are people with Democratic leanings, and I think I can describe their thought process to you. > I think their prob
by rayiner 6y ago
> I suspect a fair number of the complainers are people with Democratic leanings, and I think I can describe their thought process to you.
> I think their problem is that a private company is doing this, not the Government.
Is that a Democratic take? I think it's a liberaltarian take on it. Here's the conservative libertarian response: raising children is one of the primary functions of society, and social norms that govern private actors make a certain amount of deference to that. Replacing those norms and kicking everything up to the government is a very statist solution, inviting the government into large swaths of human activity where it wasn't present before.
- maxerickson 6y agoWhat's the conservative libertarian take on what to do when those norms are gone and haven't been replaced?
- rayiner 6y agoReinstate the norm because we haven’t come up with a better idea and are unlikely to do so.
- betenoire 6y agoI assume you'd want to reinstate the norm with the same spirit wrt government involvement... How does that work?
- maxerickson 6y agoSure, the abstract answer is obvious. I meant the concrete answer, how do you reinstate a norm that people have stopped caring about, or that has been eroded by some policy (in the worst case, a policy championed by those that claim the norm)?
- sdenton4 6y agoProbably involves market solutions... "Sister for sale! One sister for sale! One crying and spying young sister for sale!"
- leetcrew 6y agoare they gone? isn't this thread about single facebook employees resenting the special accommodations their employer has granted to parents?
- dcolkitt 6y agoIt’s not a full answer to your question, but given a long enough timeframe the problem is self-correcting. Sub-cultures with anti-natalist norms will find themselves subsumed by those that produce a lot of children. Simple math tells us that the typical American circa 2100 is a lot more likely to be descended from Utah Mormons than Bay Area rationalists.
- taejo 6y ago> Simple math tells us that the typical American circa 2100 is a lot more likely to be descended from Utah Mormons than Bay Area rationalists. Descended from today's Utah Mormons than today's Bay Area rationalists. That doesn't mean they won't move to the Bay Area and become rationalists themselves.
- zajio1am 6y ago> Here's the conservative libertarian response Seems to me more like plain conservative response. Libertarian position would be to protect individual liberty against both state and societal oppression. E.g. In 'On Liberty' J.S.Mill discussed mainly societal oppression (by social norms) as it is more prevasive and insidious than state oppression.