3 ms·
If you don’t want to deal with this possibility then simply don’t have kids. This attitude -- which is pretty common in the US -- never fails to astound me. F
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
If you don’t want to deal with this possibility then simply don’t have kids.
This attitude -- which is pretty common in the US -- never fails to astound me.
First, a lot of babies are not planned. Birth control failures happen or young people learn the hard way the facts of life because they fooled around ended up pregnant before they had a good idea of how things worked and some people are essentially brainwashed from birth into believing that using birth control will send them straight to hell. And sometimes people think "I will take my chances just this one time" and that one time turns out to be enough to result in pregnancy.
That's without getting into the reality that a woman can end up pregnant as a consequence of rape.
Second, if all people successfully take this advice and simply don't have kids, then there is no one to take care of us in our old age as our species dies out, having promoted the idea "You only live once and you should live for today and just indulge selfishly."
Children are the social capital of the future. They are future workers and future tax payers and future caregivers that people who are currently hail and hardy will someday need -- unless you want to follow up this policy with "Let's just start executing people who fall ill with anything that could require long term convalescence and, also, start executing people when they hit a certain age so we don't have to deal with the frailty of old age."
(No, I am not being extremist. I'm really not.)
- goldenchrome 6y agoMy comment was directed at wealthy tech workers who have access to education, contraceptives, and abortions. Of course there are outliers but most of my coworkers carefully planned their pregnancy around their company’s promotion schedules. And I don’t think the human race is anything special and I’m more than happy to let it die off if we decide to stop having kids.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI have six years of college and a Certificate in GIS. I was one of the top students in my graduating high school class and won a National Merit Scholarship. I also have a 33 year old son who is the result of failed birth control. I chose to not seek an abortion because I was already married to a man with whom I wanted kids, but I had originally intended to have them later. I will suggest that most of your coworkers discussing their "carefully planned pregnancies" are people willing to talk about their experiences and/or carefully framing their experiences in a socially acceptable manner. Most people who enjoy conventional success are either fortunate to have lives that fit a certain framework relatively easily or they get good at pretending to fit it and covering up or leaving out the things the people around them wouldn't be comfortable hearing. Basically, your position is one of "Everything needs to go right in your life all the time or a big fat fuck you from me." And that tends to cause the fabric of society to unravel because most people can't manage to force their life to go right every step of the way all the time. If their lives work, it's because they had some kind of safety net when things did go wrong at some point. If you are rich enough, you can sometimes pretend this is not the case, but the money itself is a kind of safety net, so it's a BS position for wealthy people to take.
- goldenchrome 6y agoGreat, so you actively chose to have a kid and you managed to deal with the consequences. That’s all I’m arguing for. I support you. If you wanted to minimize chaos in your life, you wouldn’t have had a kid. You don’t get to choose to have a kid and then complain about the chaos.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoGiven how hard it is to get an abortion in some parts of the US and that I was ten weeks along before I learned I was pregnant, it's possible that if I had wanted an abortion, I would have been unable to get it or I would have had to get it illegally and that would have caused complications, as illegal abortions are often performed under unsafe conditions and have something of a tendency to go badly because of it. People often do not have as much choice as you are more or less flippantly trying to claim they do.
- goldenchrome 6y agoYou could have called 1-800-ADOPTION Doreen! I think you wanted that baby, so you get to deal with it!
- DoreenMichele 6y agoAn adoptee himself, Mars founded his first business, a nonprofit adoption agency, in his parents’ basement in 1991. He turned his own story and passion for bringing families together into American Adoptions https://www.americanadoptions.com/adoption/scott-mars https://www.americanadoptions.com/adoption/scott-mars It looks to me like that was founded less than 34 years ago and it would have been 34 years ago this November that I was learning I was ten weeks pregnant. So, no, I probably could not have called 1-800-ADOPTION.
- derwiki 6y agoAdoption has been an option for more than 34 years, even if not this specific service.
- manfredo 6y agoWomen have the choice to whether or not to bring a pregnancy to term nation-wide. I'm sure you can identify edge cases where people aren't made aware about contraceptives and birth control due to an isolated community, but the overwhelming majority of the population it's correct to say that becoming a parent is a choice. This advice that if if someone doesn't want to deal with the responsibilities of having children, then don't have children isn't going to result in the whole country's birth rate plummeting to zero. Demographic choices like these in a country of hundreds of millions don't change overnight. It'll be a continuation of the trend of developed countries' dropping birth rates. Humanity isn't in any danger of dying out [1]. While people of working age do support retirees, the idea that increasing population is an unqualified net good for society is a much more dubious proposal. Sustaining another human's life takes a lot of energy, on the order of hundreds of thousands of calories per day most of it from fossil fuels. Experiencing a declining population creates pressure to support retirees, but it's something Japan and European countries have been doing for a while now. The rest of your comments seem to paint a very negative set of assumptions about childless people: > ..there is no one to take care of us in our old age as our species dies out, having promoted the idea "You only live once and you should live for today and just indulge selfishly." You assume that childless people are indulgent and live selfishly because...? Because they made different life decisions, you assume they selfish and indulgent? > unless you want to follow up this policy with "Let's just start executing people who fall ill with anything that could require long term convalescence and, also, start executing people when they hit a certain age so we don't have to deal with the frailty of old age." > (No, I am not being extremist. I'm really not.) Is this a joke? Because I fail to see how anyone can convince themselves that this isn't an extremist view. You're literally trying to equate childlessness with extermination of the elderly, and execution of people with illnesses. 1. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Estimated-human-population-growth-from-10-000-BC-until-year-2050-Population-grew-from_fig2_313251383 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Estimated-human-populati...
- jumelles 6y agoIt's very strange that your viewpoint doesn't seem to acknowledge even the concept of abortion. Especially if we're talking about something as awful as rape.