5 ms·
> Are the vendors going to give back your $1M? No they are not. Are they going to fix the appliance? Maybe. This means that the organizations never learn plain
by sneak 6y ago
> Are the vendors going to give back your $1M? No they are not. Are they going to fix the appliance? Maybe.
This means that the organizations never learn plainly which of their purchases were jank and which were not, and do not improve their decision-making over time.
I think this disables/obscures an important market feedback mechanism. If a vendor sells you expensive crap with the implied promise that it is forward compatible/spec compliant, and the version field increments and, it turns out, your box isn't and breaks, it's likely to damage the reputation of the vendor (and perhaps the person within the organization that bought the janky device).
The game is an iterated one. Rewarding the not-diligent vendor/purchaser with diligent effort on the part of client software development teams does three things, none of which are desirable:
1. it shields shitty vendors from the market consequences of selling crap.
2. it shields shitty customers from the business consequences of buying crap.
3. it massively raises the barrier to entry for someone who wants to develop good and widely-accepted client software, keeping it in the realm of basically only a few large multinationals, none of whom really give a fuck about your privacy.
It's bad for everyone.
- tialaramex 6y agoI think you've drunk too much Free Market kool aid and have begun to mistake a mere means for an end to itself. We're not trying to make the market set prices efficiently, we're trying to make the Network better, an efficient market is exciting for prophets of the dismal science, a Network that works better is good for all the actual people.
- sneak 6y agoThe network is better in the long run if people are more careful about which vendors they choose and vendors are disincentivized to ship broken shit.