3 ms·
That's a shortsighted and very programmer-centric view of what a filesystem is. Increasingly we are seeing a bifurcation between the kind of filesystems develo
by kccqzy 6y ago
That's a shortsighted and very programmer-centric view of what a filesystem is.
Increasingly we are seeing a bifurcation between the kind of filesystems developers use for programming (POSIX style) and the kind of "filesystems" being exposed to end users. I put the word in quotes because they are not thought of as filesystems by its traditional definition. But it's a reality that many users now think of these siloed-by-app systems as the real filesystem.
The iOS menu mentioned by GP is a great example because that's what's user facing, not the developer-facing one like /private/var/mobile/Containers/blah-blah-blah. Today even many developers won't have to deal with POSIX-style filesystems that often, since they generally write code to store structured data in a database (sqlite on mobile, more sophisticated ones on the server side) while large blobs are stored in services like S3, making the idea of a POSIX filesystem quaint.
My own prediction is that POSIX filesystems in another decade or so will be like assembly language today: it's still there, still being taught and learned, but users and a majority of developers won't need to know about it.
- boogies 6y agoI think it’s very typical of very casual and exploitable users to have product names deeply connected with a certain activity — eg. using Google or Zoom as verbs — and “cloud” storage companies would like them to think of their brand name as the main storage area on their devices (and certainly not as just rented space on normal drives in a big room full of someone else’s computers), and I think they are and will be successful, and these users won’t think of them with generic terms like “filesystem”.
- _jal 6y agoCasual users' confusion about the presentation of technical details is a different conversation. This one is about actual filesystems. It may well be that end users are abstracted away from their filesystems, but you seem to assume both that 'The Cloud' is the natural end-state of systems evolution and that everyone comes along for the ride. I don't think either of those are true.
- anthk 6y agoPalm tried what you said. Now Palm is dead.