23 ms·
I enjoy nostalgia as much as anyone, but there's no real need today. While attractive, this was a particularly atrocious line of OS in the reliability departme
by mixmastamyk 6y ago
I enjoy nostalgia as much as anyone, but there's no real need today. While attractive, this was a particularly atrocious line of OS in the reliability department.
The mind boggles at using it in a mission-critical environment and speaks to how dire and ridiculous the situation was in the late 90s due to Microsoft shenanigans and competitor blunders. When folks say to forgive MS now they've changed, perhaps, but point to this post so the damage is not forgotten.
Depending on budget one of these paths should be taken:
- Twenty year-old hardware is basically free at this point and can run a version of NT. Security/cost continues to be an issue however.
- Xubuntu or similar + (Wine || DOS/VirtualBox) would be more reliable and secure. If an unmaintained driver is a requirement, this might be the best choice.
- FreeDOS exists and is pretty good, for the truly ancient.
- React OS is a thing as well and there's a decent chance it can run older software.
Personally, I'd pick a Xubuntu or Ubuntu Mate LTS and whip up a native GUI in a robust language with plenty tests to replace such equipment.
- Funes- 6y agoI don't think Ubuntu or any of its variants--or "flavors"--are really well-suited for old machines. I find them to be very "bloated", as it were. I'd pick a bare-bones, basic installation of Arch/Artix and go upwards from there, probably using i3 as the window manager, too.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThat may have made sense twenty years ago, but more time has passed that perhaps realized. They're quite light when no unneeded apps are installed, and time is money, as they say. Spending a lot of time fiddling is a cost that is not going to help a no-revenue maintenance project like this succeed. Perhaps a light CentOS variant would be better as they tend to have longer support windows.
- def_true_false 6y agoKDE has decent performance these days. Then again, if one goes out of their way to avoid the default DE, it stands to reason they might want to avoid the distro and its questionable choices entirely.
- the_pwner224 6y agoThis is immediately obvious if you install them in a virtual machine - even on the latest fast hardware Ubuntu and Fedora both lag pretty hard. Even Xubuntu is pretty slow. I use a VM for Zoom and MS Teams, so after some time dealing with it I finally gave up and installed Arch Linux with a minimal Openbox configuration. The VM gets to the desktop within a few seconds with autologin and automatic X starting, and is lighting fast (zoom and teams still a bit slow but everything else is instant). I set the Openbox menu to only contain the items I need - Zoom, unofficial teams-for-linux, v4l2 (webcam) test&configuration utility, pavucontrol (volume control), SimpleScreenRecorder, Thunar (file explorer) with my shared folder to get recordings out of the VM, and a shortcut to a .txt with my Zoom meeting IDs and passwords (Mousepad as the editor). It'd be nice to make a compact disk image from this and distribute it, but there are some machine-specific things that need to be configured for the VM - not hard, but you can't make it a zero-configuration download-and-run type thing (shared folders, selecting USB passthrough for webcam, configuring resource allocation to the vm, etc.). Installing Arch takes about 10 minutes and installing+configuring all the GUI software takes maybe 60 minutes more. Of course part of the slowness in VMs is due to not having fast graphics which GNOME etc. rely on, but again Xubuntu is pretty slow too, and if you install a GNOME distro on bare metal it still lags pretty often. Plus the boot times for Ubuntu & Fedora are also really high in the VM.
- fomine3 6y agoGNOME's slower performance in VM due to lack of HW accel is problem, why Red Hat decided to drop support other WMs?
- mixmastamyk 6y agoSuper fast startup is not a requirement for this application. Also, I think you are overstating the case with the exception of Gnome 3. It just had a big performance regression fixed. Mate and xfce never suffered from it.
- barbs 6y agoYou might be correct in general, but if it has worked well enough and reliably for the past 20 years, why fix it?
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIt will have to be replaced sooner or later. Why not start early and take time, rather react poorly at higher cost to an emergency?
- mixmastamyk 6y ago^than
- barbs 6y agoWill it?
- mixmastamyk 6y agoAre you under the impression computer systems survive unmaintained indefinitely?
- barbs 6y agoSometimes, yeah, they do
- dmitriid 6y ago> The mind boggles at using it in a mission-critical environment and speaks to how dire and ridiculous the situation was in the late 90s due to Microsoft shenanigans and competitor blunders. Or due to the fact that Win95 was actually a very good user-friendly graphical operating system. There were very few that could really compete. Despite all the shenanigans. > Depending on budget one of these paths should be taken: You just mentioned mission-critical systems in the previous paragraph. None of the paths are valid upgrade paths. Especially not if you want to "whip up a native GUI with a requirement for un unmaintained driver". Just reverse-engineering the driver for a train would be a major undertaking. And that's before you try to add an UI on top of that.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoNot necessarily. I gave a range of options on purpose, depending on budget and safety reqs I don’t have access to. Also for desktops left behind for whatever reason. You may be over thinking it.