3 ms·
There's some important distinctions that come up with every single time we talk about Chinese apps, so I want to lay them out (disclosure: American). And can we
by godelski 6y ago
There's some important distinctions that come up with every single time we talk about Chinese apps, so I want to lay them out (disclosure: American). And can we just stop going through this literally every single time?
1) FAANG does this too:
- I complain about that and so do many others here. Expect these people to also be upset about WeChat and TikTok. Anything else would be hypocritical. It is the same fight. We know. Stop the whataboutism.
- While FAANG often willingly shares data with the government and the many eyes, it is not unfettered. We've been making gains in the privacy regime and some of these companies are starting to say no (i.e. come back with a warrant).
- There is a difference, although slight (but meaningful), between a distribution of companies having my data vs a centralized body that controls all regulation.
2) They're just going after China:
- There's a difference between your own government having your data and a foreign government. Especially when tensions are escalating between them.
- See above where gov doesn't have unfettered access (not true in China).
- We're complaining about FAANG too, it just isn't relevant in a conversation about TikTok and WeChat and derails the conversation with whataboutism.
3) What about xyz app?
- Same reason we complain about Facebook over other apps. Scale matters. Of course we're going after the app with a billion users before we go for an app with 100k users.
4) Zuckerberg just wants to make a WeChat (super app) alternative:
- See 1.1. I'll complain about that too. Wouldn't touch it with a ten foot poll. No way.
5) Something about government involvement ipso facto bias.
- If you aren't looking for bias in every source that you read, what are you doing? Read, analyze, internalize. Every source has a bias. They define specific interests. Bias does not mean false. It is not a coup de ta. Yes, we should be aware, but people aren't bringing it up for the same reason we don't bring it up in literally every conversation: because we're aware and it often doesn't serve as a meaningful contribution to the discussion.
Can we actually discuss the article now?