5 ms·
>> there has been no previous contact with the company Every law student is given that speech. There used to be a specific scam targeting new lawyers. When a
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> there has been no previous contact with the company
Every law student is given that speech. There used to be a specific scam targeting new lawyers. When a new law office was setup it would be sent books and lawyer-related equipment, along with a bill for payment. The scammers hoped the bill would just be paid without further inquiry. So law students are now warned and told that they can keep such "gifts".
But that isn't how the real world works. Who here doesn't have any previous contact with amazon? What if the package contains something very illegal (drugs etc) and the police are watching it? That will be a fun afternoon. Or what if your new address, previously perhaps a vacant house, is being used by someone buying illegal stuff? Yesterday he would pick it up from the door of an empty house. Today the package is inside the house. Unrequested deliveries should not be treated lightly.
- userbinator 6y agoObviously if it's something you don't want, you don't have to keep it.
- lostgame 6y agoI have never and likely will never register for an Amazon account. When parcels show up mistakenly (and they do!) with that 'Prime' label I know right away I didn't have anything to do with me. :3 There's a lot of reasons I will never register for an Amazon account; the majority of which are directly related to the treatment of their employees, and if it wasn't that, it would be Amazon's complete unwillingness to do something about the litany of fake products filling it's virtual shelves, or the fake reviews that make it so we can't differentiate between the real product and fake. I hardly believe I am the only person on Hacker News to have also held out. Seeing Bezo's net value vs. what employees are paid is enough to make it worth going down the road and paying a couple dollars extra. I remember when COVID first broke out and Amazon refused to cover even sanitizer or masks for their employees, much less any extra compensation for volunteering to help keep the world together in a massive disaster. Amazon epitomizes the 'slavery with extra steps' phrase from Rick and Morty, and additionally epitomizes the truly horrific nature of inequality of wealth.
- jfk13 6y ago> When parcels show up [...] with that 'Prime' label Alternatively, it could be that you ordered the product from another seller, e.g. on eBay, who is then using their Amazon Prime subscription as a fulfilment mechanism. (A form of drop-shipping.)
- jameshart 6y agoYou might want to reconsider your approach to those amazon boxes... 1) Amazon puts 'Prime' labelling on all their parcels, not just ones shipped to Prime members 2) People use Amazon as a way to send people gifts! If I know your address, I could order you something I think you might like from Amazon. They'll even giftwrap it and put in a thoughtful note from me! You don't need an account for that to happen. 3) Because of the ubiquity of Amazon, the world is full of reused Amazon Prime labelled boxes. Maybe your ebay seller is shipping you something in a previously-bought-from-Amazon box.
- Fjolsvith 6y ago> the litany of fake products filling it's virtual shelves Have only had one purchase not be what I expected (over 10 years) and that was quickly returned for a refund. Amazon employees are not slaves. They can find employment elsewhere. For you to equate them to slaves is so racist that it doesn't belong on HN.
- inglor_cz 6y agoHere in the Czech Republic the wages at Amazon aren't so bad. Unlike many other unqualified jobs, they still attract Czech employees and do not have to import cheaper workforce from abroad (Ukraine, Mongolia, Balkan states). What people find hard to adjust to is the company culture, basically you are a human robot.
- lostgame 6y agoRick and Morty has another one for that, just YouTube 'you pass butter'.
- ericmay 6y agoNot sure why previous contact with a company matters? Here's what the U.S. Federal Trade Commission says about receiving packages you didn't order [1]: "What do you do when you receive merchandise that you didn’t order? According to the Federal Trade Commission, you don’t have to pay for it. Federal laws prohibit mailing unordered merchandise to consumers and then demanding payment." There is obvious nuance here [2]. Maybe receiving "stolen property" for example. But if the item is addressed to you, and you didn't order it, I think you're in the clear, and certainly nobody can demand payment and enforce it. -edit- This reminds me of the scams in Europe where someone will grab your hand and put a bracelet on or put a flower in your hair or something and demand payment. I've been in this scenario. All you have to do is walk away or just throw the merchandise on the ground. They'll change their tune quickly. [1] https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0181-unordered-merchandise https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0181-unordered-merchan... [2] I'm not a lawyer.
- tgb 6y agoTechnically that doesn't say whether you can keep the goods, just whether you can be made to pay for them.
- ericmay 6y agoTake a look at the link. But to answer this point: “ No. If you receive merchandise that you didn’t order, you have a legal right to keep it as a free gift.”
- sandworm101 6y agoThere are different rules for people who have ongoing relationships with companies, mostly so that one party doesn't profit from an obvious mistake. For instance, say you are a store that orders a 1/2 pallet of coke products every week. Then one week the driver leaves a full pallet by accident. Do you get that extra pallet for free? What if you forget to place the order, but the company for whatever reason sends the usual 1/2 pallet anyway? Should you have to pay for that delivery if you use it? These preexisting relationships create situations different than the mystery package on the doorstep.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI question the validity of this advice (and Citizen's Advice's advice) in the UK. If you're sent something with a bill for payment then it seems to me that you are not entitled to keep it at all because the bill indicates that they are not gifting the items to you but expect payment for them. I.e. property rights have not been transferred. You can of course keep the items and wait until being asked for them back (and then you obviously don't have to pay for sending them back) but that does not mean that you can keep them as in "they are yours to keep". According to another comment it seems indeed fine to keep these unordered items in the US by Federal Law, but I don't think this is the case in the UK unless the intent is clear (and, for example, a bill clearly indicates what the intention is). Edit: Ah, I stand corrected. There is indeed a law similar to the US's one in the UK: The Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 "(4) In the case of an unsolicited supply of goods, the consumer may, as between the consumer and the trader, use, deal with or dispose of the goods as if they were an unconditional gift to the consumer.”." [1] [1] https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2013/3134/regulation/39/made https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2013/3134/regulation/39/...
- Sysosmaster 6y agoIf the U.K. properly implemented the European directives, if a company sends you something without you requesting it (e.a. Unsolicited) than it’s legally a gift. Even if they add a bill (it’s unsolicited after all). If they request it back you may send it back with property rights reverting to them (it’s a gift again) but legally there is no way to enforce it nor is there a request to get anything back For it (Ea. Money or other credit) If there is no contract (Ea a purchase request/ intend) than anything a company Can send to a consumer is a gift.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> If there is no contract (Ea a purchase request/ intend) than anything a company Can send to a consumer is a gift. I understand that there are restrictions to unsolicited goods, perhaps even a ban. But an absence of contract does not make something a gift. Whether something is a gift or an offer to purchase or anything else depends on the facts, it's not implied. So either there is a statute that says this case is legally treated as a gift or the item remain the property of the sender until the intention is clear. Edit: There is indeed a law that makes it a gift (from EU Directive you mention, perhaps). See my previous comment above. This is indeed required because as explained it cannot be implied.
- reaperducer 6y agoWhen a new law office was setup it would be sent books and lawyer-related equipment, along with a bill for payment Not just law offices. EVERY office I ever worked in pre-internet had to deal with this. Almost always it was toner for the copier. Some of the more clever scammers would call an office and say, "I'm Bill from the copier company. Can you tell me what model of copier we have over there? Oh, and what was your name again?" And when the office drone replied, the scammer would send out hundreds of dollars worth of toner and other supplies, plus an invoice for thousands of dollars, and say that it was authorized, by name, by the person who answered the phone.
- xwdv 6y agoI’m not sure if my experience is unique, but I get so many packages from amazon so often that I don’t even bother looking too closely at the box or even have a clue which delivery might be inside. Someone could easily drop a package at my doorstep and I’ll pick it up and put it in my house without any awareness. Sometimes those packages will go for a while without being opened too, until I realize I need something I ordered. I could easily be holding a brick of cocaine for a while and not know.
- eru 6y ago> But that isn't how the real world works. Who here doesn't have any previous contact with amazon? What if the package contains something very illegal (drugs etc) and the police are watching it? That reminds me of a similar scenario: a few years ago the UK enacted a new law (or was about to?) that forced people to decrypt any data they had if the courts asked them to. Burden of proof that they don't have the cryptographic keys was on the person in possession of that data. So some people who were against this law considered sending some hard disk that might or might not contain encrypted child porn and similar nasties on hard disks to the relevant ministers addresses, report them for possession of dangerous data to the police, and then wish them good luck proving they don't have the keys. (Or, more likely: walking back on the law.)