4 ms·
Unfortunately, history tells us that almost all major gains in freedom come, at one point, through violent conflict/sacrifice. If one side (an authoritarian op
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
Unfortunately, history tells us that almost all major gains in freedom come, at one point, through violent conflict/sacrifice.
If one side (an authoritarian oppressor) is not afraid to use violence, and the other is prevented from using any response, the oppressor will win. This is why major changes usually require civil war.
This is also why authoritarians definitely do not want their population to have access to weapons. (The U.S. couldn’t even control Afghan farmers with guns...)
- perfunctory 6y agoMajor changes sometimes involve civil war, not usually. Statistically non-violent rebellions are more successful than the violent ones. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YJSehRlU34w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YJSehRlU34w
- Kinrany 6y ago> Statistically non-violent rebellions are more successful than the violent ones. Countries that are already mostly democratic don't need violent rebellions?
- walshemj 6y agoEven the glorious revolution of 1688 wasn't as bloodless as many people think and still has repercussions today in NI
- diego_moita 6y ago> Unfortunately, history tells us that almost all major gains in freedom come, at one point, through violent conflict/sacrifice. No, it doesn't. Recent history tells us exactly the opposite: 1) Rise of democracy in Latin America in the 70s and 80s (Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, Chile, Brazil) 2) Collapse of communism on Eastern Europe in the 80s and 90s. 3) Democracy in Eastern Asia in the 80s (Indonesia, Korea, Philippines, Pakistan). 4) Nigeria, Spain, Greece These were achieved through pacific means. The cases of dictatorships that became democracies through violence are very few: Portugal, Romania... Prior history of violent conflict is precisely what led to dictatorships hardening (leftist guerrilla groups in Argentina, Chile, Brazil and Uruguay, tentative coup in Indonesia, etc.) Also, violent reaction against dictatorships quite often leads to other dictatorships (e.g.: Nicaragua, Cuba, Iran). Edit: again, my point is that violent reaction against oppressive regimes is foolish and leads to the opposite of freedom. Violence is the authoritarians' favorite game because it provides them an excuse to do what they do best: brutal repression. You are already loosing when you play their preferred game.
- Const-me 6y ago> Collapse of communism on Eastern Europe in the 80s and 90s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yugoslav_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yugoslav_Wars 130000 dead https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanian_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanian_Revolution 1000 dead
- diego_moita 6y agoThe Yugoslav wars were mostly ethnic conflicts that happened after the collapse of communism, not exactly a democratic revolution. I concede in Romania, but that is an atypical case. The overall case of collapse communism was peacefull: Poland, Hungary, East Germany, Czechozlovakia, Bulgaria, Albania, ...
- trhway 6y agoNo, the way to 1989 wasn't all that peaceful. For example there was the martial law and repressions against "Solidarity" during 198x in Poland. And you forgot the 1968. The resolve of the East Europeans in 1989 was pretty clear that if USSR brings in tanks the people will continue to stand up even in the face of the tanks, and it will be 1968 all over the place. The 1968 provided credibility to that. Thus the USSR and the regimes supported by it backed finally down.
- diego_moita 6y agoWe're falling into splitting straws on semantics here. All repressive regimes repress, that's what makes them authoritarian. But a violent and successful reaction by the opposing/democratic forces implying a large number of deaths is actually quite rare. This is my point.
- bonzini 6y agoIt was peaceful on the oppressed side. There's a reason why the Czech revolution of 1989 is called 'the velvet revolution'.
- 6y ago
- vvpan 6y agoI think this is a very disputable point. I've seen studies supporting both. For example here is study attesting to the opposite of your point: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-science-review/article/agenda-seeding-how-1960s-black-protests-moved-elites-public-opinion-and-voting/136610C8C040C3D92F041BB2EFC3034C https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-s...
- Taek 6y agoA key point that people often miss is that an armed population is extremely difficult to control even if the oppressor has vastly superior equipment and training. The citizenry has the advantage of living there all the time, of being able to hide in the buildings (their own homes), of overwhelming numbers, and of the fact that short of full genocide the oppressor actually needs some compliance from the oppressed to achieve their objectives. Logistically, it is an absolute nightmare to invade a city of 25% armed and trained citizens versus invading a city that is 1% armed and trained citizens. Access to drones and missiles and tanks doesn't help nearly as much as many people would believe.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoAmerica will never be invaded (never being heat death of sun), it could only devolve into civil war if education levels get low enough...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]