4 ms·
It's easier to extra judicially grab at least non citizens from Sweden. Sweden has assisted the US before in breaking their own laws to help black bag their re
by monocasa 6y ago
It's easier to extra judicially grab at least non citizens from Sweden.
Sweden has assisted the US before in breaking their own laws to help black bag their residents. The UK instead makes you bounce through their whole court system, not wanting to be overruled by one of their former colonies.
- vermilingua 6y agoI saw someone comment a while ago that Brexit effectively demotes the UK to being a colony of the US through trade dependence once they’re cut off from their special access to Europe. Does this not effectively prove that? The US has made a decision, and like a good vassal the UK judiciary is delivering Assange to them.
- monocasa 6y agoThere's a fairly public trial now though, and this is what the US was trying to avoid with the Sweden route. Sweden has provided it's own police to assist CIA operatives in black bagging it's own residents against it's own laws and process and sent them to an Egyptian prison clearly to be tortured and then blamed it all on a dead politician. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_and_Muhammad_al-Zery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_an...
- ben_w 6y agoI have the impression that the UK government genuinely (and incorrectly) believes itself to be in a position of strength, at least for now. To the extent that it is now sycophantic towards the USA, it already was — the “special relationship” meme in UK politics has been around for a long time.
- Chris2048 6y agoIt doesn't prove the UK are any more protected while part of the EU - the EU has American trade dependence too.
- foldr 6y ago>It's easier to extra judicially grab at least non citizens from Sweden. I see this repeated all over the place as if it were an obviously established fact, but there is no reason to think that this is true. Extrajudicial actions and their consequences are inherently unpredictable. It's pure speculation to say that it would have been easier to do it from Sweden than from the UK. In any case, this particular line of Assange apologism is rather obviously out of date, since we see that the US can (in all likelihood) quite easily extradite him now that he's out of the embassy, and thus has no reason to use extrajudicial means.
- monocasa 6y ago> I see this repeated all over the place as if it were an obviously established fact, but there is no reason to think that this is true. Extrajudicial actions and their consequences are inherently unpredictable. It's pure speculation to say that it would have been easier to do it from Sweden than from the UK. The proof is an empirical one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_and_Muhammad_al-Zery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_an... > In any case, this particular line of Assange apologism is rather obviously out of date, since we see that the US can (in all likelihood) quite easily extradite him now that he's out of the embassy, and thus has no reason to use extrajudicial means. If they went the Sweden route, they wouldn't have needed this public trial that we're all commenting on, and he'd already be in US custody.
- foldr 6y agoYou have a strange idea of "proof". The fact that something happened in Sweden once is hardly proof that it could not happen in the UK. By the way, you might want to look at the "aftermath" section of that Wikipedia article. It's far from clear to me that the US wants to avoid a public trial. It's not as if Assange is particularly popular these days.
- monocasa 6y ago> You have a strange idea of "proof". The fact that something happened in Sweden once is hardly proof that it could not happen in the UK. Except the UK has a very clear no extraordinary rendition policy, and even the idea that UK airports had been used as a refueling stop for rendition flights was a minor scandal in the UK. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/6736227.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/6736227.stm Meanwhile Sweden has broken it's own laws to assist the US in black bagging it's own residents. > By the way, you might want to look at the "aftermath" section of that Wikipedia article. Can you be more specific? My reading is that Sweden found it's own actions to be illegal, paid out a settlement to those whose genitals were electro shocked in an Egyptian prision, but no Swedes faced any real consequences. > It's far from clear to me that the US wants to avoid a public trial. It's not as if Assange is particularly popular these days. And yet even this article you're commenting on goes into the large amount of work going on by the US government to remove observers, including Amnesty International, from the proceedings.
- notahacker 6y agoThe problem with this theory is that if someone wanted to extra-judicially grab Assange at the time it would have been easier to do this without going through a convoluted process to charge them with a totally unrelated and arguably more serious offence in Sweden. He was living there, and his address wasn't a secret. The UK's record on unlawful rendition flights (at America's behest and otherwise) is also not good and our extradition treaty with the US very one-sided; though there was a reasonable possibility its courts might have stymied a European Arrest Warrant for something his lawyers argued wasn't equivalent to a charge and wasn't equivalent to the crimes in English law...
- monocasa 6y ago> The problem with this theory is that if someone wanted to extra-judicially grab Assange at the time it would have been easier to do this without going through a convoluted process to charge them with a totally unrelated and arguably more serious offence in Sweden. He was living there, and his address wasn't a secret. The Iraq release from Manning's leak occurred after he left Sweden. Getting him back onto Swedish soil would have been the first step. > The UK's record on unlawful rendition flights (at America's behest and otherwise) is also not good The UK has never allowed rendition from the British isles, and certainly would not allow a former colony to subvert their court system.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dane-pgp 6y ago> The UK has never allowed rendition from the British isles Rendition of residents of the British isles, at least.
- notahacker 6y ago> The Iraq release from Manning's leak occurred after he left Sweden. Getting him back onto Swedish soil would have been the first step. Assange lived happily on Swedish soil for ages, apparently without any particular fear of unlawful rendition. He voluntarily attended a police station regarding sex offence allegations, his lawyer had ongoing discourse with the prosecutor regarding the reopening of the case, and he was still happy to continue live in Sweden. He then left the country when they informed his lawyer they did want to charge him. I'm not sure the fact the US wasn't even aware of the Iraq release at the time undermines my observation that this behaviour looks more like somebody seeking to avoid facing sex offences charges in court than unlawful abduction. And likewise that Swedish actions look like a slow motion bureaucratic response to sex offence allegations that would have been tricky to prosecute and not a dastardly plot to get him to the US. The fact the US has subsequently chosen to actually open a case against him based on something they didn't even know about at the time doesn't really change that (although FWIW I think it's politically unwise for them to bother) > The UK has never allowed rendition from the British isles, and certainly would not allow a former colony to subvert their court system. Apart from British soil having been a stopping point for CIA rendition flights and its enthusiastic cooperation with US schemes overseas, the UK has also routinely bent its own law to deport asylum seekers before their appeals are completed in manner not dissimilar to the Swedish cases which keep getting cited. (The same Home Secretary that was happy to push the unlawful 'deport first, appeal later' policy was, ironically, also the only thing stopping Gary McKinnon from being legally deported to the US after exhausting every single appeal, because our court system isn't that fussed that the US might be overzealous with national security related hacking prosecutions. But I doubt Assange had much hope of helpful intervention from her...)
- dragonwriter 6y ago> It's easier to extra judicially grab at least non citizens from Sweden. Even if that were the case, that's not the right comparison. The comparison has to be of the combination of extradition to Sweden plus rendition from Sweden vs. the easier of extradition or rendition from the UK. Since, after all, he was already in the UK, not in some indeterminate state that the US could collapse to either Sweden or the UK at its preference with no effort.
- monocasa 6y agoExtradition and rendition aren't equivalent though. In the rendition case, you avoid the possibility of airing all sorts of dirty laundry in a foreign court, so it makes sense that they'd pursue that for as long as they could, and once that was not an option pursue extradition while heavily limiting public access (as they have here).