4 ms·
> I don't understand how purely unitary evolution can explain this. Does it? What's the alternative? Assuming unitary evolution and some fairly common-sense ax
by lmm 6y ago
> I don't understand how purely unitary evolution can explain this. Does it?
What's the alternative? Assuming unitary evolution and some fairly common-sense axioms about how we'd expect subjective experience to behave (things like: we never experience being in a branch that has amplitude zero; if we experience being in a given branch then we continue to be in that branch), the Born probabilities are the only model anyone's ever come up with for how our subjective experience should go. So what's there to explain?
- millstone 6y agoThe alternative is non-MWI theories, which typically introduce the Born rule via new axioms. Regarding what's to explain, it's quantum randomness (which distills the Born rule objection). Our subjective experience is that we see spin-down 1/3rd of the time, and our theories say the result is otherwise impossible to predict, even in principle. But a deterministic theory cannot produce a random outcome, even a subjective one.
- lmm 6y ago> Our subjective experience is that we see spin-down 1/3rd of the time, and our theories say the result is otherwise impossible to predict, even in principle. But a deterministic theory cannot produce a random outcome, even a subjective one. Whyever not? What else would you expect the subjective experience of being in a state like 1/sqrt(3)|x> + 2/sqrt(3)|y> to be like?
- Orlanthai 6y agoThere's a continuous infinity of alternate basis expansions. There's no reason to think you'd experience along that particular basis.
- lmm 6y agoWhat would you expect "experiencing along those other bases" to look like? If you expand along a different basis you just get something like: half a chance of experiencing (1/sqrt(3)|x> + 2/sqrt(3)|y>), and half a chance of experiencing (1/sqrt(3)|x> + 2/sqrt(3)|y>), so it amounts to the same thing.
- Orlanthai 6y agoThose are the same states so I'm not sure what you mean. The point is that there is no reason to select out any particular basis over another. You can't just retreat into "well this is the only basis I can experience" because the human sensory apparatus would be able to select out a range of bases in a full unitary account and also the ambiguity of basis decomposition means you can't perform conditioning which we do all the time in experiments.
- lmm 6y ago> Those are the same states so I'm not sure what you mean. I mean that if you decompose along a different basis than experiencing x/experiencing y, you just get an ensemble of states each of which is a superposition of experiencing x and experiencing y. So you end up with the same thing. It's like looking at an entangled state (because that's exactly what it is) - if we have a two-particle state like 1/sqrt(2)(|x>|x> + |y>|y>), that behaves like the first particle being in |x> and experiencing the other particle being in |x>, or being in |y> and experiencing the other particle being in |y>, and it might look like that's an artifact of this particular basis decomposition, but it actually isn't - the structure of the wavefunction is that it divides cleanly into those two branches, and that's true in any basis. > You can't just retreat into "well this is the only basis I can experience" because the human sensory apparatus would be able to select out a range of bases in a full unitary account A system that's freely interacting will become entangled; whatever we consider ourself is constantly interacting with the rest of ourself, almost by definition. > also the ambiguity of basis decomposition means you can't perform conditioning which we do all the time in experiments. Of course you can, and it works exactly the way you'd expect - we already do experiments where some isolated apparatus inside the experiment does something if it detects one thing and something else if it detects something else. Choice of basis is a tool for understanding the wavefunction, not a physically real thing.
- Orlanthai 6y agoSee my reply above. You're just declaring we only experience Schmidt bases for no particular reason. Where are you getting this "clear connection" between experience and the decomposition in one particular basis. Do you have a reference?
- Orlanthai 6y agoDerivations like that don't work, you've just declared it by fiat but there's no such proof that is known to work.
- lmm 6y agoThere's no proof that it's the only possible way - but no-one's ever been able to come up with a concrete alternative.
- Orlanthai 6y agoThere are other alternatives such as the derivation of quantum theory within the GPT framework and many other axiomatic derivations. I've never seen the Born rule derived from unitary evolution and axioms for how subjective experience should work, so I don't even see this as one of the ways.