3 ms·
A key difference between bangladesh and the US is that the white majority in the US is not indigenous but is the outcome of a colonial project in which the indi
by anigbrowl 6y ago
A key difference between bangladesh and the US is that the white majority in the US is not indigenous but is the outcome of a colonial project in which the indigenous population has already been marginalized. Far right opposition to immigration is rooted in a concept of native identity that requires the conceptual erasure of prior indigenous populations to a safe historical distance. the proponents of such policy are in my experience deeply antagonistic to native Americans in the here and now on both a personal and policy level.
But the left has completely lost its marbles in treating any opposition to immigration (or even total opposition to immigration) as an illegitimate fringe idea as opposed to a policy option. That completely fails to understand what a country is.
But you're relying on a definition of 'country' that's rooted in ethnic essentialism, something very different from the nominal values o which the US was founded. I get that you're* arguing in favor of a cultural rather than ethnic identity, which is a very nice idea; but it overlooks the fact that the more hardline someone's 'cultural identitarian' position, the more likely it is to be a proxy for European ethnic identity that turns out to exclude non-white (eg ask a European identitarian about Romani people and see what sort of reaction you get).
It seems to me that there are some glaring contradictions in the broad conservative ruralism which you're articulating which don't stand up well to closer examination.
- rayiner 6y ago> A key difference between bangladesh and the US is that the white majority in the US is not indigenous but is the outcome of a colonial project in which the indigenous population has already been marginalized. That’s not a difference. Like many (most?) countries, Bangladesh is the product of multiple waves of colonization. There are a small number of indigenous people in Bangladesh (mainly Buddhists living in the hill tracts). This is true of say England as well. > Far right opposition to immigration is rooted in a concept of native identity that requires the conceptual erasure of prior indigenous populations to a safe historical distance. Opposition to immigration isn’t a “far right” concept. Bangladeshis don’t consider themselves less entitled to their country just because a thousand years ago their ancestors replaced some other people who used to live there. The country that exists today—its language, political institutions, etc.—is almost entirely the product of the colonizers. (By that I mean the waves of people who replaced the original inhabitants of Bangladesh.) I’m pretty sure the Japanese and Chinese feel the same way. > But you're relying on a definition of 'country' that's rooted in ethnic essentialism, something very different from the nominal values o which the US was founded. As I observed above, the US is a special case, because of its very recent immigration history. But I took your point about “fringe” views to sweep more broadly than the United States. What about say Germany, which even today is 80% ethnic German. Why are they entitled to a country of their own any less than Bangladeshis? There may be good reasons for them to accept immigration as a policy matter. And if they do accept immigrants, they should try to integrate them and treat them respectfully, etc. But it’s a perfectly valid position to say they want to preserve the essential character of the country as German. If you tried to argue otherwise to a typical Bangladeshi, or Chinese or Japanese, or Korean person, most would look at you like you’ve grown a second head. > I get that you're* arguing in favor of a cultural rather than ethnic identity, which is a very nice idea; but it overlooks the fact that the more hardline someone's 'cultural identitarian' position, the more likely it is to be a proxy for European ethnic identity that turns out to exclude non-white (eg ask a European identitarian about Romani people and see what sort of reaction you get). I think in most countries, at least in Asia or Africa, nobody sees anything wrong with maintaining a country along ethnic identity lines, insofar as they would strongly oppose becoming ethnic minorities in their own countries. Most European countries are homogenous enough where it doesn’t seem illegitimate to me if they felt the same way. The United States is an odd duck, because no ethnicity makes up more than about 10-15% of the population. But that’s why populism in the US is happening more along rural/urban divides.
- anigbrowl 6y agoC'mon Rayiner, it's not like Bangladesh is mostly populated by Europeans. As you said yourself: And if Bangladeshis were on the verge of becoming an ethnic minority in Bangladesh, political cataclysm would result. To turn around and say the real Bangledeshis only remain in the hill tracts so contradicts your previous argument that I see little point in reading further; I'm not going to waste time on sophistry. I'm really disappointed in the direction of this conversation.