3 ms·
"In a seminal 2004 essay in Wired titled "The Long Tail," journalist Chris Anderson argued that digital culture would help niche music, books, and movies thrive
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
"In a seminal 2004 essay in Wired titled "The Long Tail," journalist Chris Anderson argued that digital culture would help niche music, books, and movies thrive. With fewer gatekeepers and more avenues to find likeminded fans, people would be more likely to indulge their true interests, rather than just accept what was offered by the mainstream."
Nice idea, there is some truth to it based on what we've seen so far, but we can also see how the corporations that control "what was offered by the mainstream" are now controlling (financing) the gatekeepers of the web and/or personal computing device (for lack of a better term). The new gatekeepers have become entrenched thanks to centralisation, lock-in and using the system itself as the world's most powerful hype machine, or "network effects".
The entertainment industry has gatekeepers, so too does the web (perhaps even the wider internet) and the personal computing device.
If and when things get tight for the gatekeeper business, they (web gatekeepers) will also control the so-called "long tail". What we are seeing is that it is not the "gatekeeperless" distribution channel many might imagine, as YouTube deletes a seemingly non-commercial video and arguments ensue over rights to "free speech".
The tentacles of these gatekeepers keep reaching out further. No "long tail" seems to be safe from their influence and ultimately their control.
- duxup 6y agoDoesn't the article indicate...the long tail might be true?
- Barrin92 6y agosomewhat but the decline seems relatively small. My intuition is that the dynamics of digital content lower the barrier for new talent to go very quickly to the top, think Billie Eilish and her brother producing an album out of their bedroom, but that the centralisation still means most eyeballs go to the top, maybe that part even got worse given how monotonous viral spread is. I don't think there is much indication that there is a broad shift from the top to the middle. Other mediums like Youtube and Twitch almost exclusively concentrate attention at the top as well, with IIRC two thirds of streamers not even having any viewers.
- Applejinx 6y agoFor income? Oh hell no.
- medymed 6y agoThe long tail of artists that makes the platform more long-tail money with minimal cost is comparatively safe. Especially given that artists/labels do the grunt work of loading everything to the electronic platform and even for them the cost of production and distribution is markedly decreased from several decades ago.
- spiderfarmer 6y agoEven users do the grunt work for them, by discovering and listening to new artists, adding them to playlists and giving them extra data for their algorithms.
- Dumblydorr 6y agoI'd disagree in music. Many of the industry's top musicians started lo-fi in their room or basement, like Lorde or Billie Eilish, or all the garage rock, punk rock, hip hop, etc. Those artists get propelled by mass media, but they were nobodies and had basic equipment. So even in the Poppiest of genres, you have breakout by unheard of people. Then, expanding to folk or jazz or electronic, Spotify allows a measly income and exposure for very obscure, niche players and their small record companies. Power has been widely distributed by Napster, Spotify, and many others. They barely gatekeep these obscure artists, they use algorithms, though they do not share a decent % of profits with artists, IMO.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoBig difference between Napster and Spotify. No gatekeepers with P2P. It is like two friends lending each other LPs, tapes, or CDs. That is how "long tail" music used to spread, pre-Internet