6 ms·
Then maybe the solution is to also have the option turn off animated GIFs and perhaps frequent canvas repaints too; and not simply give up completely! In any c
by userbinator 6y ago
Then maybe the solution is to also have the option turn off animated GIFs and perhaps frequent canvas repaints too; and not simply give up completely!
In any case, just leaving the option alone so at least it has some effect like it did before, would still be better than essentially a full surrender.
- amluto 6y agoHow about restricting the frame rate of all elements until some heuristic determines that the user has interacted with them?
- ehsankia 6y agoRestricting framerate will still download the 100mb GIF. Also, so many parts of websites use gifs and canvas. If you start blocking those, you'll be hiding loading spinners, menus and more. You're adding ton and ton of complexity and going at war after something pretty silly. If a website is abusive and does shitty things, just don't use the website. After some point, it's no longer the browsers job to babysit the web. I completely agreed with autoplaying audio, but blocking video is just not worth it.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoI'd like the option to abort downloading once a gif reaches the first full frame or 1MB. Whichever comes first. Looks like Chrome will never be that browser. Seriously gif is only used because it's autoplay predates widespread abuse of autoplay generally. Now is the time to put an end to it, at least as an option.
- baybal2 6y ago> If a website is abusive and does shitty things, just don't use the website. What do you do if the aforementioned is not done by the website as such, but by some omnipresent, and hard to avoid 3rd party ad net? > After some point, it's no longer the browsers job to babysit the web. I completely agreed with autoplaying audio, but blocking video is just not worth it. Video is by far the heaviest piece of media out there. There is no practical means to reduce its loading time, especially on mobile. It simply cannot be considered an ordinary piece of page content. Lastly, people are sick and tired of video ads, and, particularly, obscene, bombastic, and blinking like no tomorrow ones.
- esperent 6y ago> What do you do if the aforementioned is not done by the website as such, but by some omnipresent, and hard to avoid 3rd party ad net? Use an ad blocker. Since mobile chrome doesn't allow adblocking, this means you will have to choose one of the many other mobile browsers that do.
- baybal2 6y agoThis is not a duty of adblocker. You don't have it to be an ad to bust your data package.
- dwaltrip 6y agoCanvas and gifs could be an opt-in feature on a per-website basis, just like notifications and webcam access.
- ehsankia 6y agoWith that logic, soon every single feature in the browser will have a pop up saying "Do you want to allow losing <img>?", "Do you want to allow use of "cursor css style?", etc.
- toastal 6y agoSVG is smaller in a vast majority of those cases and looks better to boot
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoSVG can have non svg images inside of it. SVG has autoplaying animation possibilities. SVG has JavaScript if you are putting it directly into the body of the page. You can also put anything into SVG with the foreign object element, so also videos. So yes if someone stopped me abusing the users with my autoplaying videos I might decide to abuse them with SVG before these other options.
- toastal 6y agoI didn't think about that. That's depressing.
- Razengan 6y ago> Then maybe the solution is to also have the option turn off animated GIFs Safari actually does that! At least on Big Sur, if you enable the "Reduce Motion" option in Accessibility Preferences, gifs only animate when you hover the pointer over them. Feels a bit odd at first (e.g. on animated Discord emojis) but then it seems like an option that should have been there since forever.
- JadeNB 6y ago> Safari actually does that! At least on Big Sur, if you enable the "Reduce Motion" option in Accessibility Preferences, gifs only animate when you hover the pointer over them. I'm not on Big Sur yet, so I can't check, but it's a shame if that's the only way to animate it, because I might trust OS-curated animations but not random-website-curated animations. It's a browser preference, not necessarily an OS-wide preference. (But I do think that inheriting it is sensible!) As with all things customiseable, Firefox has had this option for a long time. (But look for their Chrome-chasing to lead them to get rid of this option soon ….)
- fiblye 6y agoThis is the common sense solution. And what sites are replacing videos with massive gifs? Buzzfeed-like sites have always been filling their pages with 250 megabytes of gifs. News sites with half a dozen autoplaying videos certainly won't be replacing their videos with multi-gigabyte gif versions. And it seems like detecting a large, constantly repainted canvas would be easy enough.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoI remember implementing some web proxy monitoring a while ago, and I had a whole list of sites I had to ignore because of stuff like this. HN homepage would take a handful of milliseconds to load, but some sites would routinely take 10-20 second to get to the window load. Somebody asked “but what if a user complains that cnn.com is loading too slowly?”, and we all agreed we’d just have to tell them to get in touch with CNN.
- d3nj4l 6y agoAnd if you replace videos with gigabytes of gifs, customers will leave because the gifs take ages to load.
- extropy 6y agoOr complain that their browser is slow/ battery life is abysmal.
- ajmurmann 6y agoI dream of a search engine that heavily penalizes websites with advertisements on it.
- cdmckay 6y agoSeems unlikely given the biggest search engine makes the majority of its money from ads :(
- toper-centage 6y ago
- swiley 6y agoThis is infact a common feature on smaller browsers.
- edoceo 6y agoCould you name them? I want to download.
- mattigames 6y agoI agree with you in principle but is more nuanced than that, lets say an user taps a link they think goes to a gif, according to you there should be a play button over the gif? You would be killing a lot of traffic for that site because that annoys users, or imagine a site with infinite scroll (ala twitter) with funny gifs, should the user have to click each single gif they want to watch? Plus keep in mind the users would save a lot of (maybe costly) bandwidth and battery if they used muted videos instead of GIFS so why use them?
- userbinator 6y agoThat's why it is (or was...) an option, and ideally should be a per-site one.
- edoceo 6y agoBigG couldn't do that (disable other user hostile media) because it would interfere with ads. Now I'm looking for a gif and canvas blocker for FF mobile. Any hints on how to tune uBO?
- madeofpalk 6y agoYou can't turn off gifs or canvas because it would just break too much internet. I could imagine and equal reaction thread here if google deemed some gifs and canvas uses "unworthy" and were blockable.
- gopiandcode 6y agoThis is not an excuse - the user should have the freedom to disable whatever they want - who is to say that your definition of a broken internet matches mine?
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoThis. If I, the user, disable some functionality and the site doesn't work I can: A: add the site to an allow list B: temporarily enable the feature for that site C: stop using the site Most of the time I'll give a site the benefit of the doubt, only when they pull shady tricks like dark patterns and whatnot do I just stop using the site. Reddit is a great current example. I will not use their site or their app because they're both awful, and reddit is trying to force the app down my throat. If the app I use gets shut down by API changes I'll just stop using reddit.
- Meph504 6y agoNot sure how it would break the internet at all, can you say that you have ever had a user experience improved by auto playing anything? I mean, heaven for bid, they could the user the ability to actually control the repaint rate. Or pull only the first frame of a gif, and not pull the 100+ meg gif without user consent(via touch, by site, etc..) Browsers wouldn't block popups for years because it could break legitimate use, now I don't think a single browser doesn't ship with that option not on by default. I think the reality is, that these are features and functions that advertisers want, and google is in the business of selling ads. This isn't a can't, its a won't.
- ulfw 6y agoUsing a browser from an ad company will do that to you
- pvg 6y agoYou can turn off GIF animation in Chrome, you are still downloading the giantass GIF. Slowing down canvas repaints if one of your overall goals is web applications that have feature and performance parity with desktop ones is, I think, unlikely. I'm a bit more surprised Google (and all browser vendors) aren't more proactive in just killing off animated GIFs.
- aikinai 6y agoExcept animated GIFs are the only way to have embedded "video" in Google Slides. (Yes, you can technically "embed" YouTube videos, but they play in the YouTube player with all of its chrome and only in widescreen with letterboxing if your aspect ratio doesn't fit)
- fomine3 6y agoThat's why they suggest to use <video> for replacing GIF.
- dependenttypes 6y agoOr mark said sites as malicious. No need to select the most anti-user solution.
- ignoramous 6y ago> Then maybe the solution is to also have the option turn off animated GIFs Here's a hammer Google has used before to make other websites tow their line: Peanlize their search rankings.
- wang_li 6y ago> perhaps frequent canvas repaints too; Which touches on something that drives me insane. Browsers are reinventing the OS and they are leaving out all the tools useful for managing one's computer. I should be able to identify which tab is using tons of CPU. Which tabs are using lots of RAM. I should be able to stop a particular bit of script (aka process.) WTF do I get a pop up telling me a script may be causing a page to be slow, but nothing identifying which of the five to six tabs in my eight to ten browser windows it is? Another thing that would be nice is if I had a setting in the browser that allowed me to specify how many ms/sec a script is allowed to run. It would be pleasant to be able to limit scripts to 1 ms per second of run time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]