5 ms·
This analysis is very US/Euro-centric. Bumping the price from US$20 to US$100 might indeed allow you to focus more on your most dedicated customers. It also b
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
This analysis is very US/Euro-centric.
Bumping the price from US$20 to US$100 might indeed allow you to focus more on your most dedicated customers.
It also bumps the price way above anything that billions of people around the world can pay for such a thing.
At Ardour, we have 3 subscription price levels:
Regular: US$10/month
Low Cost: US$4/month
Developing World: US$1/month
We leave it to users to decide which category to select. Maybe you don't care about people in Senegal or Bangladesh or the Phillipines. That's certain an option, but some demonstration that this has crossed your mind is probably a good idea.
It may also be important that on a technical level, our subscriptions are not like e.g. Adobe's. Stop subscribing to this GPL'ed software and nothing changes except for your ability to get updates for free.
- OJFord 6y agoRegional price discrimination is nothing new, but I haven't heard of making it buyers' choice before - why aren't you using IP or some other method of determining region? The obvious answer is that it's defeatable, but if the alternative is then to make it a radio button (trivially 'defeatable'), that's clearly not it.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIt's not intended to be non-defeatable. It's intended to recognize enormous disparities in income worldwide (and sometimes even within the same city). The user/buyer who elects to use a one-time payment gets to pick their own price, too: the default is pre-seeded based on OECD data on the cost of a mid-prize restaurant meal for two without alcohol, combined with IP address. Our motto has been (thus far): it doesn't matter if everybody pays for it, it only matters if enough people pay for it.
- OJFord 6y agoI realise that, I meant that as the usual response that clearly doesn't apply to your case. What I'm not clear on is why you don't work out the correct region & pricing on the customer's behalf; why you leave it to honesty?
- dsjoerg 6y agoA hint towards their answer is when they said "(and sometimes even within the same city)". Because it's important to them to allow for non-location-based price adjustment, they simply leave it up to the user.
- OJFord 6y agoThat makes sense as 'pay what you think it's worth'/'can afford', both of which I think I've seen, but a city isn't both 'developing world' and not based on individuals' income or whatever. And now I quote that, is that the real wording? 'Regular' vs. 'developing world'? Idk, I won't speak for others, but I wouldn't phrase it like that myself.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe wording thing is a fair point. I haven't noticed them juxtaposed in that way. Perhaps we'll change them to something less descriptive of the intended "audience". The "Low Cost" name does this at present. Thanks for pointing it out.
- seanwilson 6y ago> The obvious answer is that it's defeatable, but if the alternative is then to make it a radio button (trivially 'defeatable'), that's clearly not it. Do people really do this? I use Paddle for subscription payments and they offer regional pricing plus they charge country specific tax and VAT processing at checkout. If a business tried to get around this, wouldn't they be at risk of accountancy issues?
- OJFord 6y agoYes, they do, since as the commenter I replied to points out, otherwise you're either pricing yourself out of, or leaving money on the table in, some markets. The cost of mobile data in the USA is 1-2 orders of magnitude higher than in India, for example. You can't charge the same for some mobile app subscription in both markets and not lose out vs. discriminating.
- seanwilson 6y ago> We leave it to users to decide which category to select. Maybe you don't care about people in Senegal or Bangladesh or the Phillipines. That's certain an option, but some demonstration that this has crossed your mind is probably a good idea. Is there some automated way you could come up with reasonable pricing based on IP detected country? I use Paddle for payments and they offer localised pricing - you either enter the country specific prices manually or you enter e.g. the USD price and it sets a price for each country based on converting this by the exchange rate. Is there a better way than using the exchange rate?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoRight now, most IP address detection mechanisms will place me in Albuquerque, NM. In reality, I'm about 70 miles from there. In the circle defined by that radius, there are families who barely earn $10k/yr and single individuals who earn millions per year. So IP address is not particularly useful in determining the "right price". That said, and as mentioned below, we do use IP address and OECD data on the cost of dining out to pre-seed the one-time payment option (the user is free to edit it as they wish).
- seanwilson 6y agoNetflix, Adobe etc. would never be able to go with what's essentially a "pay what you like" or "pay what you claim you earn" subscription if that's what you're getting at. Isn't there something more practical than this?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIf the goal is "never leave money on the table", your strategies will be very different than if you goal is "raise enough income to do something you want to do". To whatever extent Netflix or Adobe are attached to the former goal, then certainly they are not going to offer pay-what-you-say-you-can. Whether that's the best goal for them to have, either for themselves or for society at large, is an entirely different question.
- Kaze404 6y agoThis is incredible. Thank you for not forgetting about half the planet's population like most services do. I'd like to point out that https://sloppy.io https://sloppy.io (not sponsored) recently helped me out with regional pricing. On top of being a great service, I can tell the people running it actually care.
- jimkleiber 6y agoI really appreciate this approach. I thought about charging a low rate of $1/month, but with Stripe processing fees of $0.30 + 2.9% and Memberful fees of 4.9%, I was going to be charged something like $0.38, leaving me $0.62 per $1.00 transaction. Have you found a way around this or just accepted the essentially 38% tax on those $1 monthly transactions?
- jimkleiber 6y agoUPDATE: The Ardour community says they use PayPal because of the micropayments rate [0], which PayPal says is 5% (6% for crossborder transactions) + $0.05 USD per transaction [1]. [0] https://community.ardour.org/about_subscriptions https://community.ardour.org/about_subscriptions [1] https://www.paypal.com/gf/smarthelp/article/How-can-I-update-my-payment-preferences-for-micropayments-FAQ1691 https://www.paypal.com/gf/smarthelp/article/How-can-I-update...
- riquito 6y agoOn mobile, do you also have to give to the app store 30% of $1 for each subscription?
- jimkleiber 6y agoOh goodness, I have no idea. I was doing it through a web page, but I could imagine if I turned it into an app, the app stores might charge for it. They may even charge for it for accessing the website, but I doubt it.
- judge2020 6y agoBased on the saga from Epic and Floatplane[0], if your product is digital or mostly digital, Apple will enforce IAP purchasing which is a 30% cut to Apple. If it's something mostly physical, like packages or food delivery, you are allowed to implement your own CC processing screen. You also can't link to your website via any means if you can subscribe via the website. Even support articles can't link to the main website. 0: https://youtu.be/WzQw3kEbEio https://youtu.be/WzQw3kEbEio
- ramshanker 6y agoApple does this automatically with their price bands?
- dave_sid 6y agoAbsolutely. I’m surprised nobody’s mentioned this. Apple will let you choose a different price for every country. At Band Mule, we just have one low price. The thing is, we are also freemium. But the feature base in the free offering is good enough for most users and has no ads other than an occasional reminder that they can upgrade to premium to allow an extra audio playlist within the app. So the key for us is, actually make it free for most, and not a crappy free, good enough that they may never feel the need to upgrade. The premium level gives some bonus features, nice-to-haves.
- Aperocky 6y agoThis would be super interesting analysis, but what percentage of IPs from US/EU claimed to from 'developing world'?
- an_opabinia 6y ago> Maybe you don't care about people in Senegal or Bangladesh or the Phillipines. This brings to mind a more interesting question: nevermind you, but can Senegalese, Bangladeshi and Phillipino developers make money at $1/mo? If the answer is yes, where are all the local apps taking over the world with their low prices? If the answer is no, are you depriving those locales of local producers?
- d3nj4l 6y agoDisclaimer: I'm Indian, I'm writing from my experience here. I can't speak for any of the three countries you mentioned, but I think you can extrapolate. In the Indian market most of these apps are just free and ad supported, by which I mean they are filled to the brim with banner ads and every action requires going through an interstitial ad. As for this, though: > where are all the local apps taking over the world with their low prices? There's a ton of shovelware made in developing countries on the Play store, it's just not good. Most of them have bad UI, bad UX and/or the ad problem I mentioned earlier, making them unappealing to anybody who can afford an alternative. There's also the fact that apps made locally target local customers for region-specific use cases, so you're not likely to find them useful if you're not from the region (and that is, if you can find them at all in the Play store without any marketing targeted at you!) I know of a few decent to good apps that have to do with Indian accounting etc, and they're making good money at low prices but nobody in the US is going to use them because they're made with the Indian GST and accounting principles in mind. An implication is that these apps don't follow US/EU regulations. There was an Indian-made fertility app that was collecting data that was flagrantly in violation of GDPR (https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/3196/no-bodys-business-mine-how-menstruations-apps-are-sharing-your-data https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/3196/no-bodys-bus..., search for "Maya by Plackal Tech".) To them, the additional work required to be GDPR compliant is not worth it, given that the domestic market is big enough for them at the early stage.
- ivanhoe 6y ago> If the answer is yes, where are all the local apps taking over the world with their low prices? They're out there, but you've never heard of them because to market them to Western public you have to pay Western prices for ads, and it's out of reach for the most of 3rd world indy devs. And at the local markets it's hard to sell even at very low prices, as customers tend to be more careful with their expenses even at $1/mo prices. In poor(er) countries it's not just that people earn less proportionally while still keeping the same relative buying power. A lot of stuff that you need is not proportionally cheaper, and often it's even more expensive if it's from import or market is small, so people have less money to spend both in the total and relative terms... and because of that free/bootleg versions are the number one choice for any software. And all of that results in lowering the bar, poor overall quality of software products, as it just doesn't make much sense to invest time in polishing products too much, it will not pay out.
- sudhirj 6y agoI wrote a tool to calculate product or service prices for different parts of the world based on the Big Mac Index (the price of a local mcdonalds lunch burger). That method makes more sense to me because all your customers have a similar point of reference. McD is thought of as a premium product in some very poor areas, but on the whole they aim for mass market affordability, which makes it a fair comparison. https://bigmacpricing.com/ https://bigmacpricing.com/
- vosper 6y agoThis is cool. I think it would be helpful if the input was in terms of units of currency, rather than Big Macs. Like: I want to charge €10 a month for my product in the EU. Use the Big Mac pricing model to tell me what that is in Brazil. According to your site, a Big Mac in the EU is €4.21 (is it really the same across all EU countries?) which means €1 buys you 0.237 burgers. €10 is therefore 2.37 burgers. At the current Brazilian price of 20.9 BRL per burger, you should charge 2.37 * 20.9 = 49.53 BRL (at the time of writing Google says €10 is worth 62 BRL)
- sudhirj 6y agoYup, I need that too. Will add it in. The Euro zone is reported as a single economic zone in the index (it's published by the Economist). I'm not sure if the prices are actually exactly the same, but from an economic reference point of view, they ought to be. I'm sure there are differences in the prices within each city that McD operates in as well... the currency prices are probably an average.
- dsomers 6y agoI assure you, a Big Mac in the Netherlands will cost more than a Big Mac in Latvia.
- Semaphor 6y ago> According to your site, a Big Mac in the EU is €4.21 (is it really the same across all EU countries?) Just googled prices for Germany: Apparently it’s €5.29 here.
- rootlocus 6y agoThe article is written by the CEO of Astropad which is a tool that allows you to turn an IPad into a secondary, touch display for Macs. The users of Astropad must own both a Mac and an IPad, so people in developing countries are most likely not the target demographic.
- bayindirh 6y agoI have both a Mac and iPad and, I'm in a developing country. Paying $100/year for a utility like this a bit too much. Exchange rates aside, I'm coming from register once, pay to upgrade world. When deciding not pay means losing access to the app, not to the latest version only; It's very hard for me to fork the cash.
- bromuro 6y agoIn the “developing world”, owning an Apple devices costs more dollars than in EU or US. Also customs are incredibly high - try to get a 5k display from the US, you may pay like 1600 dollars in import fees. Someone may assume they don’t want us to “develop”, but for sure, the attitude is not helping.