5 ms·
About the timber harvester: I assume better here is meant from a economical perspective, because from a ecological perspective the walkers are superior, as they
by hutzlibu 6y ago
About the timber harvester: I assume better here is meant from a economical perspective, because from a ecological perspective the walkers are superior, as they do not devestate the ground so much. But that is sadly not really a issue for most wood production, but I could imagine, with rising awareness for the forests, market demand for not so intrusive wood harvesting(along with advances in the field in general) could bring the walking timber harvester back.
I would very much welcome it. I really hate, having all the forests paths messed up in the wood cutting season.
- brianwawok 6y agoWould 500 trips with a giant mech walker wouldn’t hurt the forest as much as a dirt trail and wheels? Both would seem pretty messy
- hutzlibu 6y agoWell, yes, I know horsetracks who already look very bad, after regular riding. But most forest paths are not driven (or walked) 500 times back and forth. Sometimes just once to go in, cut down and take it out. Enough to cut open the soil with the conventional foresters - but much less intrusive with mechanic legs.
- gdubs 6y agoTotally. I want that walker for my woodland, because it looks a lot less damaging to the soil (less soil disruption / compaction). The other thing is it would be nice for climbing to spots that don’t have easy road access. This way you can pick a few trees without devastating a whole area just to reach them.
- skylanh 6y agoDraft horse logging; we had it done in a sensitive woodland. It's not particularly fast, and it would be expensive.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoOh yeah, there was a bit on a Discovery real-life soap once where one of the characters was a draft horse logger; that was pretty impressive.
- 082349872349872 6y agoFor those of you into team[ster]work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NthnHmZT0Go https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NthnHmZT0Go (for those of you who aren't familiar with the english method: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soPp06vwwiI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soPp06vwwiI )
- Meph504 6y agoMost timber today isn't harvested in natural forest, they are effectively tree farms, they have a 10 to 20 year growth cycle and since all the trees planted are harvestable, they basically clear cut the land, burn it, off cycle growth as needed, and do it again. In those instances, there is no ecological consideration as the whole area basically gets wiped out.
- ganafagol 6y agoThat's not really accurate. It depends on the tree type, but the growth cycle is somewhere between 50 to 100 years for optimal results. It's true that most forests today are not old growth anymore. They have been cut (usually clear cut) and then either replanted or just naturally reseeded and are now essentially waiting for the next cut. There are some areas where they are monocultural tree farms with not much else growing, but forest industry starts to realize that that's not the most efficient anyway. Most forests today, even those used for lumber (which are almost all) are integrated ecosystems. That's a great benefit to nature. Clear cutting is quite bad for the surrounding ecosystem. Habitat loss, soil erosion, it's a pretty traumatic event for a forest. (Some shrubs really thrive for a few years after a clear cut though. In Sweden that's when you get to pick tons of wild raspberries, for example.) An alternative is selective cutting where you only cut the oldest trees and leave everything intact. For that, such a legged harvester would be much better. The traditional method is to use horses, but that's too slow for modern forest industry.
- Meph504 6y agoI'm guessing you aren't from the U.S. but in the southern U.S. growing newer species of Pine (variants of Loblolly Pine). A standard lease is 20 years from seedling to harvest, some older variants can go 30 to 50, but you don't see that being planted any longer and that's all leases maturing. And here, I can assure you they are very much mono culture, evenly spaced, engineered species of trees, almost nothing else happens on the land in that time period. (generally it looks pretty similar to this https://a.rgbimg.com/users/p/pa/paparabbit/600/mwYGk8q.jpg https://a.rgbimg.com/users/p/pa/paparabbit/600/mwYGk8q.jpg) They do come and selectively thing at 5, 10, or 15 depending) See the issue is, at least in the southern U.S. they clear cut nearly everything in the 1800s. There is very little old growth left.
- octoberfranklin 6y ago> because from a ecological perspective the walkers are superior You sure about that? Soil compaction is the most serious long-term damage caused by timber harvesting. It's why only tracked harvesters driven by highly-paid fellers are allowed off the gravel. The masses of everyday log-truck drivers (and their wheeled vehicles) are not allowed on the dirt. You want the ground pressure spread out as much as possible, not concentrated on tiny "feet".
- hutzlibu 6y agoI am not sure about compaction compared to a tracked forester. Physics implies that tracked ones are better, for that, yes. But they rip up even more surface. I believe it is a question, how often the specific path has to be passed by by a forester. "It's why only tracked harvesters driven by highly-paid fellers are allowed off the gravel." And this is sadly not true for germany or other parts of europe I know about. I think I never saw a tracked forester in europe. Are they mandatory in the US? That would surprise me, given they have much more lax regulations in general (fracking for example)
- 24gttghh 6y agoThis is a good example of the range of equipment I have seen: https://www.mainecustomwoodlands.com/maine-custom-woodlands-timber-harve https://www.mainecustomwoodlands.com/maine-custom-woodlands-... Only thing non-tracked that goes off the gravel logging roads would be the Skidder (it literally drags bunches, or 'hitches' of trees to the transport vehicles). And even that might be partially or fully-tracked. The feller, slasher, excavator, bulldozer, etc. are all tracked from what I've seen. Mandatory? Doubtful. But they are most practical in the rough terrain.
- octoberfranklin 6y ago> Mandatory? Doubtful. But they are most practical in the rough terrain. I didn't mean to imply there was a government mandate. It's the large forestland owners who demand it of their contractors.
- 6y ago