6 ms·
> “A license for all of mainland China has already been sold, lock, stock and barrel.” This is precisely what the U.S. government was trying to avoid when it i
by gumby 6y ago
> “A license for all of mainland China has already been sold, lock, stock and barrel.” This is precisely what the U.S. government was trying to avoid when it intervened in the previous acquisition of MIPS Technologies.
Why does the U?S? Government care? The MIPS is a mature design that has suffered from neglect for many years and while its useful I can’t imagine how it could be any sort of strategic asset.
What am I missing?
- jeffrallen 6y agoThere are probably military systems that use MIPS processors.
- gumby 6y agoSure, I believe I remember an avionics design win but can’t find the reference right now. Those design wins wouldn’t be affected by any such purchases (chips are fabbed by a third party and any procurement contract wouldn’t permit any mask change — quite the opposite). But any new design would pick a new part anyway, and MIPS could simply be dropped from the candidate list — except there would be no reason to: this deal is China-specific and any US supplier would be buying a license from imagination — or from a merchant chip supplier.
- baybal2 6y agoDo you think that Chinese Electronic Warfare companies care about licensing rights?
- RantyDave 6y agoNo, but they might care about being able to get support.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIf you're capable of doing EW, which is basically Black Magic as far as tech is concerned, support for an ISA won't be that much of an issue.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoNot likely to be many. They were never available in a rad hard form. Mil spec micros tend to be old platforms at this point. The most sophisticated was an old PowerPC and there is a VHDL SPARC clone that is popular for ASIC and FPGA implementations.
- doctorshady 6y agoDidn't NASA start using a radiation-hardened R3000 variant? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongoose-V https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongoose-V
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoAnd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RH-32 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RH-32
- skissane 6y agoDo the people in charge of this in the US government have any clue? Quite possibly they don't. They may not understand the market reality that MIPS is a shadow of its former self. And they may think that CPU architectures are some kind of black magic that China is incapable of inventing on their own. Even if the lower level staff have a good understanding of reality, that could easily be lost in the transmission by the time it filters up to the senior level
- Aperocky 6y agoWhile China is very far behind in terms of chip manufacturing technology, the US government has essentially showed China that if they don't have it themselves, they'll be sanctioned at whenever and whatever.
- hashtagmarkup 6y agoIn what world can you believe China is behind or "very far behind" in chip manufacturing??? Or, are you one of "Taiwan isn't China" types?
- SR2Z 6y agoTaiwan is distinct from the PRC - they have their own government, currency, and most importantly, a totally different relationship with the west that led to the rise of companies like TSMC. Either your comment is about Taiwan having a legitimate claim to the name "China," or you're claiming that Taiwan is rightfully a part of the PRC. The first one is intentionally awful communication, and the second one is a whole other can of worms.
- marky75 6y agoTechnically, most countries are not allowed to recognize the ROC (Tawain) as an independent country but as a Rogue province. The one China policy was accepted when the UN removed the ROC in favor of PRC.
- bleepblorp 6y agoArbitrary sanctions against Chinese companies (e.g. the war against Huawei) and seizures of Chinese assets (e.g. TikTok) are driven by a sizable faction in Washington DC that feels entitled to rule the planet uncontested. They would like to unwind the past 75 years of Chinese economic development, and push most of the Chinese population back into poverty, to make sure that an independent global power can never develop.
- xenadu02 6y agoChinese state-sponsored actors and corporate espionage have also been stealing technology from US companies so it's not like their hands are clean here. Why is a Chinese citizen allowed to come to the US to buy property or start a company - but if I want to do the same thing I am forced by Chinese law to give half of it away to a Chinese "partner"? China wants to have it both ways: concessions for 3rd world developing economies yet to be treated as a world power with its own technology and innovations. China wants the benefits of trade, yet manipulates the hell out of its currency. The current US administration is certainly hamfisted and inept, no argument there. But even a broken clock is right twice a day. People are right to be upset about some aspects of China's policies. That doesn't mean punishing Chinese companies is a good solution, but the US is also under no obligation to just sit here and let China do as it pleases while talking out of both sides of its mouth.
- gumby 6y agoThe same activities, lack of copyright, harboring fugitives etc were how the US got its start, to the consternation of the then dominant superpower. From Lowell’s theft of the spinning mills to Dickens’ (and Tolkien‘s) complaints about lack of copyright, the US didn’t care until it was on top. Not to defend the British whose IP was being pilfered, they’d done the same in their turn. It was ever thus.
- ardy42 6y ago> are driven by a sizable faction in Washington DC that feels entitled to rule the planet uncontested. They would like to unwind the past 75 years of Chinese economic development, and push most of the Chinese population back into poverty, to make sure that an independent global power can never develop. Cite for that? Especially that bit about the goal of pushing the Chinese population back into poverty. My impression is the situation would be quite different if China was not run by authoritarian communists.
- fit2rule 6y agoMIPS is used in a lot of US' military applications, even still today.
- yaantc 6y agoMIPS has excellent cores in the middle range (The "I class"). They can't compete at the high end with ARM, as high end need to be optimized for the latest processes in close cooperation with the leading fabs (TSMC and Samsung) and this is very labor intensive and so costly. So in the CPU IP world, it's ARM area. They're not the best for the very small cores either. But in the middle, like the I-7200 or I-6500, they have very good cores and related IPs (like a coherent LLC). From last time I looked, still much more mature than anything from RISC V suppliers for example. If the I-7200 used the RISC V ISA (with extensions), it would likely be a reference in its class. Instead MIPS went with a new compact ISA that nobody cares about, too bad. Of course, the RISC V suppliers will mature over time and will at some point offer competitive or better solutions. But right now, the quality of some MIPS IPs shouldn't be underestimated. It would be too bad if this were wasted, but unfortunately it could happen. Hopefully the IP and people behind it will be acquired and the know-how will end up in coming RISC V chips. One can hope...
- RantyDave 6y agoPresumably (as someone who doesn't really know shit about this) it's fully possible to make a MIPS chip that speaks Arm instructions? Instructions arrive and are decoded to uops, right? So is the instruction set itself software defined?
- jbirer 6y agoIt's like the ex-girlfriend who came back because she found out you are with someone else.
- kjs3 6y agoMIPS hasn't been neglected, though it's clearly not one of the new hotness and hasn't seen the attention that ARM has. Look at what companies like Octeon have produced. If someone stepped up with nation-state levels of investment, I think you could see some very interesting outcomes. That's the concern.
- hashtagmarkup 6y agoyou are dumb