4 ms·
Oh, that thing. Back when I was into legged locomotion, I found out more about that machine than I ever wanted to know. The designer was really into four-bar l
by Animats 6y ago
Oh, that thing. Back when I was into legged locomotion, I found out more about that machine than I ever wanted to know.
The designer was really into four-bar linkages. The leg mechanism is set up so that one actuator moves the leg in X, one in Y, and one in Z, with a four-bar linkage encoding that into the leg position. This simplifies the control problem, while complicating the mechanics. I suspect they wanted to be able to get the thing home by manual control of the actuators if the computers crashed. It's not towable; you'd need a crane and a flatbed.
It could only walk on flat ground. It was supposed to be able to cross a ditch, but that was manual. The driver had to drive it up to the ditch and stop. Then lock five legs, and, using a joystick, move one of the leading legs across the ditch and set it down. Then, with support in place, move the vehicle forward slightly with no leg lifts. Then lock five legs again, and place the second forward leg. Repeat until all six legs had made it across.
Cool, but not useful.
In the 1990s, a company in Finland got this right.[1] They built a six-legged walking timber harvester. It's impressive. Deere bought the company But it's not better than 8-wheel articulated timber harvesters [2], so it was never produced as a product.
[1] https://youtu.be/CD2V8GFqk_Y https://youtu.be/CD2V8GFqk_Y
[2] https://youtu.be/BwCTDXatIYA https://youtu.be/BwCTDXatIYA
- ChuckMcM 6y agoOh I want one of those "Timberjack" machines. (well without the timber cutting stuff). Based on some of the papers I found on the OSU project it seems like you could replace the entire computing infrastructure it was carrying around with about one pound (1/2 kg) of computers. I don't suppose you have a pointer to an IK paper on the 4-bar linkages do you? Looks like something that might be fun to cons up with servos.
- jcims 6y agoThere are quite a few quadruped robots that use them for legs: https://youtu.be/2k5lOUGenkE https://youtu.be/2k5lOUGenkE
- Animats 6y agoNow that's a more modern way to use a four-bar linkage. The ASV used it to simplify the kinematic problem, which is doing arithmetic with big steel connecting rods. That little quadruped is using it to get two degrees of freedom without the first actuator having to carry the mass of the second one.
- jcims 6y agoHey you might know this. Is there a term for using what effectively a differential gear arrangement to get two axes of motion as shown in the arm in this video (twice actually, for axes 2/3 and 4/5)? https://youtu.be/ri8kwOCJnY8 https://youtu.be/ri8kwOCJnY8
- Animats 6y agoThere's an MIT Press book.[1] Chapter 6, "Leg Design by Four Bar Linkage Synthesis" covers the four-bar linkage. They were struggling to get enough working volume for the foot out of the four bar linkage without the mechanism becoming too bulky. They wanted to be able to move horizontally using only one actuator per leg, which allowed manual backup control. It's an interesting piece of history, but there's no need to do it that way today. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Machines-That-Walk-Adaptive-Suspension/dp/0262192748 https://www.amazon.com/Machines-That-Walk-Adaptive-Suspensio...
- jcims 6y agoA modern timber harvester run by a skilled operator is beautifully terrifying.
- hutzlibu 6y agoI once camped wild with a friend in the middle of a forest. The next morning there was sawing in the distance, no worries. Got closer and closer ... so we hurried to pack our things .. just in time to have our camping place vanished as it was in the path of destruction. I was not aware before how fast they could be. (and I don't know, if we just had bad luck, or he had fun messing us, but we were quite hidden)
- jcims 6y agoThat’s some nightmare fuel haha
- hutzlibu 6y agoWell, I think I actually had some dreams in that regard, because there was also a second encounter with unexcpected approaching foresters and this time in a dramatic setting, with a strong thunderstorm approaching and we generally were quite paranoid, because we were in the border area of germany and Czech and we were really scared of the high wildcamping fines that exist in theory and we did not know at that time, that usually you get away with a warning and mostly not even that. So we felt a bit like hunted ... (ah yeah, also because a hunter was shooting close to us, without noticing us)
- hutzlibu 6y agoAbout the timber harvester: I assume better here is meant from a economical perspective, because from a ecological perspective the walkers are superior, as they do not devestate the ground so much. But that is sadly not really a issue for most wood production, but I could imagine, with rising awareness for the forests, market demand for not so intrusive wood harvesting(along with advances in the field in general) could bring the walking timber harvester back. I would very much welcome it. I really hate, having all the forests paths messed up in the wood cutting season.
- brianwawok 6y agoWould 500 trips with a giant mech walker wouldn’t hurt the forest as much as a dirt trail and wheels? Both would seem pretty messy
- hutzlibu 6y agoWell, yes, I know horsetracks who already look very bad, after regular riding. But most forest paths are not driven (or walked) 500 times back and forth. Sometimes just once to go in, cut down and take it out. Enough to cut open the soil with the conventional foresters - but much less intrusive with mechanic legs.
- gdubs 6y agoTotally. I want that walker for my woodland, because it looks a lot less damaging to the soil (less soil disruption / compaction). The other thing is it would be nice for climbing to spots that don’t have easy road access. This way you can pick a few trees without devastating a whole area just to reach them.
- m0zg 6y agoThat timber harvester is pretty unbelievable for 20+ years ago. I wonder what Boston Dynamics would be able to do with it today.
- gdubs 6y agoThat timber harvester looks amazing. As I commented below, the weight distribution is a pretty appealing aspect for minimizing the impact on soil. Though, unclear how much better it is then the tank treads which also do a pretty good job distributing weight as far as I know? Super cool though. Would be a nice way to selectively take out trees without tearing up a whole area for access, etc.
- twothamendment 6y agoIt isn't just about weight distribution. My yard is a forest. I have a mini excavator with tracks and I can sneak in and out of places without disturbing things too much - as long as I don't have to turn sharp (and the ground isn't too wet). I think the walking machines might have an advantage there. The tracks can only slide sideways when you turn, that tears stuff up.
- gdubs 6y agoI know what you mean — we’re restoring an oak woodland and between the various springs and poorly drained soil, there’s a very small window where an excavator can actually get in there to work. Our Douglas Fir stand is on good soil, but getting to it is a little tricky. Getting a bit easier though after 3 years of blackberry removal, and tree limbing (to reduce wildfire risk and improve trails etc).
- 082349872349872 6y agoRelated: tracked APC vs 4-legged (+wheeled) construction vehicle https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBgzkKqCXzw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBgzkKqCXzw (Menzi Mucks are available with forestry attachments) Bonus clip: (multi-metre obstacle) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Y85nfQuU0M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Y85nfQuU0M
- yoz-y 6y agoTangential but I find it interesting how the old ad shows the machine and explains why it is interesting while the new one has detail shots, buzzwords and epic music. I guess it’s just to catch the eye and then one can find all the info later, but still.
- danans 6y agoBah. That thing's got nothing on the Onceler's tree harvester: https://youtu.be/5cXntJFWv5U https://youtu.be/5cXntJFWv5U
- wtracy 6y ago> It could only walk on flat ground. It was supposed to be able to cross a ditch, but that was manual. Well, now I'm wondering what they needed eleven onboard minicomputers for. How much route planning intelligence do you really need if you're operating over identical terrain every time?
- dmix 6y agoWhy didn't they also put wheels under the harvester for road travel? I'm guessing that'd massively complicate things...
- aembleton 6y agoWould have been a good idea for towing to a site though. They wouldn't need to be powered.
- lumberingjack 6y agoI have seen working walking Timberjack models in Ohio I have pics from early 2000s someplace of fresh painted unit standing in the woods getting ready to clear some dead forest to stop all the wildfires we where having.