3 ms·
Mainstream journalists are not a good source of information. The WSJ and FT are a great source for business news (for which they have to be good) but that's abo
by renewiltord 6y ago
Mainstream journalists are not a good source of information. The WSJ and FT are a great source for business news (for which they have to be good) but that's about it.
Journalists are on the cusp of losing their jobs and it's the greatest thing that could happen. For decades, perhaps centuries, they are propaganda arms but now every man with a camera is a better cameraman and every man with a blog is a better writer.
Newspapers are doomed. Not because they transformed into liars but because what they can give us can now be given to us by others much better and we don't really need the lies anymore. In their effort to stay relevant they have tried to be more opinionated, but if I just want you to give me your opinion I could get that from smarter people on Twitter rather than some guy who barely knows how to read and write sleep-deprivedly rewriting an AP/Reuters text - which in itself is about 95% bullshit anyway.
Perhaps only sports journalists need professionally exist.
There are still people who fall for the broken media, though. And fortunately, that is a good thing for the rest of us. While HN celebrated the "discovery" of SuperMicro's "spying", I loaded up on cheap SMCI. Keep doing what you're doing. Making money is all the sweeter this way because someone else is losing it to me.
- EliRivers 6y agoIs Joe Random poster on the internet more reliable? I would have gone for less. Making money is all the sweeter this way because someone else is losing it to me. Why such a coward? If you get your kicks through other people's pain, just do it direct.
- renewiltord 6y agoYeah, that's the counter-intuitive part: Joe Random is more reliable. It's like asking "Is your opponent for President less reliable than a random?" when wondering about information they give you. Sure the opponent is smarter, more well educated, and less likely to be wrong. But he's your opponent. So maybe don't listen to him if he says "I saw the stats and you're not going to win. It's probably best to save your money" The journalists are suckering you. And if you want to avidly defend the suckering, then go ahead and fit this siphon to your bank account. No no, don't worry, it's a great idea. Bloomberg News said so.
- EliRivers 6y agoI disagree. Joe Random is going to be all over the fucking place. He's going to know about a few small items that he happens to have expertise in, and he's going to be a shitshow on all the crap he's just spouting about, and there's going to be no way to tell the two. That's not reliability; it's the opposite of reliability.
- renewiltord 6y agoHey, believe what you will. Your disagreement is desirable. Just so long as whatever index fund you're in sells that SuperMicro. Let the market choose between us. It is the strongest competition of world views. May the best man win. It's true that there's variance and I elided a model I talk about in real life for simplicity but as a mathematical analogy, your opponent has high bias low variance and the random has high variance low bias. You pick the former, I'll pick something else. And may the universe decide who prospers. So far it's looking good for me.
- LIV2 6y agoIn Aus the media is almost all either owned by Murdoch or held hostage by the government who cuts the budget any time they do honest reporting so there is definitely some value in democratic "rando" media imo
- antiterra 6y agoI believe you are very wrong. The situation you described befits mass produced clickbait over well researched articles of high journalistic integrity. Local news is dead and along with it, local perspective. News photographers are significantly better photographers than the everyday person with a phone, but the coverage of amateur images and video is game changing. That said, much of news photography is being in the right place at the right situation and many of that profession are particularly brave, clever and devoted.
- renewiltord 6y agoNews photogs had one advantage: good equipment. Now people want authenticity and everyone has equipment. No one really cares all that much about the one carefully posed photo some news photog decided to take because his boss told him to represent some view. You may get a million views and your NatGeo / J.D.Power Asia-Pacific Best Photo of the Week or whatever nonsense but the next kid using his iPhone to record with image stabilization is going to get two million. Because he has something you don't: he's there and he's authentic. "High journalistic integrity" was a fiction we all collectively believed because ultimately we wanted the dopamine hit of "knowing" stuff. But it's over: journalism is now democratized. No more controlled lies. Now everyone can lie as powerfully. And that is a good thing for information.
- antiterra 6y agoI agree with you to the extent that so-called ‘photo-journalism’ is far more editorial and subjective than widely thought. However, journalists absolutely believe in a number of values and, as a whole, hold themselves to them. There exist a number of articles which stand as culturally important works of nonfiction. We are going to have significantly less of those, and a lot more blunders like the Bloomberg chip thing because the structures are gone. Fundamentally, I sense you just have something against the idea of expertise and ordained authority. I get that. It’s ridiculous that the Academy Awards are seen as an authoritative measurement of how good films are. But that doesn’t eliminate the wide spectrum of sophistication and depth that is much more than a TED Talk dopamine hit. The incentives and security required for in-depth, long-term reporting are gone. That’s bad.