3 ms·
> Would you expect different ratings for hardcover/paperback versions of books? Probably not, at least assuming people review the content of the book, not its
by tzs 6y ago
> Would you expect different ratings for hardcover/paperback versions of books? Probably not, at least assuming people review the content of the book, not its appearance.
I would expect different ratings, because when you buy a book it is not just the content you are buying. The reason people look at reviews is to decide whether or not to buy, and the physical quality of the book is important for that.
If the hardback is fine but the paperback has pages out of order and that fall out when you turn them, then people who bought the paperback are going to (quite justifiably) be leaving reviews with the lowest rating possible. This doesn't help me at all when I'm considering buying the hardback.
- ghaff 6y agoWell, people can explain their low ratings. "A real page turner but the paperback printing and binding were awful." The problem is that, if you rate at the SKU level, you now have different reviews for every size and color of shirt. "The green color isn't at all like what was on the product page." The reality is that for most books (pretty much all fiction, most trade paperbacks without a lot of illustrations/code/etc.), Kindle format is just fine even on a e-paper reader.
- liability 6y ago> "The green color isn't at all like what was on the product page." That's a valuable review though; if a green shirt is not as advertised I want to know that before I buy it.
- ghaff 6y agoYes, but it's pretty much as valuable lumped in with the other shirt reviews whereas if you split out reviews for each individual SKU, many of the items will end up not having reviews at all.
- liability 6y agoIf a particular variation has no review, I want to know that before I buy it. What good is a bunch of 5 star reviews for a red shirt if the lime green shirt I want to buy is actually the color of baby shit?
- tzs 6y agoAmazon could simply have aggregated star totals and reviews, with the ability to select narrower subsets. If I'm looking at a book and worried about quality differences between formats I could ask ask for just reviews from verified paperback purchasers, then from verified hardback purchasers, and then from verified Kindle purchasers. They already allow filtering by verified purchasers. Just add the format filtering, and when viewing through filters show the aggregate star stats for the resulting reviews. This would be close to trivial for them to do and greatly increase the usefulness of reviews with no effect on people who are OK with the current aggregate approach.