3 ms·
> I'll accept that rocks are just the substrate, but integrated circuits are just carefully cooked rocks; substrate-vs-consciousness thinking might be wrong It
by tsimionescu 6y ago
> I'll accept that rocks are just the substrate, but integrated circuits are just carefully cooked rocks; substrate-vs-consciousness thinking might be wrong
It's a side point, but I think the important difference is that a rock can exist even without bacteria (imagine the rock is somewhere close to the earth's core, just below the temperature that would melt it into lava), while the bacteria on the rock could also exist independently of the rock (they could be blown by the wind and moved to a different rock, for example). So it makes sense to discuss the amount of consciousness in the (sterile) rock itself, and in the (floating) bacteria as well, though of course the system of rock+bacteria can have its own amount of consciousness.