4 ms·
> There are 20 billionaires in Africa, you’re saying they had an advantage of race and country of origin. You conveniently skipped over the part where the comm
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> There are 20 billionaires in Africa, you’re saying they had an advantage of race and country of origin.
You conveniently skipped over the part where the comment you're responding to said "family or nation of origin". If anything, more billionaires in 3rd world countries got their wealth through corruption and family connections. Take the top billionaires in Africa:
1. Aliko Dangote: see "Family and Personal Life" on his Wikipedia page, which includes "He is the great-grandson of Alhaji Alhassan Dantata, the richest West African at the time of his death in 1955."
2. Nassef Onsi Sawiris: His Wikipedia entry starts with "is an Egyptian billionaire businessman, the youngest of Onsi Sawiris' three sons". Onsi Sawiris was a billionaire.
3. Mike Adenuga is more self-made, but even then, "his mother, Omoba Juliana Oyindamola Adenuga, was a businesswoman of royal Ijebu descent."
There are other more notorious examples from that list of billionaires, like Isabel dos Santos.
I'm interested to see how you re-evaluate your argument "when put against facts".
- dredmorbius 6y agoThat, and also an "often or always" tied to the full list of qualifiers.
- bluedevil2k 6y ago“often or always” is a cop out for people who can’t decidedly prove a point.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoLol, no. "Often or always" is used by people who realize the world is rarely black and white. It's weird, you're arguing against a point that no one else is making. Of course there are many billionaires whose individual intelligence, innate gifts, hard work and diligence were crucial to them earning their fortune. Just as obviously as there are many billionaires who earned their fortune through family, connections, graft, etc. (It's also pretty easily arguable the majority of the wealthy earned their money this way, given that for every "self-made" rich person there are usually loads more family members/connections who inherit or benefit from that wealth). But the larger point is that nobody makes their fortune in a vacuum - even all these "self-made" rich relied upon the structures of their society to enable their wealth accumulation, so it seems more than morally fair that that society has a claim to some of that wealth so the next generation can reap the same benefits. Just look at all the Internet billionaires, or billionaires who rely on GPS. Both the Internet and GPS were created by the government, and it seems fair to me that the government take a chunk of the wealth enabled by the enormous investments into those systems.
- dredmorbius 6y agoQuite this, yes.
- bluedevil2k 6y agoThey’ve aleady paid income tax to help pay for GPS!!
- bluedevil2k 6y agoYou named 3 of the 20 I listed. What about the 138 in India? All from warlords and inheritance? Mark Cuban? Elon Musk? Warren Buffet? Larry Ellison? Steve Jobs? Steve Mozniak? Ted Arison?