3 ms·
That doesn't mean rocks are conscious, it means the things that live on rocks are conscious - an interesting idea that appears to scale well. There is no CS so
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
That doesn't mean rocks are conscious, it means the things that live on rocks are conscious - an interesting idea that appears to scale well.
There is no CS solution to the hard problem, because the hard problem is not about information, or behaviour, or data compression, or rocks. It's about subjectivity, and there isn't even a working definition of what subjectivity is, never mind any experiment that can be done to confirm that it exists.
Subjectivity is essentially metaphysical in the sense that it's outside of science.
It's impossible to make a testable statement about any phenomenon of any kind that isn't filtered through human perception and all the layers of human cognitive processing.
In a very real sense it's objectivity that's the illusion. Try to make a statement about anything whatsoever that is truly independent of collective human sense perception and human mental processes and see how far you get.
Whatever you think you're doing in science or math, you're looking out through a distorted window whose properties you're not aware of, and trying to correlate your observations with others looking out through windows with similar distortions.
The best you'll get is an interesting list of distortions which everyone agrees on. Even if they have predictive power, that doesn't make them truly objective - it just makes them a spiky median of collective experience instead of an outlier of individual experience.
- arithma 6y agoThis kind of reminds me of the usual interview question: can you make a fair die from an unfair one. Similarly, us as humans, could possibly have the ability to get over some/all of our distorted senses. I am not talking about every day life here. It's in principle possible to deal with the logical fallacies that we're programmed with, but it requires effort. What am more interested to convey is: our potential for objectivity is troubled with subjectivity. It is, however, not impossible on just the account of having subjective distortions. Those can be overrun. There are many other similar analogies that come to mind, one that is prominent: digital systems made from purely analog ones.
- Kednicma 6y agoI agree with your direction, but have qualms with your points. Suppose for absurdity I replay my original argument, but with humans, and you reply "that doesn't mean humans are conscious; it means that the things which are housed within skulls are conscious". I understand the nuance you're introducing, but don't think that it helps. Part of the difficulty of the Combination Problem is that the boundary of conscious control extends beyond the nexus of thought. I'll accept that rocks are just the substrate, but integrated circuits are just carefully cooked rocks; substrate-vs-consciousness thinking might be wrong. I agree with you that science is done empirically, and thus doesn't experience objectivity. However, maths is quite formal, and in the past century we managed to achieve "formal formality" with category theory. We now can talk of certain objects as existing universally; in their context, not only do they exist, but they uniquely exist. For example, `1+1=2`, which is to say that there's an equivalence between any pair of objects selected one by one, and any pair taken both at a time; for any particular counting context, there's only one natural numbers object. I am not quite as pessimistic as you regarding the quality of the conclusions that we reach. Rather than saying that our filters make us subjective, I would simply say that the experiences of humanity are essentially human. There's an anthropic bias because humans can't experience anything that isn't human; we can't think truly alien ideas or build truly alien artifacts. Everything we think is non-human is actually human. This doesn't prevent us from drawing conclusions, but it does forbid objectivity.
- tsimionescu 6y ago> I'll accept that rocks are just the substrate, but integrated circuits are just carefully cooked rocks; substrate-vs-consciousness thinking might be wrong It's a side point, but I think the important difference is that a rock can exist even without bacteria (imagine the rock is somewhere close to the earth's core, just below the temperature that would melt it into lava), while the bacteria on the rock could also exist independently of the rock (they could be blown by the wind and moved to a different rock, for example). So it makes sense to discuss the amount of consciousness in the (sterile) rock itself, and in the (floating) bacteria as well, though of course the system of rock+bacteria can have its own amount of consciousness.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThough to some extent the problem is purely metaphysical and as iresolvable as the question of divinity or boltzmann brains, I still think that it is a question that is fundamentally inaccessible to science in all its aspects. Let's assume that at some point in the distant future, if we have a working understanding of animal and human cognition, to the extent that we can either build a program that works as well as a dog or even human being, and we can also probe its functioning in a meaningful way, perhaps in a similar manner that we can today model a complex fluid or large mechanical system (that is, we understand the general idea, but not all aspects of it). If we could do all of the above, then we could model and alter states, and identify which "brain" states correspond to certain subjective experiences - assuming of course that there is no ghost in the machine. This could be considered reductionist, and it would not be a fully satisfying answer to the hard problems of consciouness - just like a theory of everything or a perfect model of the formation of the universe wouldn't actually answer the concept of divinity, but it may make it seem unnecessary to many people.