6 ms·
Teenages tend to revolt against their parents no?
by markus_zhang 6y ago
Teenages tend to revolt against their parents no?
- phkahler 6y agoYep. People like to think we are more sophisticated, but we have built-in animal behaviors. Teens revolting and making their own way is a big one. Hard for parents but important for the kids. I still find it weird how hard wired some things are.
- faitswulff 6y agoI’ve heard (can’t remember the source now) that the rebellious teen phase is a cultural phenomenon. I find it believable. In general, ascribing human behaviors to biology is shaky science. Ah, here we go: > Although Westerners may expect from adolescents a certain level of delinquency, antisocial behavior and sometimes violence, cross-cultural research demonstrates adolescent behavior and experience is actually quite variable across the world. Adolescent misbehavior does not appear to be a cultural universal. https://hraf.yale.edu/are-teens-always-troublemakers-cross-culturally-considering-bad-behavior-in-adolescents/ https://hraf.yale.edu/are-teens-always-troublemakers-cross-c...
- untog 6y agoI agree that ascribing human behaviours to (particularly animal) biology is shaky. But the changes going on in teenage years (ie puberty) lead me to think teenage rebellion isn’t just cultural.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe hormonal changes are hard wired, but certain behaviors aren’t. As an interesting corollary, did you know that the symptoms experienced by schizophrenics is extremely culturally dependent? Here in America the voices heard by someone with schizophrenia often urge violence, but in other countries (India is the one I’ve heard) they say nice, positive things. Same condition, culturally dependent outcomes.
- ant6n 6y agoThere are cultures that deal with it better
- mordymoop 6y agoTeenage rebellion is often “rational but dumb”, in the sense of being an understandable but unskillfully directed protest against actual injustices. If you take off the “teenager” lens and imagine that you’re witnessing the behavior of an adult who is being denied every variety of personal choice, while being pushed and browbeaten into spending their time in activities that don’t earn them money or status, the behaviors seem almost reasonable. Just to take one example, if you were forced to wake up at 5:30 AM to get on a bus to sit in chairs for 7 hours listening to mediocre lectures, got in serious trouble if you took more than 5 minutes to move between rooms, had to ask permission to use the rest room, and that’s just what happens before you get home and have a new sequence of orders and chores issued to you ... then you would rebel.
- iso1631 6y ago> if you were forced to wake up at 5:30 AM to get on a bus I know this is an American thing, in the UK high school for me started at 0845, which meant leaving home about 0820, so getting up about 0800. Still way to early, but at least it's not in the middle of the night. I don't understand how a school day would even work with a 6:30 start. When's lunch?
- mordymoop 6y agoI haven’t been to school in decades but basically, the bus arrives when it arrives, maybe 30-45 minutes before school starts, and you want to be at the stop early for obvious reasons. It gets a little less stupid once you’re old enough to drive yourself, if you have a car or can carpool. But no way would a 20 minute commute be assumed.
- iso1631 6y agoUK average commute for high school is 25 minutes, and 3.4 miles [0], but a 30-40 minute doesn't sound awful on a bus, means leaving home 0800 so getting up 0740. So your high schools start at 6.30 AM? [0] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/476635/travel-to-school.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- BurningFrog 6y agoUnfounded theory I came up with just now: Teenagers go through puberty because biologically they are now ready to have children, and evolution has favored those with very strong such urges. In cultures where having babies at 14 is completely out of the question, teens rebel!
- faitswulff 6y agoThe article goes on to add: > What predicts more trouble-making? Adolescent behavior (and misbehavior) is related to key social relationships and socialization styles. More specifically, cross-cultural research finds adolescents are more likely to misbehave in societies that have more severe punishment, more restrictiveness, and more distant mother-child relationships (summarized in Ember, Pitek, and Ringen 2017).
- mmm_grayons 6y agoI didn't, nor did many of my friends. I think that's just a stereotype.
- cellular 6y agoSame here and same for my old kids.
- irrational 6y agoIt depends. My wife did not rebel at all. From the way her parents, siblings, etc. describe her, she was a model person from childhood to adulthood. But, our children have taken more after me - wild, rebellious, etc. This has been really hard on my wife since it has been so antithetical to how she was growing up.
- amenod 6y agoIt mostly depends on the parents, not on children. Teens are finally independent and strong enough to be able to revolt - if they do or not is in many cases just a reflection if their parents treat them as equals or not. Before you answer "but they are not equal...", please think.
- alexbanks 6y agoCame to post. Teenagers aren't the totally irrational monsters television/media makes them out to me, necessarily. As one could guess, they're very much a reflection of their parents' investment in their emotional health and growth. Purely anecdotally, none of the children I've been around that had thoughtful/respectful/logical parents have gone through the mindless rebellion phase - they've all been very level headed reasonable people in their teens. On the flipside, all of the children of mindless authoritarian parents have gone kinda wild pretty much as soon as they developed the agency to do so. It's kind of sad that (at least in the US) we've painted teenagers as some kind of psychotic monster that needs tamed.
- justinclift 6y agoYeah. My early years (up to age 12) were ok. After that though was very... not good. One memory really stands out though, from about a week (rough guess) before I turned 13. It was my mother saying she was dreading my 13th birthday, as that's when things go bad. It completely surprised me, as I hadn't thought anything special about it. However from (literally) my 13th birthday onwards, life became hell. On the day. My mother turned into an absolute control freak, full on, with no-let up. For years. If I didn't do something she wanted, in exactly the way she wanted (generally with no explanation), it was name calling, taking away of <whatever she knew I felt was important>, and doing whatever she could to belittle and degrade me try try and "teach me a lesson". There are no words to describe the mental abuse from that day onwards. It never stopped, and there was no way of getting it to stop. I eventually dropped out of school (age ~15), lived on the streets for a while, then went to live with my grandmother. All because some idiot bitch thought teenagers were the problem. :( :( :( Please, don't take this approach with your kids.
- 6y ago