4 ms·
The article isn't really clear on the mechanics of this. Are they changing their names and starting over entirely? Or are they just moving and the company hel
by duxup 6y ago
The article isn't really clear on the mechanics of this.
Are they changing their names and starting over entirely?
Or are they just moving and the company helps them establish themselves in a way where their name isn't likely to appear as easily and Japan has some mix of legal / personal norms that allow this to happen / them to remain hidden?
- toast0 6y agoIt sounds like it's mostly legal / personal norms that make it hard to investigate. They mentioned continuing to use ATMs etc and that police won't do anything. In the US, I imagine you'd file a missing persons report, and track down people still using their banking connections. If you wanted to disappear in the US and not be tracked, you'd need to keep a lot of cash, and not use a car (or not register it).
- vmception 6y agoyou can register the car under an LLC or buy someone else's car registered under an LLC and you purchased their LLC, the state isn't aware that the car changed titles
- scoopertrooper 6y agoPresumably, you'd need to register as a director of the LLC.
- Uberphallus 6y agoSounds like a company that makes people disappear would have an LLC for such purposes and charge accordingly.
- vmception 6y agoIts state dependent of where the LLC is registered, as not all states have those requirements Its state dependent on whether the state you are physically in has the resources to enforce foreign LLC registration (hint: none do, with California being a big maybe) Its state dependent on whether enforcement has any real consequences, such as whether there is any retroactive punishment or not (example: New York State actually gives retroactive protections for your foreign LLC even after you are sued in court and form a domestic LLC as required to have a better case, so the only consequence there is having to register once you get sued which costs a little money, no consequence for the property and this doesn't address a bill of sale for a car) So, what happens when you get pulled over? Shrug, have all the papers? Point is that you can transfer any property this way by transferring the business that owns it with nobody knowing what the business actually owns.
- stickfigure 6y ago> So, what happens when you get pulled over? People get pulled over driving company cars all the time. That's exactly what this is.
- octoberfranklin 6y agoThis is exactly what do, because of outrage over DMV data leaks. Been pulled over a few times (tail light, missing front plates, etc). Never a problem. Helps to pick a company name that is boringly generic yet obviously conveys that "this company's purpose is to own vehicles".
- feteru 6y agoWait you actually own your car this way? Do you use the LLC for anything else?
- vmception 6y agoI use LLCs and similar concepts to hold title, sometimes to a single asset. Its nice to be in an audience where others do it as well. But I think that's the point, you shouldn't know who does it if its designed well. Your name wouldn't be on any public records. And you can always just ambiguously say "my CPA/lawyer said to set it up that way I don't know anything" as opposed to coming across as a meticulous chess player in life.
- octoberfranklin 6y ago> Wait you actually own your car this way? Yes. > Do you use the LLC for anything else? No.
- tkgally 6y agoA summary of privacy laws in Japan is at [0]. I've been living in Japan since 1983, and my impression is that companies and government agencies became more careful about customers' and citizens' privacy about 15 years ago, after a privacy-protection law took effect [1; see also 2]. Since then, when I have done something like buy a new cellphone or pay taxes, the company or agency has had to go through an extra step or two to demonstrate to me that they would use my personal information only for the stated purpose. Television and newspapers started obscuring faces, license plates, etc. in photographs more often as well [examples at 3 and 4]. I teach at a public university, and we're now supposed to encrypt all information we have about students' grades, e-mail addresses, etc. I don't know how effective these laws and rules are in general, but they probably do make it harder to find someone who wants to disappear. The brother of someone I know did just that a few years ago. He went through some kind of midlife crisis and left his wife, children, and family business without a word. She tried to trace him through the police, but the police wouldn't cooperate because there was no sign of foul play. He was spotted by a relative a year or so later living in an apartment not too far away and has since moved back with his family. [0] https://www.generalunion.org/laws-and-rights/1490-a-guide-to-privacy-laws-in-japan https://www.generalunion.org/laws-and-rights/1490-a-guide-to... [1] http://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/law/detail_main?id=130 http://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/law/detail_main?id=1... [2] https://www.ppc.go.jp/en/index.html https://www.ppc.go.jp/en/index.html [3] https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/b4383067ba5e14089768a47f386128cf957e3da2/images/000 https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/b4383067ba5e14089768a47f38... [4] https://www.webcartop.jp/2020/08/565475/ https://www.webcartop.jp/2020/08/565475/
- searchableguy 6y ago> The brother of someone I know did just that a few years ago. He went through some kind of midlife crisis and left his wife, children, and family business without a word. She tried to trace him through the police, but the police wouldn't cooperate because there was no sign of foul play. He was spotted by a relative a year or so later living in an apartment not too far away and has since moved back with his family. What possible middle life crisis can make people detach themselves from their family and kids for a year without telling them? Are there services to reintegrate these people with their family if it's a widely acknowledged problem?
- Hamuko 6y agoDo other countries not have laws that allow people to remain hidden? I remember this case from Finland. Police were asking for clues about a man named Janne after he had been missing for a week and a half. Some days later the police announced that they had been in contact with the man and that he was alive. However, he did not want to have his current location revealed and the police obeyed that. "People in Finland have the right to disappear. If a person wants to remain hidden, there's nothing the police can do about that" they said. The only thing they were able to tell his family was that he was still alive.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- searchableguy 6y agoInteresting. We definitely need that as a law everywhere. People want to escape from abusers and sharks all the time.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoThe police aren't the only people with investigate ability.
- kwhitefoot 6y ago> "People in Finland have the right to disappear. Really? In most European countries there is a requirement to register your home address with the state. See https://www.norden.org/en/info-norden/notifying-move-and-population-registration-finland https://www.norden.org/en/info-norden/notifying-move-and-pop... So you can hide your location from family but you do not have a general right to hide from the state. The same applies in all the Nordic countries.