3 ms·
This is already a solved problem, we tax income rather than wealth. I assumed it was clear from context the 90+% tax is an income tax. It only applies when they
by crazygringo 6y ago
This is already a solved problem, we tax income rather than wealth. I assumed it was clear from context the 90+% tax is an income tax. It only applies when they sell (or die, as inheritance tax).
So none of your concerns over who would have the money, or whether foreigners would gain ownership, would have any relevance.
But since you seem interested in wealth taxes, for people who advocate that instead, the strategy there is very different -- generally something like ~2% per year (2% yearly would add up to 70% after 60 years), which for public companies presents zero problem since the stock market is constantly purchasing shares anyways. And just like many companies have non-voting shares, selling those would prevent dilution of control.
- forrestthewoods 6y agoA 90% tax rate doesn’t actually mean the government collects that money. It just forces the money to be spent in different ways. Which is maybe a good idea! But that’s the actual end result. People love to quote US income tax rates of the past. But tax revenue to GDP has been almost perfectly flat since WW2. Despite huge fluctuations in personal income tax rates. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hauser%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hauser%27s_law
- crazygringo 6y agoThe fact that tax revenue to GDP has been flat doesn't really matter, because that masks the fact of progressive taxation. The whole point of taxing billionaires 90% is so we can tax the lower class close to 0%, or even spend more on them than we collect (through education, social services, health care, etc.). It's totally fine if the overall tax revenue to GDP remains unchanged. The point isn't necessarily to raise more money, it's to address inequality by creating a level playing field for each new generation of citizens. And yes, taxation pretty much necessarily distorts spending. But loopholes are not actually that hard to fix, if we want to fix them. If we tax income and inheritance, and close taxation loopholes around things like setting up trusts/charities, then that billionaire's wealth is going to end up being collected one way or another.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]