4 ms·
I definitely don't buy it either. The market has nothing to do with morality. It's simply a question of efficiency: are people as a whole better off, utility w
by crazygringo 6y ago
I definitely don't buy it either.
The market has nothing to do with morality. It's simply a question of efficiency: are people as a whole better off, utility wise? But as long as everyone is making voluntary, non-coerced trades (labor for $, $ for products), then by definition they are better off. There's no moral aspect to it, just economic efficiency/"progress".
But that doesn't mean you get to keep everything you make. The market is a tool, not an end. If you kept everything, there'd be no taxation, no government, no education, nothing else, and it would be a moral disaster. The moral element comes into play with taxation: because you (as a billionaire) benefit extraordinarily from the country's systems put into place -- contract enforcement, courts, roads, education of your workers, everything -- you are morally obligated to pay your "fair share" of that back.
The only people who claim people are entitled to 100% of the money they make are a subset of libertarians/anarchists. It's not a very popular opinion, since it makes society pretty much unworkable.
- pmontra 6y ago> But as long as everyone is making voluntary, non-coerced trades (labor for $, $ for products), then by definition they are better off. Add "correctly informed" and "able to understand the consequences" to that list. Examples: 1. Financial consultants propose to invest in high interest securities, "trust me they are safe", people invest and lose the money. 2. People lost years of life and tons of money commuting, then suddenly discovered that they can work from home. Many businesses benefitted from that, they are in trouble now. This at least was a common belief, shared by almost everybody. Most of us were wrong though.
- taneq 6y agoDid businesses really benefit from people not working remotely? It seems more to me like the problem was inertia rather than any zero-sum mechanic. Switching to predominantly remote is benefiting everybody.