4 ms·
> I prefer the idea that a billionaire is a market failure. Not at all -- the market is working exactly as intended (as long as it's not coming from externalit
by crazygringo 6y ago
> I prefer the idea that a billionaire is a market failure.
Not at all -- the market is working exactly as intended (as long as it's not coming from externalities, like pollution that's not being paid for).
What's failing isn't the market, but taxation. We should be celebrating billionaires because they've succeeded in delivering better, cheaper products than other people. But we should also be taxing them at 90+% by that point.
Again -- it's not market failure. It's taxation failure.
- coldtea 6y ago>as long as it's not coming from externalities, like pollution that's not being paid for When it comes to crazy wealth, most of it comes from externalities - from environmental to paying workers poorly.
- maest 6y ago> the market is working exactly as intended I'm not saying that's what you're saying, but a lot of people tend to treat the market as intrinsically morally correct. As in, if something is the outcome of the market working correctly, then that thing is the "correct" outcome. So, if billionaires appear as a result of the market doing its thing, then billionaries are morally entitled to their money. I'm not sure I buy that argument.
- crazygringo 6y agoI definitely don't buy it either. The market has nothing to do with morality. It's simply a question of efficiency: are people as a whole better off, utility wise? But as long as everyone is making voluntary, non-coerced trades (labor for $, $ for products), then by definition they are better off. There's no moral aspect to it, just economic efficiency/"progress". But that doesn't mean you get to keep everything you make. The market is a tool, not an end. If you kept everything, there'd be no taxation, no government, no education, nothing else, and it would be a moral disaster. The moral element comes into play with taxation: because you (as a billionaire) benefit extraordinarily from the country's systems put into place -- contract enforcement, courts, roads, education of your workers, everything -- you are morally obligated to pay your "fair share" of that back. The only people who claim people are entitled to 100% of the money they make are a subset of libertarians/anarchists. It's not a very popular opinion, since it makes society pretty much unworkable.
- pmontra 6y ago> But as long as everyone is making voluntary, non-coerced trades (labor for $, $ for products), then by definition they are better off. Add "correctly informed" and "able to understand the consequences" to that list. Examples: 1. Financial consultants propose to invest in high interest securities, "trust me they are safe", people invest and lose the money. 2. People lost years of life and tons of money commuting, then suddenly discovered that they can work from home. Many businesses benefitted from that, they are in trouble now. This at least was a common belief, shared by almost everybody. Most of us were wrong though.
- taneq 6y agoDid businesses really benefit from people not working remotely? It seems more to me like the problem was inertia rather than any zero-sum mechanic. Switching to predominantly remote is benefiting everybody.
- roenxi 6y agoI agree that it isn't a moral issue, but here is a perspective that goes hand in hand with the issues: Billionaires have by and large demonstrated the ability to take resources with millions of dollars and transform them into resources worth billions of dollars. That is evidence that they should have disproportionate power. They're obviously competent at creating wealth if given power. They compare favourably to their closest competitors in the social arena, politicians. When dealing with big name politicians they are doing well if they don't cause excess deaths in their tenures, don't accidental destroy the economy and they generally siphon wealth and opportunity to unimpressive insiders. There might be an equilibrium that is better, but there are a lot of equilibriums that are worse. If an Amazon-like entity is going to exist at all it makes sense for someone like Bezos to be running it. There are literally billions of people out there who would do a worse job than him. He does deserve some acknowledgement and support.
- forrestthewoods 6y ago> But we should also be taxing them at 90+% by that point. Many (most?) billionaire's wealth is tied up in the stock of companies they own. Presumably they should be required to sell their stock to give money to the government. What group of people do you expect to have the hundreds of billions, if not trillions, of dollars necessary to buy stock from company founders over the first decade? If I'm being honest that sounds like a great way to force American owned companies to sell control of their companies to foreign individuals and institutions.
- thundergolfer 6y agoThis seems like a strange issue to get hung up on. In the event that the government is receiving hundreds of billions in tax revenue, that can just give money to the public so that they can buy the stock, or just accept the stock as tax payment. This would help with the inequality problem of ~10% of the richest Americans owning 90% of all stock. You could even have a baby bonds program where isn’t of cash sitting in a trust there’s an ETF with a bunch of stock from taxed billionaires.
- forrestthewoods 6y agoOk so Bezos gives X% of his stock to the government per year. So either we’re actually socialists at that point or the US sells it to... somebody; so that cash can be given to or spent in the benefit of people who need actual money and not imaginary money. At some point you have to convert stock to cash. > This would help with the inequality problem of ~10% of the richest Americans owning 90% of all stock. Reducing the value of stock is certainly one way to reduce inequality. Of course that doesn’t _actually_ help anybody. Inequality is mostly, although not entirely, a second-order metric.
- crazygringo 6y agoThis is already a solved problem, we tax income rather than wealth. I assumed it was clear from context the 90+% tax is an income tax. It only applies when they sell (or die, as inheritance tax). So none of your concerns over who would have the money, or whether foreigners would gain ownership, would have any relevance. But since you seem interested in wealth taxes, for people who advocate that instead, the strategy there is very different -- generally something like ~2% per year (2% yearly would add up to 70% after 60 years), which for public companies presents zero problem since the stock market is constantly purchasing shares anyways. And just like many companies have non-voting shares, selling those would prevent dilution of control.