2 ms·
The ultrarich don't comsume as much of their wealth, whereas the poorer consume everything they make (aka "hand to mouth"). A 10,000,000/year consumption by a
by coldtea 6y ago
The ultrarich don't comsume as much of their wealth, whereas the poorer consume everything they make (aka "hand to mouth").
A 10,000,000/year consumption by a billionaire is an insignificant part of their wealth and their annual revenue, but still allows for an extravagant lifestyle.
A 40,000/year consumption by a working class person make barely allow them to make end meet, and it might be everything they made in that year (and they might even owe a lot as well).
So, taxing 20% on consumption, would net 2M on the billionaire (a laughable amount for them) and 8K for the working class person (which could be a matter of life or death for them, some health treatment, their kids going to college, etc.)
- el_nahual 6y agoConsumption can be taxed on a sliding, marginal scale, and it has no upper bound, unlike income tax which can't go above 100%
- weaksauce 6y agoit's staggering just how large a billion of something is... a million seconds is about a 11.5 days. a billion seconds is about 32 years. a few million dollars to a billionaire is next to nothing.
- ropable 6y agoSo don't tax the first (e.g.) $25,000 of a person's annual income/consumption, then tax the remainder at a progressive rate.
- coldtea 6y agoEven if we tax it at a progressive rate, the total consumption tax paid by the rich will be only nominally, not percentage wise, bigger than the middle class/poor, because their consumption doesn't even come close to their revenue/wealth (aside from the fact that it's also hidden behind 2000 shell companies whose assets they use for personal use).
- dahfizz 6y agoWe need to separate the location of the tax and how progressive the tax is. They are orthogonal. Any tax can be made more progressive in implementation (high deductions, tiered rates, etc). Impact on poor vs wealthy shouldn't be a consideration when deciding what we want to tax.