8 ms·
I'm sure not all the ultrarich are like this, but so often I can't get over how truly awful these people are, especially for a man who made his Midas fortune in
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I'm sure not all the ultrarich are like this, but so often I can't get over how truly awful these people are, especially for a man who made his Midas fortune in something that has no net benefit to society (yeah, yeah, liquidity liquidity, blah, blah, still think it's total BS that high frequency traders are anything but leaches on capital markets).
- fxtentacle 6y agoOddly enough, the more tangible benefits to society a job provides, the less it is paid for. It's almost like a "your job is not bullshit" salary deduction. From bakery to supermarket to food delivery, pretty much all of the people I interact with daily are paid badly.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoYeah, I have no idea what the solution is, but I was pretty down during the pandemic that all the "essential worker" jobs that we truly depend upon, e.g. delivery, grocery, sanitation, many (but obviously not all) health care workers, etc., are paid shit, and further more often have to put their health on the line to work, while honestly a huge number of highly paid tech worker jobs (that now get to happen from the safety and comfort of home) could disappear and society wouldn't notice.
- jdkee 6y agoTax wealth, not income.
- DuskStar 6y agoTax consumption, not wealth or income.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoGenerally that's considered regressive (so we all have to eat and eat about the same amount of food each day.) For jeff bezos the Tesco Extra Special range is a rounding error whereas for the bottom 10% it's a large fraction of daily income. taxing that basically taxes a large fraction of their daily income.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoTax consumption progressively.
- Thorrez 6y agoHow would you implement that? Isn't consumption tax generally a sales tax? At the time of a specific sale it would be hard to find out the right tax rate.
- dahfizz 6y agoYou could have a large personal deduction. You could tax everything at the lowest rate at the point of sale but make people do the accounting and pay their real rate if they are in a higher rate. The "tax" at the point of sale would act like income withholdings do now. You could categorize good so that yatchs have a much higher rate than groceries. You could also come up with an average price for good so that really expensive e.g. clothes and cars are taxed at a higher rate than they are for "normal" goods. All it takes is some creativity.
- Thorrez 6y agoIt requires people to save receipts on everything they buy. People (in states that charge sales tax) already sort of are required to do this for goods they buy online that don't charge tax. The vast vast vast majority of people (every single person I've asked) evade this tax. I try to pay the tax myself (I'm the only person I know who does this) by going through online receipts, putting them in a spreadsheet and calculating the tax. I know I'm missing some though, I buy too much stuff. There are even people I know who don't just evade the tax out of laziness, but evade it intentionally to save money, intentionally buying stuff online because it doesn't charge tax. My point is that this will be a very large amount of effort for people, and there will be a large amount of tax evasion due to both laziness and greed.
- godzillabrennus 6y agoExcept we don’t tax non-profits and the rich are already smart enough to have trusts, foundations, a string of 506(x) variation entities, already at their disposal. We need a tax system overhaul but I’m afraid no one has the political will to do it before stagflation creeps in from the current fed policies and bankrupts is all anyway.
- gameman144 6y agoI'm confused as to the motivation here; taxing wealth as opposed to taxing income seems to disincentivize saving and investment as opposed to consumption. Some consumption is definitely necessary, but I'd argue that savings and investment are also extremely important to an efficient economy. From the practical perspective, if one has the same lifetime earnings as another, they will have paid the same amount of tax over their lifetime. Why should they be taxed again for choosing to save or invest that money? I'm all for taxing any gain once it's actually converted into income (and while I understand the motivation behind different capital gains rates, I'm not super opposed to taxing capital gains as income.) Taxing wealth always seems to me to be explicitly taxing the choice to invest in the future or build something, though.
- Viliam1234 6y agoAll taxes have an impact on something. Taxing income disincentivizes circulation of money within community. When A does some work for B, B does some work for C, C does some work for D, and each of them pays a fraction of the income to the govenment, after a few steps the money effectively disappears from the community. The only way to get it back is to do some work for someone outside the community. But maybe the people A, B, C, D are effective at helping each other locally, but not really competitive at providing work outside the community. With no income tax, they could trade with each other. With income tax, their choices are either gray market or poverty. Wealth tax hurts the startups. Income tax hurts the local communities. Land tax hurts the rent seekers. The rent seekers and startups have greater lobbying power than poor communities, and our laws reflect that.
- snarf21 6y agoWe could get rid of capital gains tax and tax it as normal income. We could also get rid of like kind exchange. This money could be used to lower or eliminate income taxes for the poor. It is all about incentivizing how we want capital to be invested for the benefit of society. Today we've decided that shareholders are primary for public companies. The stock market is at all time highs but it comes with a cost.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoYeah, when it comes to capital gains I always thought it made the most sense to tax it as normal income but to index the basis against inflation.
- herpderperator 6y agoIn the US, investments held less than a year are taxed at normal income.
- pkaye 6y agoIsn't Biden proposing to do that for those who earn more than $1M. Not sure how likely that will pass though.
- innagadadavida 6y agoHow about we abolish all taxes and just tax the total wealth? That will give people the incentive to work as opposed to making a quick buck and retiring.
- bluedevil2k 6y agoHow many people are looking to make a quick buck and retire? The people who are billionaires are billionaires because they are super competitive and super hard workers. Gates, Bezos, Jobs - you think they worked 8 hours a day when they were growing their companies? No, those guys are driven to succeed and that doesn’t just go away when you make X dollars.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xorcist 6y agoMedical doctors are paid pretty well, and that's a real job if there ever was one. It's interesting to see how that profession has held up so well, in almost all parts of the world, while others have slowly inflated supply to lower payments.
- coldtea 6y ago>Medical doctors are paid pretty well, and that's a real job if there ever was one. On the other hand, the health industry (from drugs to hospitals) makes a shittoan of money, and most of it is by pushing BS on people and (in the US) by overcharging 10x simple procedures...
- dahfizz 6y ago> while others have slowly inflated supply to lower payments. Could you give some examples? Real personal income has been rising pretty steadily for as long as the data has been collected [1]. So the median person earns more as the years go on, not less. [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N
- xorcist 6y agoRelative to other jobs, not in absolute terms (which isn't very meaningful to compare). Lots of specialized jobs start out well paid and then spread out over time as more enter the profession. Airline pilots, for example, used to be a lucrative job but isn't now. School teachers used to be paid well. Engineering is a bit of a mixed bag, but there are plenty of examples there too. Medical doctors is the common exception to this.
- rebelos 6y agoYour observations are coincidental and skewed by cognitive bias. A neurosurgeon is one obvious counterexample. The predominant determinant of labor compensation is substitutability.
- Maarten88 6y ago> The predominant determinant of labor compensation is substitutability. Which proves the article right: the guy labored hard to move the proceeds of his partners work into a forest of trusts that only he knows and that only benefits him personally, by statute. He can't be substituted anymore!
- rebelos 6y agoLabor compensation is a subset of compensation in the abstract (or, even more broadly, "return on time and capital"). Importantly, in most economies, it's typically set by employers hiring within an efficient labor market.
- brmgb 6y agoI might have believed you before the covid epidemic but I think it definitely proved that wrong. We have a dearth of essential people. Nurses are a perfect example. Yet they keep being paid like crap. It is becoming clearer by the day that the job market is not an efficient market at all. Why keep pretending ?
- rebelos 6y agoFirst of all, everything is running remarkably smoothly given the circumstances. The Covid-19 statistics are largely a consequence of people acting individually out of self interest and ignorance, yielding negative systemic externalities, and not a dysfunction of the healthcare system. Furthermore, if you think about how insurance risk pooling works, it's quite easy to see how an insurance-backed, profit-motivated healthcare system may not be the best vehicle to address a systemic health problem afflicting the entire population. You may recall AIG as a rough analogue for this situation. Or even entities insuring against natural disasters in California. The government has to step in to prevent failure. And then we have the most obvious counterargument to your flawed thesis: why would labor compensation go up during a recession with high unemployment and considerable attendant macroeconomic instability? Those factors have contributed to dramatically increased substitutability and thus quite naturally suppress wage growth.
- newguy1234 6y agoLabor is not valued based on the "benefits to society" it provides. It is valued based on supply and demand. The low paid jobs are jobs that basically anyone can do with minimal education or on the job training. If those jobs were harder to do then they would certainly be paid more.
- pixelbash 6y agoSome of the hardest jobs are underpaid, and level of education means less than it used to. Nurses and scientists for example. Partner is a microbiologist PHD graduate and starting salary wouldn't be much different my self taught first coding job - not that getting a job right now is really possible anyway.
- lisper 6y ago> I'm sure not all the ultrarich are like this What makes you so sure? At some level of wealth, it is essentially zero effort to engage in these shenanigans; you just hire someone to do it for you. The more money you have, the higher the return on this investment. At some point it becomes deeply irrational not to do it.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoIt's only irrational not to do it if you're a completely self-centered asshole who derives no internal happiness from seeing others thrive. I can't believe the marginal increase in quality of life, happiness or life satisfaction is any different between someone worth $100 million compared to billions. If I was married to someone for decades, and decided to leave her for a newer model (shitty to begin with but bear with me), I would feel the value of leaving on at least decent terms would be worth a couple percent of my wealth.
- seibelj 6y agoJust to play devil’s advocate we have no idea what is between this couple, or any couple for that matter, and are being presented with her side as he is silent. Sometimes people break up, and one person doesn’t want the other to get a single penny, whether they have $1 or $10 billion.
- thrav 6y agoThe end around this is convincing yourself that you’ll spend it better than the government would. There is a famous clip of Michael Dell saying as much at Davos. Bezos and Musk think they’re saving the human race by deploying their capitol towards the pursuit of life in space. Gates is attempting to make various diseases extinct. Soros is attempting to bring about a world more closely aligned to the philosophical ideals that shaped his early education. The richest of the rich usually have some pet project that they think is the most important thing in the world.
- Shorel 6y agoAnd Gates, Bezos, and Musk are probably right. If anything, it is a much more efficient way to spend some resources. Instead of filling the bellies of thousands of red tape enabling workers, or spending that much money in pharmaceutical advertising.
- el_nahual 6y agoHere's a question. I find it abhorrent that 15%-30% of my tax dollars go to funding the military, dhs, nsa, etc. If one is a pacifist, is there an argument to be made that minimizing taxes is in fact the ethical thing to do?
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoNo. Spend more of that money on lobbying, to get funding for the military, dhs, nsa, etc cut. For added bonus morality points, spend even more money providing aid or employment training for those who lose jobs in the process. Do not get super clever to pay less taxes, leave those who cannot avail themselves to such methods to pay more (or the government to go further into debt), and call that morality. Don't kid us, and don't kid yourself.
- egypturnash 6y agoYour tax dollars also go to the social safety net, education, funding the arts, maintaining roads, keeping parks nice places to visit, and a whole bunch of other stuff that is generally not in conflict with pacifism. Should these babies be thrown out with the military bathwater?
- djKianoosh 6y agoThe majority of these dollars in the US go to military bathwater. Perhaps there may be a way for citizens to earmark their preferences directly for where they feel their tax dollars should go. Yeah yeah go vote of course. But Congress acts too slow. I am talking about a more direct system, maybe with limits sure. But as it is, Congress has a lot of the purse strings, and maybe individual citizens could have more say-so with an improved system.
- ashtonkem 6y agoEarmarking your own dollars for what you support might make you feel better, but it won’t change anything. Money is fungible by design, every dollar of yours that’s earmarked for welfare programs frees up someone else’s for the military. Sure, if everyone did that it would have an impact, but that seems pretty improbable.
- dcolkitt 6y agoHonest question? Do you believe it’s possible to sustain anything close to the levels of consumer wealth seen in US, Europe, or Australia without liquid and efficient financial capital markets? If so, how come since the industrial revolution, the wealthiest economies have always had the most liquid and sophisticated financial markets? (With the possible exception of a few natural resource states) Have you considered the possibility that financial liquidity is as essential for high consumer living standards as reliable electrical grids or fair court systems? Because the majority of economists would certainly say so.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThere is more than ample financial market liquidity without needing some of the brightest people in the world spending their time trying to shave half a millisecond off trade execution times.
- ghufran_syed 6y agoHow do you measure if the liquidity is "ample"? And does that necessarily mean it would stay "ample" if market volatility went up?
- dcolkitt 6y ago"There is more than ample database performance without needing some of the brightest people in the world spending their time trying to shave half a millisecond off query execution times" Imagine someone making such a statement, without even bothering to talk to someone with actual expertise in the field of database technology. It's fine to be a layman on the topic, but it's not a good look to presume that you no more than the domain experts without even bothering to study their positions.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoFirst of all, I have experience with HFT, so I know what I'm talking about. Second, your analogy doesn't make sense. HFT is only enabled as a byproduct of how electronic exchanges order their trades. They could just as easily bulk all orders by the second and then randomly order them to eliminate the benefit of, for example, building as close as possible to the exchange so you have a speed-of-light transit time benefit over your competitors.
- neximo64 6y agoNot to be critical but this sounds a bit like cognitive dissonance.
- closeparen 6y ago“No net benefit to society” is your personal value judgement. Other people necessarily made different value judgements when they exchanged billions of dollars in value for those things.
- thewarrior 6y agoWell gangsters, heroin smugglers and hit men probably got paid billions of dollars too. Pablo Escobar was one of the richest men in the world. And most of it was not stock but actual cash. Hence the fact that billions were paid for something does not in any way prove that it adds value to society.
- closeparen 6y agoHow has the whole “protect people from their preferences about drugs” thing been working out for us?