5 ms·
I have a theory that when news orgs nurture soft authoritarians (Bush/Patriot Act, Obama/espionage charges for whistleblowers) their weakened journalistic insti
by WarOnPrivacy 6y ago
I have a theory that when news orgs nurture soft authoritarians (Bush/Patriot Act, Obama/espionage charges for whistleblowers) their weakened journalistic instincts leave a vacuum that's easy for harder line authoritarians to fill.
That's what I believed happened in the US. I wonder if a similar process happened in Belarus.
- jwilber 6y agoCurious why the onus is on journalists and not complacent political parties or branches/members of government. Sure, newsrooms can sway public opinion, but they’re also basically the only reason we know about those problems to begin with. Blaming them seems akin to treating a symptom, not the cause. Not trying to disagree. I do think journalists today are partially responsible for our current situation - especially White House correspondents, whom are wholly ineffective at challenging any statements from the president or calling out outright lies.
- spamizbad 6y agoAlso thinking journalists are at the root of society's ills is probably a sign you're buying into authoritarian propaganda.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoAuthoritarian propaganda alleges that journalists are fabricating news. I'm not alleging fraud but neglect and passive collusion. That is, journalists are allowing certain US Gov misdeeds to go largely unreported while amplifying US Gov voices w/o ever vetting if official claims are true.
- spamizbad 6y agoA lot of misdeeds are documented but nobody is really outraged by them. There's certainly lots of bad stuff happening that doesn't have a legion of takery behind it to drive a certain narrative but... the reporting is there.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago>A lot of misdeeds are documented but nobody is really outraged by them ... the reporting is there. I'd like to rephrase your assertion, to bring it more in line with reality: A minuscule percentage of known US Gov misdeeds get reported, generally as a one-off novelty. The story then becomes so forgotten that it doesn't even get referenced for context in any future reporting. Meanwhile top Gov officials get miles of free press time to make headline-grabbing claims, that have no meaningful truth. Because zero independent experts are EVER consulted, the official never gets challenged. Dozens of actual experts reach out to set the record straight - which has no effect at all on present or future reporting. Free of any press oversight at all, the official is free to continue to make patently false claims, pretty much for the duration of his tenure. He'll then revolving-door to the private sector & get invited onto news segments as a guest expert, to vouch for whatever Gov claim needs an instant witness.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> Curious why the onus is on journalists and not complacent political parties or branches/members of government. It's because the primary power to oust corrupt officials rests with the public. Likewise for the power to push broad policy change. US Gov agencies have been accumulating inappropriate power and commit atrocities (esp post 2001), largely w/o any pushback or coverage from news orgs. It hasn't been zero coverage. For example, Edward Snowden dragged reluctant news outlets into doing their jobs for a little while. But the vast, vast bulk of Gov misdeeds that are right out in the open, rarely get even a nod - while a small selection of stories get huge parallel coverage, from coast to coast.
- Ericson2314 6y agoWhat? There was no descent from liberalism in Belarus. It's been a dictatorship since shortly after the fall of the USSR. This is more like if Hu Jintao just became Xi Jingping.
- sam_lowry_ 6y agoUnfortunately, Lukashenka is closer to Pol Pot now than to Xi Jingping.
- mhh__ 6y agoMaybe, but at least some journalists have been spot on about the way trump is going from Day 1 and that hasn't made any difference. He is still insulting war dead, threatening the validity of election, not even interested in solving COVID, and much more that I'm sure that you're already aware of. His approval ratings are at about 40%, that's not good but 40% is almost saint-like by (say) french standards. That's despite journalists reporting on this near constantly.
- Chris2048 6y agoTrump isn't rated in a vacuum - There is too much hypocrisy in the opposition, starting with sticking with Biden after the allegation of sexual assault.
- mhh__ 6y agoThe allegations against Biden have almost no water at all. Unless they are waiting to use Reade as an October surprise they wasted it. She made an allegation, and more specifically said she filed a complaint. The Biden team tried to publicly confirm its existence (i.e. they don't think it does), but the senate cannot publish it without Reade's permission. She later said she actually didn't publish a complaint. I would be inclined to believe her if she could keep her story straight and generally not seem a bit unreliable.
- Chris2048 6y ago> The allegations against Biden have almost no water at all. Holds no water? That doesn't seem to be accounted for in "I believe women" when Biden et al were warring with Republicans in general, not just Trump. Compare and contrast Reade & Biden with Christine Bleakley Ford & Kavanaugh, which quite a few publications have already.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nullsense 6y agoWell they stuck with Trump after he "grabbed her by the pussy".
- rsynnott 6y agoBelarus was never _not_ authoritarian. This isn’t really new.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoAre you alleging that Belarus isn't experiencing a meaningful change in policy direction?