3 ms·
>What is your argument here? A lot of countries do it, therefore it's okay? no, therefore it doesn't meaningfully change the relationship to the state, unless
by Barrin92 6y ago
>What is your argument here? A lot of countries do it, therefore it's okay?
no, therefore it doesn't meaningfully change the relationship to the state, unless one agrees that those countries are somehow qualitatively different than the UK or before they had IDs. The author tries to appeal to fear and is being dramatic. Arguments along the lines of "this will fundamentally change X" are just rhetoric to use people's scepticism of change. It's the same kind of thing you see in US politics when some politician goes "and they'll take your freedoms, and your meat, and your guns" regardless of what the actual legislation says
>Can you tell me why this is preferable to having someone look at an ID and verify it with their eyeballs?
because when I order something online there's not necessarily anyone there to look at it with their eyeballs, and to be honest I trust an (ideally open) algorithm more than a random person. Just a year ago[1] a cop was caught sniffing around in a database and stalking women under the guise of police business. So if you ask me, eliminating people from data processing is a feature.
[1]https://gizmodo.com/cop-uses-police-database-to-creep-on-over-100-women-in-1833156806 https://gizmodo.com/cop-uses-police-database-to-creep-on-ove...
- gruez 6y ago>because when I order something online there's not necessarily anyone there to look at it with their eyeballs Isn't that problematic because all Timmy has to do get his hands on booze is to lay his eyes on someone's ID? I don't see how the scheme is any more secure than validating the order wasn't placed with a prepaid credit card (presumably only adults have access to non-prepaid credit cards). It makes much more sense to do the verification on delivery, rather than when you're placing the order.
- cinntaile 6y agoIt's not that easy. To use someone's electronic ID as verification you either need their ID card and their ID pin code and probably access to their computer as well or mobile phone (+ access to it) and their ID pin code.