4 ms·
> The mainstream news reporting on Portland (and other regional rioting) got to the point where they were bald-faced lying about peaceful protests standing in f
by sneak 6y ago
> The mainstream news reporting on Portland (and other regional rioting) got to the point where they were bald-faced lying about peaceful protests standing in front of burning buildings.
It’s a little bit cliche, but also true: to judge a protest by its most violent elements but to decline to do the same of the police is the language of the oppressor.
Everyone I saw celebrating 100 days was celebrating 100 days of sustained protesting—not violence. Those same people have bemoaned the escalation of violence that happens against the protests each night by police.
The fact that some of the protestors have turned violent is, to me, entirely reasonable considering the sustained months of police violence that have been inflicted upon them illegally. If the state wants people to respect the laws and remain peaceful, it needs to clean its own house of violent criminals first.
Ironically, that’s why the protests happened in the first place. Let’s not forget cause and effect.
- rbecker 6y ago> It’s a little bit cliche, but also true: to judge a protest by its most violent elements but to decline to do the same of the police is the language of the oppressor. Then lucky us to have the news correct our judgement by withholding key facts. Edit: When replying to my extremely short comment, I would be grateful if you took the time to first read it. The single sentence I wrote neither claims the attempts at censorship were perfect, nor that the police were perfect little angels, nor does it equate anything (such as violence by one side) with anything else.
- sneak 6y agoI’ve seen no shortage of pearl-clutching over breathlessly reported videos of almost all of the violence so far. Some buildings and vehicles have burned. On the other hand, children have been shot in the face with projectiles and suffered TBIs. Police have permanently blinded people and shattered bones. I think it is a mistake to even begin to equate the amount of police violence that has been inflicted with the violence that has resulted from rioting. The police have been inflicting permanent injuries indiscriminately on anyone present. There is no comparison or remotely corresponding events in terms of violence from the protests, with the exception perhaps of the people who attacked Rittenhouse.
- amadeuspagel 6y ago> Some buildings and vehicles have burned. And some people have been murdered: https://apnews.com/864cb5c14ba08b4411a16577042d0773 https://apnews.com/864cb5c14ba08b4411a16577042d0773
- sneak 6y agoAt least one of the deaths mentioned in that URL... was shot by police. Recall also that these protests began because the police in the US have murdered thousands in the last few centuries. Anti-police-violence protests would have to sustain dozens of related deaths every single night for months to even approach the level of depravity exercised by police for years.
- amadeuspagel 6y ago> At least one of the deaths mentioned in that URL... was shot by police. The URL clearly refutes the parent comment that the only damage done by the protestors are vehicles and buildings getting set on fire. > Recall also that these protests began because the police in the US have murdered thousands in the last few centuries. > Anti-police-violence protests would have to sustain dozens of related deaths every single night for months to even approach the level of depravity exercised by police for years. If we're going to police violence in the last few centuries, surely we should also include riots in the last few centuries? I'm pretty certain that more people were murdered by rioters then the police during that time.
- sneak 6y ago> The URL clearly refutes the parent comment that the only damage done by the protestors are vehicles and buildings getting set on fire. You seem to assert that the murders itemized in that URL were committed by protesters. It's not reasonable to assume that any murders that happen at or near protests were caused by protestors and not opportunistic criminals that aren't invested in the protest one way or another, just as it's not reasonable to assume that police are justified in shooting anyone whose hands they can't see. The violence imposed by police is documented, because police are in uniform uniform, and zero non-cops are wearing those uniforms. There is no plain way to distinguish between opportunistic-criminals-present-at-a-protest and protesters. Indeed, during all of this, it has been documented that sometimes police have engaged in violence whilst wearing all black and not identified as police.
- cochne 6y agoIt's not as if these elements don't exist on the side of the police either. Check out the article "Teargassed, beaten up, arrested: what freedom of the press looks like in the US right now", for example. For either side, the actions are in my opinion completely unwarranted by either side, and just wrong, but it didn't start with the protesters.
- jpxw 6y agoThe “language of the oppressor” is the language of protestors forcing people to not film.
- youareostriches 6y agoDo the protesters control two branches of the federal government? Or indeed, any government at all? Do the protesters control the economic system by monopolizing most property and wealth? Do the protesters have access to a vast war-making apparatus?
- zaroth 6y ago> If the state wants people to respect the laws and remain peaceful, it needs to clean its own house of violent criminals first. No, the people demand that everyone respect the laws and remain peaceful. To that end, the people fund and enact a police force to protect life and property, and to apprehend suspected criminals. I don’t think it’s accurate to say that “some of the protestors have turned violent.” There is a contingent which is using violence as a specific strategy, against property and against police as well as bystanders who may not agree with them.
- watwut 6y agoAnd when the people think the police is endangering their safety, does the job badly and abuses power given to them or breaks the law, what are people supposed to do?
- compiler-guy 6y agoAt least one thing that you do is allow others the freedom you want for yourself.
- watwut 6y agoWhat freedom you have in mind? Afaik the exchange was 1.) about whether police can be blanket assumed to be the "good guys" due to that being presumed original intent. 2.) Whether and how ir is legitimate to protest if they are not "good" in practice. I am not asking for any special freedom. I do find second question interesting and complicated. I do have own answer to question one (namely that blanket trust is super naive of course low paid force with few weak checks will end up having bad actors in it and it is then question of pruning them out or not).
- compiler-guy 6y agoThe freedom I have in mind is the freedom to film in public.
- landryraccoon 6y ago
- josteink 6y ago> considering the sustained months of police violence that have been inflicted upon them illegally What part about the police stopping a violent riot which has been going on for months to end is illegal? I realize it depends on who you ask these days, but to me it sounds like they are doing their job, to ensure law and order.
- watwut 6y agoI mean, the protests did not stopped and generally got worst. The situation was not calming down over time. And not just that, people died due to conflicting groups comming in and cops failed to stop them but before and after killing. If someone was ensuring law and order, that someone completely failed.
- scythe 6y ago> to judge a protest by its most violent elements but to decline to do the same of the police is the language of the oppressor. Reason has had a running police brutality tracker for decades. You're mad at the wrong magazine.
- vidarh 6y agoFrankly I'm impressed things haven't descended into far worse than what has happened so far. Most of the demonstrators are showing an incredible level of restraint.
- sneak 6y agoI agree. I think the police are, too; I expected to have seen some Kent State-style attacks by now given how insanely violent and trigger-happy they've been. This is not to minimize the tremendous blunt-force and chemical injuries they've incurred in any way, but I'm still surprised the police haven't caused more of their usual style of shooting deaths.