5 ms·
Argh! Yes, there's a lot of empty space in the U.S. but land area is not the limiting factor on population growth, and never has been. At the moment the limit
by lisper 6y ago
Argh! Yes, there's a lot of empty space in the U.S. but land area is not the limiting factor on population growth, and never has been. At the moment the limiting factor appears to be planet-wide carbon emissions, and we are already way past the point of sustainability with respect to that. We need to be talking about reducing the world's population, otherwise there will just be that many more people who have to suffer through the climate apocalypse that is surely coming.
- kiba 6y agoIt is rich people that pollute the most, so our objective should be focused on reducing negative externalities, especially reducing excessive consumption(which correspond to pollution) that don't contribute to our quality of life. Remember, the sun gives more energy in an hour to the earth than our entire civilization consume in an entire year. It's clearly not a resource problem.
- edoceo 6y agoWhat if we eat the rich?
- kiba 6y agoBy rich, I meant the American people are the rich.
- HenryKissinger 6y agoWarren Buffett is 50% bodyfat. Bill Gates is like 20%. Bezos, Zuck, and Elon are like 10%. There is a lot of variability for the meat content of the rich.
- mdorazio 6y agoRich people pollute the most, but that means that as non-rich people become richer (as they are rapidly now doing as a result of globalization), pollution increases substantially over time. Likely at a higher rate than you can offset with externality pricing because good luck getting developing nations to agree to that.
- kangaroozach 6y agoDon’t rich people also drive the economy? They buy lots of goods and services from other people. They own businesses which employ people. They invest capital in income producing business that create value and employ people. They donate money which helps others (albeit for tax benefits). And if they park their money in cash in their backyard then they are reducing the circulates money supply which slows inflation and keeps prices of burritos for the Plebians from doubling every 10 years as we have grown accustomed to. What can rich people do that is not helpful to the economy (ie other people)? Even money spent on fancy meals, Ferrari’s, yachts all keep regular people and their families fed! It’s such a fallacy to point a our fingers at the rich!
- kiba 6y agoI meant something more mundane like inefficient land use policies, which mandates consumption of motor vehicles by which only a wealthy society likes ours can afford. Arguably, the consumption of those goods doesn't really contribute to the well being of our society, rich or poor.
- damnyou 6y agoIf your priors are oriented toward anti-natalism, this is the logical argument to make. Mine are not. I think anti-natalism is a failure state. I haven't heard any compelling arguments about why we shouldn't try our very best to innovate our way out of our crises instead. Of course, innovation means reorganizing the entire world economy around R&D, and that means (among other things) throwing the gates open to any immigrant with talent. Too many Einsteins are stuck in countries with failed institutions, where their talents can't be harnessed. It is critical for the survival of humanity to try and get as many of them to our shores as possible, and do the research we desperately need done.
- lisper 6y ago> I haven't heard any compelling arguments about why we shouldn't try our very best to innovate our way out of our crises instead. Innovation and population reduction (or at least stabilization) are not mutually exclusive. > reorganizing the entire world economy around R&D Yeah. Good luck with that. > It is critical for the survival of humanity to try and get as many of them to our shores as possible Why? Is there some law of physics that prevents innovation from happening outside the borders of the United States?
- damnyou 6y agoNot a law of physics, no, but obviously empirical evidence suggests that the US has the greatest scientific output in the world. Other countries can build up their institutions too, but the US is desperate for research and engineering talent.
- Thorrez 6y ago> We need to be talking about reducing the world's population That's going to happen. Look at the table on the right: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_fertility_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_fertility_rate Dropping dropping dropping. The global replacement rate is 2.33, soon we'll be below that.