13 ms·
Just because it's there doesn't mean you should use it
- theamk 6y agoReally, worrying about 20 amp in a 15 amp circuit? If one likes to worry about such things, there are much scarier things: unswitched extension cords [0]. One 15 amp plug in input, three 15-amp outlets on outputs. Sold in most stores and used very widely. Nothing illegal about it. Plugs into 15 amp rated outlet, wire itself is rated for just 13 amps, and you can pull up to 45 amps in the worst case (like if you plug in three electric kettles). [0] https://www.homedepot.com/p/GE-12-ft-2-Wire-16-Gauge-Polarized-Indoor-Extension-Cord-White-51954/203806535 https://www.homedepot.com/p/GE-12-ft-2-Wire-16-Gauge-Polariz...
- HarryHirsch 6y agoOur fire guy didn't like the unfused kind of extension cords much. One can understand why, you overload the electric lead and hope that the breaker is thrown before the insulation burns through.
- noizejoy 6y agoWouldn’t the breaker trip if you try to suck 45 amps through a 15 or 20 amp breaker?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kaetemi 6y agoAfter a minute, I think. Depends on your breaker rating. 20 amps on a 15 amp breaker will take a while to trip. You will have wiring damage.
- namibj 6y agoOver here in Germany we call the breakers Leitungsschutzschalter, which translates to wiring protection switch. They're specifically sized to protect the wiring in an overload situation, both gradual overloads and short circuits. The main issue is actually with the slightly-less trigger-happy breakers (class D) needing a sufficiently low resistance on the output to ensure that the magnetic trigger is both reliably triggered if you short the outlet, yet reliably not triggered by the current spike allowed from it's class. They trigger between 10 and 20 times the nominal rating, and 16 A is the typical circuit choice here. Ensuring that you reliably hit 320 A through a long circuit isn't the easiest/cheapest thing.
- watermelon0 6y agoClass B should be used for home use, and all domestic appliances should not trigger it. C/D are more appropriate for industrial use, where wiring and devices are designed beforehand, and people (ideally) won't just join together extension cords, and put multiple electric motors on it.
- namibj 6y agoC is quite typical for new installations due to the abundance of SMPS's, which can easily cause issues after a power loss due to the combined inrush current. But yeah, D is indeed rare, and not typically found in domestic installations.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoLaymans simply say "Sicherung".
- esoterae 6y agoIf that were true, wouldn't UL refuse to certify them?
- bigiain 6y agoHow many of the things with UL stamped/moulded into them that are available for sale on AliExpress do you suppose UL have ever even seen, never mind certified?
- jasomill 6y agoAnd if quantity and type of receptacles are intended to be a form of overcurrent protection, wouldn't the UL refuse to certify a duplex 5-15R receptacle for use on a 15 A circuit? The fact that they do not leads (non-electrician) me to believe that outlet types differ to prevent unintentionally plugging devices into inappropriate circuits, not to prevent intentional abuse. The present example is just a band-aid fix for cases where lower-current devices are connected in through some intermediate wiring (UPS, extension cord, RV power system, etc.) with a plug consistent with its own, higher ampacity, and in this application, seems no more prone to abuse than a garden-variety 15 A duplex receptacle on a 15 A circuit.
- ses1984 6y agoIsn't the breaker supposed to protect the damage? If it doesn't, why not just make the breaker more sensitive?
- bleepblorp 6y ago15 amp Schneider QO breakers are rated to trip in between 3 and 9 seconds in response to a 45 amp load. They are rated to trip a 20 amp load within 50-300 seconds.[0] [0] https://schneider-electric.app.box.com/s/cgxddrh26v9tpd48d2k21m4zb8hwti0j/file/262864157253 https://schneider-electric.app.box.com/s/cgxddrh26v9tpd48d2k...
- labawi 6y agoUnless your wiring was damaged or sketchy, it will have no issue taking 20 amps for a while. Problem is a (small) chance it could in fact cause issues, possibly fires, possibly at a later date. People don't usually count consumption of their devices, so plugging in pretty much anything that the circuit breaker will take is a fairly common occurrence.
- ThrustVectoring 6y agoIf everything is working correctly, yes. If things aren't working correctly, you get an electrical fire.
- Lammy 6y agoDepending on the age and quality of wiring there may be “hot spots” that can start a fire before there’s enough draw to trip the breaker. Old residential aluminum wiring is terribly dangerous for this reason. Corroded wire splices can do it too. That’s why I always solder my romex junctions! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminum_building_wiring#Older_homes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminum_building_wiring#Older...
- asddubs 6y agosoldering electrical wiring is really not a good idea. just use wagos
- josuepeq 6y agoAgree, Wago’s Lever Nuts especially are a game changer. Those DIYers who reject the “licensed electrician and I need a permit” model could benefit most from them - they’re almost foolproof. Instead they’re expensive, hard to find as Lowe’s/Home Depot don’t sell them, and not too many average people are familiar with them. I won’t ever buy plain wire nuts again unless it’s to cap a single wire.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y ago>> ...expensive What do you expect? It's German engineering :-)
- hinkley 6y agoRelative lost his whole house to old wiring in the attic. Staples, aging plastic, and thermal cycling. Roof was engulfed before the smoke alarms went off.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoSoldering those is forbidden here nowadays. Has to be crimped with a metal jacket around the ends.
- kaetemi 6y agoYes, but if all the wires are rated 15A, and the breaker is 15A or less, there's no issue. The problem case is putting equipment onto a 20A breaker using 15A wires and plugs. Or putting 20A equipment on a 15A breaker and wiring. The breaker won't trip immediately. Things will heat up slowly until the breaker trips, and you will have damage.
- theamk 6y agoIf you follow the link I showed, you'd see that the wires are actually rated 13 amperes, less than maximum capacity of the outlet. So it is not that uncommon to have unsafe wiring combinations -- be it 20A equipment on 15A wiring, or 15A equipment on 13A wiring. Neither is illegal, for better of for worse. Know the specs of your equipment if you deal with non-trivial electrical power.
- XorNot 6y agoWires are generally not rated for any specific current - the insulation is rated for a certain thermal load, and then electricians have a bunch of look up tables for the environment, run length and current to determine what gauge to use.
- Galanwe 6y agoI see nothing worrying here, this is pretty standard to me. You have a single 15A input and multiple 15A output, but you cannot use all the outputs at 15A at the same time. As long as you use it on regular domestic outlets you will be limited by the 15A of your breaker anyway. This is the same as all the USB hubs chargers. They often have 5 outputs rated 2A each, but the whole hub limits you to 2A total.
- bleepblorp 6y agoAt 15 amp circuit breaker will trip in 3-10 seconds if confronted with a 45 amp load. The number of sockets on an extension cord is immaterial to the available current just as is the number of receptacles on a circuit. Putting 12 two-socket receptacles on a 15 amp circuit does not mean you can get 360 amps, after all. The risk with 13 amp extension cords is the gap between the extension cord's safe capacity and the trip point of the circuit breaker. If you plug a 13 amp cord into a 20 amp T-slot receptacle, the breaker will happily supply 20 amps indefinitely even as the cord melts and ignites.
- snuxoll 6y agoGod I wish more people using electrical lawn equipment paid attention to the rating of their extensions cords. Nothing like seeing somebody buy the cheapest super-long cord they can for their electric pole saw and wondering how long before it melts. I’m going to blame the manufacturers for this one as well, they don’t usually provide current limits meaning you have to grab a table giving safe loads based on AWG and length.
- hinkley 6y agoI’m pretty sure I could tow a car with my outdoor power cord/reel. Or for that matter, with my jumper cables. I paid around $5 more for these monsters than the option next to them, which was flimsy, ridiculously short, and barely had claws. $5. It took me two seconds to make that decision and another 30 to stand there making sure I didn’t misread the prices and then trying to figure out why the others even existed.
- bleepblorp 6y agoI wish UL and other regulatory bodies would take a page from UK electrical standards and require cords that aren't capable of carrying the full amperage available at the socket to have fuses. Voltage drop protection wouldn't be a bad idea, either. No one should be expected to look up ampacity and voltage drop tables just to avoid starting a fire.
- m463 6y agoI think the worst is plugging surge protectors into surge protectors. Or plugging a surge protectors into ups. (not all, but most) It's confusing to people because dumb power strips can be daisy chained with no problem.
- h2odragon 6y agoI'd say such things should exist, sometimes, because the job needs to be done. They should be obvious ugly hacks covered in tape and embarrassing by their existence, to help prompt someone to find a the proper solution. Hands up whover made an RJ12 fit an MMJ when wiring up a vt terminal serial port
- Godel_unicode 6y agoIt sounds like the job that needs to be done is ensuring you've adequately planned ahead. With very few exceptions, this is the result of someone trying not to pay what the job costs and just faking it. Hands up whoever insists on doing site surveys so they can do quality work they're proud to put their name on.
- h2odragon 6y ago"the show can't go on because the site survey was wrong" won't fly. That's when you bust out the wirecutters and electrical tape. Preperation is great, wonderful, etc, etc; and never complete. Shit happens, be prepared to deal with it. Many disagree with me, but im a happy lunatic.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoIs this actually unsafe? In theory, won’t the circuit breaker flip if the load ever becomes unsafe? ISTM, this might end up being inconvenient (Plug another Computer into the UPS, and the breaker flips), but it won’t be dangerous, unless someone also “upgraded” the breaker.
- HarryHirsch 6y agounless someone also “upgraded” the breaker That happens. 10 years ago or so there was a big explosion at the University of Texas, Austin. The Chemistry Department had a storage vessel for liquid nitrogen. Of course the cold liquid evaporates and creates pressure inside the container. Typically the internal pressure is held at 1.5 bar by means of an escape valve. The escape valve failed and someone replaced it with a solid brass plug. To prevent accidents if the escape valve fails there is also a burst disk that breaks at higher pressure but before the tank itself explodes. That mechanism worked as designed, it released pressure, so they replaced the emergency release valve with a brass plug as well. One nice night the burst pressure of the tank itself was exceeded, and the bottom launched itself through the floor. The top was stopped by a concrete beam, but it did break a few water pipes. Here's the report from the Fire Marshal: https://www.tdi.texas.gov/fire/documents/fmred022206.pdf https://www.tdi.texas.gov/fire/documents/fmred022206.pdf There is no need to test if safety equipment works, because sometimes it does not.
- c1ccccc1 6y agoThe terrible thing is that this happened in a chemistry lab, where people should really know better. Liquid nitrogen is dangerous in a surprisingly large number of ways: Cold burns when touched, explosions when sealed in a container. And if you're in an enclosed space with it, you've got to be careful not to let it fill the room with nitrogen gas and asphyxiate you.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoin a chemistry lab, where people should really know better Some places are accident factories, where people are encouraged to be team players and not rock the boat even in the face of clear and present danger. Universities can be problematic, when you do your PhD you really need your supervisor to give you a good recommendation.
- exmadscientist 6y agoIt's worse than that! That's a NEMA L6-20, not a L5-20. That means whatever's on the other end is expecting a 240V, 20A source. And you're providing 120V, 15A. If you're really lucky, it'll start in "safe mode" with a warning light or message. If you're just lucky, it'll refuse to start at all. If you're unlucky, it'll run but silently limit its capability, so you don't know about your ticking time bomb. And if you're really unlucky, the power supply on the other end is a SMPS which will try to pull down 40 amps.... EDIT: Never mind. The photo appears to be marked L6-20R, but that's an illusion. It's actually shaped, and if you squint marked, to match an L5-20R, which is 125V 20A. Carry on....
- other_herbert 6y agoThis looks like a power cord that would be used for a welder that can run on 120 or 240v usually at about half the capacity when at 1/2 the voltage Edit: nevermind since it was pointed out that this is only a 120v appliance end
- jasonjayr 6y agoI've manufactured such a monstrosity for temporary use, because the outlet on the wall used a 15A outlet (the typical plug you see in the US everywhere) but used a 20A breaker.There should have been an outlet on the wall that had the 20A outlet (one of the blades is horizontal instead of 2 vertical blades). I used a length of 10/2 solid core wire to make the converter. I took delivery of a APC network-switched power bar that used the 30A twist-lock, and it included it's own pair of 20A breakers. I only plugged 10A (verified using a built in meter) of equipment into it till we could get a proper installation. (I should add this device is not being used in eons and hasn't needed to be used since we've made sure to get the outlets setup right before we get the equipment!)
- minikites 6y ago>the outlet on the wall used a 15A outlet (the typical plug you see in the US everywhere) but used a 20A breaker.There should have been an outlet on the wall that had the 20A outlet (one of the blades is horizontal instead of 2 vertical blades). Then replace the outlet, don't cover up one problem with another.
- petee 6y agoIdeally the plug end would be a 20a plug (one blade horizontal), but often in commercial/industrial places you'll find 15a outlets on 20a circuits. If used correctly this would be ok. They're probably made for all the people renting floorsanders from Home Depot with no way to plug em in. The scariest adaptors are the ones that dump or fake a ground - and 'cheaters' should be illegal
- jimmaswell 6y agoWouldn't the -|| 20A design solve this? Why does the circular design here have to exist too?
- lavezza 6y agoThe NEMA 'L' receptacles (L5, L6, ...) are locking. When you connect the two ends together you rotate them slightly so they won't disconnect due to vibration, etc.
- baking 6y agoThe circular one is a twist-loc that prevents it from disconnecting accidentally. The -|| 20A design is great in theory, but you only want to install a receptacle of that type if it is the only one on the circuit (and I mean only receptacle, so not even a single duplex) because what would be the point if you can plug in two devices that both require 20A. I've put these next to a window to power an air conditioner. The problem with the twist-loc is that the 15A and 20A designs are not compatible. You can't plug a 15A device into a 20A outlet, but 15A twist-loc receptacles are rare. So it is not uncommon to put a 20A plug on a device that draws much less than 15A if say you don't want someone to unplug your router by accident.
- orev 6y agoThese things are handy for devices that use the higher current when fully operational, but need power for initial setup. In IT, the main thing that comes to mind are managed PDUs. You want to be able to power up the control unit to get things like networking configured, and you don’t want to be doing that while standing in the data center balancing a laptop on your knee. With this, you can get it setup in the office, then go in and start pulling floor tiles to get it plugged in to the high Amp plug with all the settings pre-configured. To be clear, when you’re doing the setup you don’t have any actual equipment connected to the PDU; you’re just getting power to the unit itself to get power to the management circuitry.
- decker 6y agoThis makes a lot of sense. The post definitely lacked context about whether the cable was in use or if it was just something found in the server room. It's a shame the author simply assumed other people are stupid rather than bothering to investigate and understand what's going on.
- closeparen 6y agoDo you think everyone who finds this cable will investigate and understand what's going on before they deploy it in a way that starts a fire? It's not usually this easy to do something this wrong.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hyperman1 6y agoNot even that. After a fire has started for a completely different reason, the fire insurance company inspector comes in and finds it. You know, the person that loves to find any half reason to not pay you. Why are you even paying fire insurance when this thing even lies unconnected on a shelf.
- 6y ago
- c0nsumer 6y agoI once worked with a very friendly can-do project manager who did something very similar. He had a deployment project that was behind because the cabinet's PDU needed an L6-30 and the row only had an L6-20. So he went over to Grainger, bought a L6-20 male connector, an L6-30 female connector, some appropriate cable, and made an adapter. If I recall correctly he'd calculated the maximum draw from the cabinet as right about 20A, so he was really bothered when the facilities manager absolutely refused to deploy with that adapter. (<cough>inrush?<cough>)
- Lammy 6y agoI built one of these to use a surplus APC power distribution unit (basically a really tall power strip with an ethernet port for monitoring) at my house, because the PDU has a molded 30 amp 120V locking plug that I didn’t want to cut off. There’s no 240V or three-phase plugs on the thing, and I’m not running any more or any different equipment than if I used a more traditional cheap power strip. It’s really nice to be able to have a tall sturdy PDU running up the back of my rack instead of that, though! My adapter is obviously out of spec and I wouldn’t leave such a thing behind for an unsuspecting future tenant to find, but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with it in my particular situation. I love Rachel’s posts but I wish they didn’t have this pervasive air of looking down on the stupid people who did the horrible-thing-of-the-week :/ e: the PDU and plug in question: http://i.imgur.com/sUOzquZ.jpeg http://i.imgur.com/sUOzquZ.jpeg
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> I love Rachel’s posts but I wish they didn’t have this pervasive air of looking down on the stupid people who did the horrible-thing-of-the-week I generally agree, but some things are over the line, and a fire hazard feels like a good case.
- errantspark 6y agoIt's minimally a fire hazard and it's very handy to have when you know what you're doing.
- Beldin 6y agoBut it ended up in the hands of someone who didn't. That really makes it a much bigger problem. "This is OK if used by persons in the know" is not helping: Rachel wasn't/isn't in the know. So clearly, people without the proper knowledge can get their hands on this cable.
- rachelbythebay 6y agoSo certain are you? I knew it was probably trouble just from a glance. Knowing this topic would bring out every single nitpicker, I did the actual research to be doubly-sure before writing the post. You might be surprised how much extra shit goes into my posts just to avoid the inevitable backlash. It's not good enough to have a reasonable amount of knowledge. You have to go well beyond into the arcane to avoid the sniping from this crew. And even then, well, THE ONE shows up time and again.
- smiley1437 6y agoIn the same vein, it was popular around Christmas to use male to male power cords (known as a suicide cord) to string lights together, they were even available on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/Dual-Male-12-Gauge-Connection-Extension/dp/B0035Z13FI https://www.amazon.com/Dual-Male-12-Gauge-Connection-Extensi... OSHA, anyone? I get that it solved a problem for someone, but I feel a little uncomfortable just looking at it...
- esperent 6y agoWhat's the issue with these? They look as safe as any other fuse-less extension cable to me. As long as you have a fuse somewhere in the circuit, what's the problem?
- Stratoscope 6y agoYou plug one end into a hot AC outlet. Now the other end has hot 110-120V AC on exposed pins. Touch them and you are in for a bad time. A normal extension cord like we've all used has a plug at one end and a socket at the other, so you won't get killed by simply mishandling it. I love this part of the product description: "It Can Help Protect Your Family And Keep Them Safe" Right... Having said that, the longer Product Description With Every Word Capitalized explains the use case somewhat: You've lost power and it will be likely be out for quite some time. But you had the foresight to have a generator and one of these cords. You plug one end into your generator and the other end into an ordinary wall outlet. Now every outlet on that circuit will be powered from your generator. However, your normal fuse or circuit breaker will not protect you from an overload on that circuit, because you've just hotwired your generator into the "house" side of the circuit. So, as the description says, you may be able to power your refrigerator and some lights, but overload the circuit and you may burn your house down. Also be sure to turn off that breaker or remove the fuse on that circuit. Otherwise you will be having some fun when power is restored! Oh gosh, it gets even better. Check out the reviews on the Amazon listing! Finally, I would like to thank the parent commenter for asking an honest question. Perhaps it sounded naive to some, but I appreciate a question like that, as it gave several of us a chance to explain the issues around this kind of electrical cord.
- mmphosis 6y agoThe 30-amp locking receptacle has become the norm at most U.S. and Caribbean marinas, so equipping your boat with a 30-amp inlet minimizes compatibility problems. https://www.fisheriessupply.com/marinco-marine-15-amp-125v-twist-lock-male-plug https://www.fisheriessupply.com/marinco-marine-15-amp-125v-t...
- dehrmann 6y agoI remember seeing USB A to A cables. Actually, I just found one on Amazon. The only reason I know for these to exist is some external HDD enclosures where the designer somehow understood USB well enough to make a controller board, but not well enough to know it should have been a B connector.
- jrockway 6y agoI had a Wacom tablet that comes with one of these. The tablet's only input is USB Type C that requires the other side to support the Displayport alternate mode... and computers didn't really have that kind of port when Wacom released it. So it same with a box that has a USB type A port, a mini Displayport, and a USB Type C port. You can then use an A-A cable to plug into your computer (along with the Displayport for video), and then connect via Type C to the actual tablet. In theory, you can also connect the box to the tablet via Type C, and it becomes an extra USB port. It is janky and every time I go through my cables I say to myself "why on Earth does this abomination exist", but I suppose they had a good reason. Now that graphics cards have Type C ports for VR (apparently), it's not a problem. But it was back when they first came out. They ended up having to use a stupid special cable because they made their device too nice (if you did have a Type C port with video out on your computer, you could still use the converter that you paid for). I suppose there is some precedent for USB devices that can switch over to being the host. I remember buying a "USB on the go" adaptor and plugging a mouse into my Nexus back in the day. It worked! A cursor appeared and you could move it around. (Unfortunately, I hated that tablet. My Surface Pro was much better, and it wasn't even designed for drawing. I gave both devices away and now just use my iPad, which still isn't as good as the Surface Pro 4.)
- sbx320 6y ago> Now that graphics cards have Type C ports for VR (apparently) Had. The VirtualLink standard (for which the ports were supposed to be used), was never wildly adopted and is pretty much dead. AMD never introduced Type C ports and Nvidia removed them from their newer graphics cards as well. Sadly this also means there's practically no direct support for the DisplayPort alternate mode on Desktops anymore, assuming you want a dedicated GPU.
- stickfigure 6y agoThis seems to be written by someone that doesn't understand electrical wiring. I have (and sometimes use) adapter cables like these (5-15P to L5-20R). As other people have pointed out, you can draw a lot more than 15 amps through a 15-amp cable by plugging a simple Y connector into the end. That's why 15-amp circuits have 15-amp breakers in the panel. There are a variety of devices that could draw 20 amps (and thus have 20 amp NEMA connectors) but don't necessarily. If everything is wired properly, the worst that happens is you pop a breaker. I would be more concerned about the gender-opposite of the connector shown (ie, L5-20Plug to 5-15Receptacle). That would allow you to plug a 15-amp rated cable into a circuit which is defended by a 20amp breaker - now the cable is the weakest link. TL;DR: She has it backwards.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scottlamb 6y ago> I would be more concerned about the gender-opposite of the connector shown (ie, L5-20Plug to 5-15Receptacle). That would allow you to plug a 15-amp rated cable into a circuit which is defended by a 20amp breaker - now the cable is the weakest link. Huh? Isn't plugging 15-amp appliances (with cables only rated for that) into 20-amp circuits totally normal? I have a few NEMA 5-20 receptacles in my home; in fact I think the latest code requires that kitchens have at least two of them. They accept NEMA 5-15 plugs, and I use them in that fashion without a second thought. You probably do, too. My understanding is that the circuit breaker protects the wiring in your wall from excessive current. If your appliance may draw more current than its cable can handle, shouldn't it have its own fuse/breaker? The adapter cable that Rachel mentions allows plugging a 20-amp appliance into a circuit that may actually have a 20-amp breaker, with this plug between that's only rated for 15 amps and doesn't have a built-in fuse/breaker. (I wonder if the cable is at the proper gauge for 20 amps or not.) That doesn't sound proper to me...
- stickfigure 6y agoThe problem is when you plug one of these (as someone already linked) into the 20 amp socket: https://www.homedepot.com/p/GE-12-ft-2-Wire-16-Gauge-Polarized-Indoor-Extension-Cord-White-51954/203806535 https://www.homedepot.com/p/GE-12-ft-2-Wire-16-Gauge-Polariz... Everyone in the US has a bunch of these. 16ga is good for 13 amps. Even if everything is working properly, two 10-amp devices will draw 20 amps and the cable will melt before the breaker pops. If everything is not working properly, and there is a short-circuit, the cable will still probably melt before the breaker pops. This is why the OP gets it exactly backwards - she is looking at the big cable/connector and thinking "that's dangerous!" No, danger comes from the weakest link in the system, not the strongest. That weakest link must be a fuse or breaker.
- qppo 6y agoIt's not horribly uncommon to see 20A rated breakers connected to standard 3 prong sockets and people to have gear with these connectors. Interesting sidenote, I can tell you at least one NFL and two college football stadiums require these cables to use any broadcasting or recording equipment on the sidelines. And countless venues for live music, usually ones wired before the millennium.
- bleepblorp 6y agoUnless the NEC has changed recently, it's legal in the US to use 20A breakers (with appropriate wiring e.g. 12ga or larger) to supply 15amp receptacles. I don't know why the NEC allows this given that the practice is banned in Canada despite identical circuit breakers, wiring, receptacles, and electrical devices being used in both countries.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Animats 6y agoThe connector bears the name WELL-SHIN, and a UL approval number E115330. Those match and check with the UL database.[1] Well-Shin is a company in Taiwan. Revenue about US$160 million. The part number, WS-111, is the connector only, not the cable assembly.[2] Well-Shin makes cables, connectors, and all the small metal parts for people assembling cables. Their own line of cables is here.[1] They make some common cables, and this one isn't on their list. The connectors are. But it's a moulded cable, at least at the plug end. The wires are connected to the metal parts and the housing is injection-molded around it. Only the connector manufacturer can do that. Question: is the twist-lock end also a molded connector? If it is, WELL-SHIN made this, or the whole thing is counterfeit. Either way, report it to UL. They track counterfeits. If it's not a molded connector, someone cut the end off an extension cord and put that connector on. [1] https://productiq.ulprospector.com/en/profile/28839/elbz.e115330?term=Well%20Shin&page=1 https://productiq.ulprospector.com/en/profile/28839/elbz.e11... [2] http://www.wellshin.com.tw/en/mod/product http://www.wellshin.com.tw/en/mod/product
- Reelin 6y ago> If it's not a molded connector, someone cut the end off an extension cord and put that connector on. That's almost certainly what was done. You can buy a loose L5-20R at the local hardware store. Typical PC power cables are plentiful and cheap, saving you the trouble of buying and assembling a 5-15P and a length of cable.
- ohazi 6y agoI have a short adapter like this for my dual boiler espresso machine. You can configure the machine to allow both boilers to come on simultaneously, which brings the machine up to temperature faster, but requires a 20 amp circuit, or you can configure it to only allow one boiler to be on at a time (alternating between the two, when necessary), which takes longer to warm up initially, but allows you to use a 15 amp circuit. The machine has a 20 amp plug, because it's physically capable of drawing 20 amps. I have a 15 amp circuit, so I took extra care to enable the 15 amp mode and verify that it was working as intended. These cables can be okay to use if you understand what you're doing and are not violating the rules. They're obviously not supposed to be used to blindly ignore the wire or breaker ratings. It's like using `unsafe` in Rust. You're still absolutely not allowed to dereference null, even though you might be able to. You're telling the compiler, "I know you can't verify that what I'm doing is safe, but I promise that I've checked it, and it's fine." That's the same deal you're making when you use one of these cables.
- hardsoftnfloppy 6y agoITT: a woman is stereotypically a woman to the detriment of other women
- hyperion2010 6y agoI might translate this to "If you don't understand what it's for, don't use it for what you think it might be for." Things like this exist, and they are exactly as absurd and dangerous as this, but they aren't for people who don't know what they are doing, they are for people who know exactly what they are doing. It is like a booby-trapped burial site where only the priest are supposed to be able to get in without getting crushed by boulders or impaled on spikes. Unfortunately most code doesn't come with a sign that says "never call this function unless you know exactly how many C level executives are going to be up all night when you do." Engineered safety controls tell you that some things should be obscure and hard to figure out so that people who don't know what the are doing don't accidentally destroy something. On the other hand this prevents knowledge transfer and effective communication, but if it is not obscure some idiot will set both the `--i-know-what-i-am-doing` and the `--i-accept-full-legal-resonsbility-for-the-consquences-of-running-with-this-enabled` flags AND do it in a shell script. This article is spot on, and I have come to think of people who have developed this mindset as having a kind of selective lack of curiosity, say, defensive disinterest -- they see a system that they don't understand, identify that it appears to be dangerous, leave it bloody well alone, and possibly leave a note telling others to do so as well. Those in the know hopefully appreciate when the defensively disinterested warn others off, and as in this thread, take the opportunity to educate about the potentially not completely insane use cases for such things.
- alibarber 6y agoSo I came across something like this once, UK 13A Plug -> 16A Ceeform Socket in an event and asked the guy (a professional with credentials) about it and he explained that it was actually fine from a safety standpoint: (This happened a while ago, might have understood it slightly wrong) The 13A fuse was there to protect the thing from drawing more than 13A from the supply. After that it just doesn't matter - under a fault, nothing would be able to draw more than the lowest rated link. It's up to you to be aware that if you push it to 11 then things will fizzle out when the fuse goes, but no damage would be done. In this case it was just a couple of parcans so no issue. The dangerous combination would in fact be the opposite, a 32A Ceeform plug to 16A Ceeform socket unfused. Then it would be possible under fault to actually pass >16A through a thing only rated up to 16A. He said something along the lines of a 16/32A socket on the wall just means that the socket is capabale of handling 16A, not actually giving you that (or if it was even switched on) and in his line of work for anything needing more than 'a bit' of power they'd rather just tow their own generator in. This made sense as in the UK, which is different from a lot of the world, 13A sockets are usually backed by a ring main that will happily give you 32A - hence a fuse is mandatory by law in all plugs to protect the plug and flex leading from the plug to device and anything after that. Conversely, you can buy a cheap car inverter with a 13A socket perfectly legally, but try drawing that full 13A and see how far you get. Also note I'm just talking about amperage here, the voltage (i.e. blue ceeform 230V) must be the same throughout.
- gambiting 6y agoSo I discovered something disturbing about UK plugs - yes, the fuse is 13Amps, but it's not like your main circuit breaker which trips instantly - no, those fuses take a long time to melt and break. I discovered this by accidentally drawing 20 amps through a single plug, because I was mistaken about the power draw of the two devices that were plugged into one extension cord. I only realized once I touched the cable and it was pretty hot(not melting yet, but definitely hotter than you want your cable to be) - I got a power draw meter and yep, I was drawing about 4.4kW(~20amps) through a plug equipped with a fully intact 13Amp fuse! I asked an electrician how can that be, and he said that yep, these fuses won't protect you from a higher draw that lasts a few minutes, the current needs to be either super high(like, not 20 but 50 amps) or prelonged enough to melt the fuse. That has....changed my perception of how these fuses are meant to work.
- bartread 6y agoThis is a pretty ignorant and immature post. For example, "All I know is, if that was my building and they were my tenant, I'd probably sic the fire marshal on them." Well, you clearly don't know very much, and this kind of histrionic commentary isn't useful to anyone. On the other hand reading the comments I'm pleased to see people chiming in who do know the purpose and legitimate use cases of this little adapter. Personally I had no idea so I'm fascinated to learn, and hopefully one day the knowledge will come in useful. So even though the post has irked me I'm glad to have read it just because of the comments.
- HugoDaniel 6y agoLike docker
- josuepeq 6y agoRelying on a breaker to save the day if a device draws too much current from an adapter such as this is a terrible idea. My issues with the adapter: - The adapter is allowing higher current devices to connect to an outlet design that only started showing up in the 1960s; connected to “god knows what.” Some people use two-to-three prong grounding adapters. (NEMA 1-15 to 5-15.) Some NEMA 5-15 outlets are wired with bootleg grounds. My Grandmothers’ old house, built in 1837, was upgraded with “knob-and-tube” wiring sometime in the 1910s and had NEMA 1-15 plugs. There’s a certain amount of heat a knob and tube wiring install is designed to allow due to an over current; but this was contingent upon being installed properly, and never modified. The issue today (and in the 1950s) is that many DIYers spliced their safety into a black hole of junction boxes. Even If it’s a shiny new Siemens Load Center, none of that matters if it connects to wire made during the Ottoman Empire, and illegally spliced into the old breaker panel during the 1970s. - The breaker box, fuse box, load center.... Well, what is it? It is important to know who made it, and if it was done correctly. Fuses take time to blow. There could be 10 other things on that branch and it could blow quickly. It’s the big unknown. Did the last occupant get tired of replacing blown 15A fuses because they couldn’t use two kitchen appliances at once, and drop in a 30A? Same goes with actual circuit breakers. Square D will gladly sell me a single 30A breaker that fits into the spot where I pulled a 15A breaker from. I bet Federal Pacific Electric would too if they were still in business selling StabLok breakers that cheated their way through the UL tests.... in which their panels are installed commonly throughout the Bay Area. Relying on a Federal Pacific, Zinsco, Wadsworth panel to trip with the correct breaker is too much a liability for most home insurance companies. If one prefers to rely on circuit breakers, I’d really suggest that they reconsider. Especially during Fire Season here in the Bay Area. Rachel By The Bay knows what she doesn’t know about the branch circuits in her home. She’s 100% in the right here, as it pertains to her unique situation. Exercise an abundance of caution and hire an electrician!
- shash 6y agoI don’t know what you guys are bellyaching about... http://www.madamletmetellyouonething.com/wires-jammed-into-the-socket/ http://www.madamletmetellyouonething.com/wires-jammed-into-t...
- jaaames 6y agoWhat do you do when you see this lying around? http://www.fiftythree.org/etherkiller/img/etherkiller.jpg http://www.fiftythree.org/etherkiller/img/etherkiller.jpg
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoThinking of Powerline or PoE!