5 ms·
The Case for Adding 672 Million More Americans
- spaetzleesser 6y agoInteresting article but I am not sure if this is satire or not. There are many projects the country could or should take on but making an effort to massively increase population seems just lunacy to me. There are already problems with pollution and water resources. Why make these things much worse?
- chadcmulligan 6y agoThis has been Australia's secret sauce for the last 20 something years - growth by immigration has meant no recession, until now of course. Australias population was low, still is really.
- nikkwong 6y agoI don't feel like the article discusses the economic reasons to increase our population count deeply enough. We're a consumer economy, so when population count slows or stagnates near mid this century, markets will suffer. Japan's GDP has slowed to around ~1% per annum, in large part due to their stalling population count. That has hurt people in every walk of life, not only those exposed to financial markets. Canada is taking these projections seriously, and therefore has incredibly generous immigration policies, aiming to grow their population by nearly 200% by 2100 [0]. This video is definitely worth watching! They seem to be taking cues that have been gleamed off of protectionist and introverted policies that have inflicted harm on other states in the past. China under Mao, for example. It will be interesting seeing what the effect their approach will have vs one in diametric opposition such as modern-day GB. Immigration does come with problems absolutely; but I'd be more for expanding immigration domestically than by increasing the birth rate, while we still haven't figured out larger problems like pollution and climate change. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M1jat2-zI98 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M1jat2-zI98
- sumedh 6y ago> That has hurt people in every walk of life How has it hurt them?
- mdorazio 6y ago> That has hurt people in every walk of life, not only those exposed to financial markets. Seconding sumedh's comment, what's your basis for this statement?
- nikkwong 6y agoI'm sure there are multiple ways to look at the data and an argument can be made for both sides; but generally speaking I feel like a rising tide lifts most boats. Or to be said differently, rising GDP creates the greatest good for the greatest number of people. (ex. Amazon in Seattle, not everyone shares in the wealth city's new wealth explosion, but most would argue the net wealth creation is positive). Even better, Western European countries that are relatively speaking highly productive and also socially supportive can boast better quality of life for their residents no matter where they fall on the income ladder. That is in opposition to countries with low productivity, or weak social safety nets. The US may be the latter, but that is a different debate. A slowing GDP won't fix that problem; though, I think it is likely that weak social systems impact those at the bottom of the income distribution more than a relatively lower GDP.
- mdorazio 6y agoYou're going to be very hard pressed to find any data to support your view. GDP growth has basically nothing to do with quality of life. For that, on the economic side, you would look at median real GDP per capita adjusted for PPP. For example, [1]. Raw GDP growth could boost that over time, or it could all flow to a minority of people and leave the majority of the population worse off, or it could go hand in hand with price inflation and corresponding drop in PPP, or your population could be growing just as fast as your GDP, etc. Consider also [2], which adjusts a common measure of general citizenry well-being for inequality. Japan routinely is in the top 5 on this list while countries with much higher GDP growth are not. As a third point, keep in mind that HN and reddit favorite "life is best here country" Norway rarely tops 2% GDP growth, and a big chunk of that is attributable to oil exports. If your population is relatively stable and sufficiently developed, you really don't need GDP growth to improve quality of life, you just have to properly invest your GDP in the right places. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_Quality_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_Quality_Index [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_inequality-adjusted_HDI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_inequalit...
- Google234 6y agoNo thanks.
- drewcoo 6y agoThis is a Matthew Yglesias book advertisement. It's an extremely partisan excerpt by a Vox co-founder who likes the controversy.
- jessaustin 6y agoI'm not sure if it even counts as partisan. It's so goofy that everyone regardless of team affiliation will find something with which to disagree. This is book marketing, troll-style.
- CPLX 6y agoIt’s not an advertisement, it’s an excerpt. Printing excerpts or serializing longer works is a staple form of journalism.
- lisper 6y agoArgh! Yes, there's a lot of empty space in the U.S. but land area is not the limiting factor on population growth, and never has been. At the moment the limiting factor appears to be planet-wide carbon emissions, and we are already way past the point of sustainability with respect to that. We need to be talking about reducing the world's population, otherwise there will just be that many more people who have to suffer through the climate apocalypse that is surely coming.
- kiba 6y agoIt is rich people that pollute the most, so our objective should be focused on reducing negative externalities, especially reducing excessive consumption(which correspond to pollution) that don't contribute to our quality of life. Remember, the sun gives more energy in an hour to the earth than our entire civilization consume in an entire year. It's clearly not a resource problem.
- edoceo 6y agoWhat if we eat the rich?
- kiba 6y agoBy rich, I meant the American people are the rich.
- HenryKissinger 6y agoWarren Buffett is 50% bodyfat. Bill Gates is like 20%. Bezos, Zuck, and Elon are like 10%. There is a lot of variability for the meat content of the rich.
- mdorazio 6y agoRich people pollute the most, but that means that as non-rich people become richer (as they are rapidly now doing as a result of globalization), pollution increases substantially over time. Likely at a higher rate than you can offset with externality pricing because good luck getting developing nations to agree to that.
- rmrfstar 6y agoI read somewhere that "butter side down" people write pieces easy for the "butter side up" crowd to dunk on. The dunks amplify the message well beyond the attention the original author could muster.
- jml7c5 6y agoI don't understand; are you saying the author doesn't actually want this, but just wants to be a strawman?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 6y agoYglesias is a divisive enough figure who has been around for a long enough time that he could pull a thesis out of a hat, noodle around for 100 pages without ever building a recognizable argument, hire a couple of interns to pad it out to 300 pages (when extensive back matter is included), arrange for a well-orchestrated pay-for-review campaign to get some small fraction of the public excited or perturbed, and then just about pay for the advance (after extensive publishing-company accounting shenanigans). So, that's what he does. He doesn't actually give a hoot whether there are more or fewer Americans.
- damnyou 6y agoA simpler explanation: the guy sincerely believes there should be more Americans and is also decent at self-promotion (which is how he got where he is).
- rmrfstar 6y agoNot so sure about that, given his claim that "it’s worth emphasizing that while 1 billion Americans may be impossible and absurd, there’s actually nothing hard about it."
- russellbeattie 6y agoWhen I was born in 1972, the global population was roughly half of what it is now. It was like living in a world after Thanatos snapped his fingers... I'm not sure how they were able to survive. In [another 50] years the population will double again, and everyone then will look back at today and be amazed there were so few people. They'll make a movie where there's "only" 7.8 billion people left and it'll be a blockbuster. (Assuming there's still a functioning democracy then.) * Edited. See below.
- sumedh 6y ago> In 30 years the population will double again How would it double if the population growth rate has been falling down for decades?
- russellbeattie 6y agoActually, yeah, it looks to be about 60 years if things don't change... My bad. I misread a chart on Wikipedia earlier, just used this instead: https://population.un.org/wpp/Graphs/Probabilistic/POP/TOT/900 https://population.un.org/wpp/Graphs/Probabilistic/POP/TOT/9...
- jessaustin 6y agoIf you'd like to wager that the population will be > 15B in 2050, you will find lots of people eager to take the other side of that bet.
- Rexxar 6y agoWith the same logic we should add 1850 Million more Russians. The number will keep them warn in the tundra.
- rgbrenner 6y agoThis is something I always thought as a kid. Just look at a map... why arent there like a billion people in the US? This makes sense to a child because it's so simple. But reality is more complicated. 2/3rds of the US lives east of the Mississippi river. So if we had that level of density across the US, we would have 650m people. So east of the Mississippi is pretty close to being populated at that level. The central plains is rapidly draining the water table. So it's unlikely we'll be able to continue farming it at the rate we have been (unless technology improves to reduce water usage), much less increase output. To illustate this, I love this image in [0] figure 2 on the first page. Water in an aquifer is stored in small cavities in the rock/soil/etc, and when you drain it enough, the ground literally collapses.. meaning you can never refill it. Our farmers now have to drill deeper than every before, and some farmers are just put out of business entirely... and that's today. And the west is arguably already overpopulated. We literally drain the Colorado river. We already need more desalination plants as it is. If we put a billion people in the US, it would look very much like China. China has a similar geography problem. So when you imagine the US with a billion people, just imagine them all packed in on the east coast with some of the same problems as China (food supply, pollution, etc). 0. https://water.usgs.gov/ogw/pubs/fs00165/SubsidenceFS.v7.PDF https://water.usgs.gov/ogw/pubs/fs00165/SubsidenceFS.v7.PDF
- kiba 6y agoThis is because water usage is not priced, and that we wasted water in the most inefficient manner. Land is cheap, sun is free, and water is effectively free. We could switch to aquaponic, which is water and land efficient, but that's expensive.
- rgbrenner 6y agoThat's very expensive... and consider we live in a globalized economy, that would just result in more food imports. Again, China has a similar problem, and they import food... because the economics of that solution just don't work unless the rest of the world agrees (and they won't).
- gremlinsinc 6y ago
- jccalhoun 6y agoIt is an interesting argument but I wonder if tripling the amount of people in the USA would result in denser cities or more smaller cities and overall less farm land. It certainly wouldn't be distributed equally. The idea gives me a real feeling of Not In My Back Yard. If they want to make denser residential areas in cities that is fine but I like my low real estate prices and having a house instead of being in an apartment building.
- kiba 6y agoTokyo have lot of single family housing and remains affordable for middle class. You just don't get lawns or backyard, which is fine by me. Lawns are unwanted busyworks.
- loraa 6y agoI have spoken to anti-border progressives that fantacise to this.
- seebetter 6y agoLet's start by moving 1 million people each out of the major cities.
- in3d 6y ago"21.1 percent of American children are living in poverty, compared with 11.3 percent of German children and just 9.3 percent of Swedish children, even though the U.S. is richer on average than either Germany or Sweden." Dishonest. First, the poverty rate for children was 16.2% in 2018 (latest data from https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2019/demo/p60-266.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2019/demo/p60-26...). Second, the income calculated by Census for this measure doesn't include things like food stamps or housing subsidies (https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2019/demo/p60-266.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2019/demo/p60-26...). If they are included, the poverty rate becomes a lot lower. Increasing spending on social programs that address poverty can have no effect on the poverty rate.
- kevingadd 6y agoI guess it's essentially the divide between "are they living in poverty" (is their family very poor) and "are they living in misery" (no food, no heat, etc). Programs can address the latter without fixing the former, but that doesn't necessarily mean the programs are a failure - gotta measure the right things and measure them properly.
- clairity 6y agoonce you get past the xenophobia, most americans will realize that the only way to continue the properity and global power we've enjoyed over the past century is to import more people because we're not making enough here. it's literally the playbook for sustainably growing an otherwise mature and stagnating economy. moreover, incumbent americans are just too risk-averse to innovate or invest in real innovation vs paper gains. the wealthy and powerful among us have been in hardcore harvest mode for 40 years and we're gradually, collectively losing our knowledge and ability to plow and sow. instead, we're all on social media trying to out-shizzle each other.
- HenryKissinger 6y ago> incumbent americans are just too risk-averse to innovate or invest in real innovation vs paper gains Can you expand on this? Native born Americans prefer to play the stock market than starting new businesses?
- rsync 6y ago"... most americans will realize that the only way to continue the properity and global power we've enjoyed over the past century is to import more people ..." Given the global externalities produced by that prosperity and global power, why is it obvious that "most americans" would want that to continue ? It may, in fact, be the case that importing citizens is the only way to continue this, but it's not obvious that there aren't other modes of living and growing. Living things are born, they mature, then grow old and die ... mature living things don't consume the same resources or create the same outputs as juvenile living things. That's not necessarily bad ...
- clairity 6y ago> "...why is it obvious that "most americans" would want that to continue ?" because the pie doesn't grow otherwise, and folks are fighting over the pie we have already. also, a growing pie doesn't mean maintaining the same inefficiencies/externalities we've gotten used to. part of the imported innovation will have to go towards mitigating those very problems if the growth is to be sustainable.
- freyr 6y agoExcept for my childhood birthday parties, I can't think of a time when I thought, "God, I wish this was three times as crowded."
- pas 6y agoThe US is so sparsely inhabited (in almost every way) yet many citizens think it's already full.
- freyr 6y agoSparsely inhabited compared to what? 100 years ago? Australia? China? Sweden? Rwanda? You say that as if it's a bad thing, but perhaps it's the goal? Some of the least densely populated countries are the happiest and healthiest. Some of the most densely populated countries are the poorest and unhappiest. Regardless, we're at the point where we need to seriously consider the long-term sustainability of the current global population level.
- pas 6y ago> Some of the most densely populated countries are the poorest and unhappiest. Sure, there's a golden mean between slums and unwalkable suburbs/exurbs. Interestingly the urbanization percentage for the US is basically the same as for Norway 82.5%. And interestingly Oslo about tenth of the size of LA has comparable density: https://www.ssb.no/a/english/kortnavn/beftett_en/fig-2011-06-17-01-en.gif https://www.ssb.no/a/english/kortnavn/beftett_en/fig-2011-06... (per km^2) https://i.redd.it/v84al8v4ymp11.png https://i.redd.it/v84al8v4ymp11.png (per mi^2) "About 14% Americans live in the nation's rural counties, 54% in its suburbs and small metros and about 30% in its urban core counties" (data from 2016) and in Europe "In 2018, 39.3% of the population lived in the cities, 31.6% lived in towns and suburbs, and 29.1% lived in rural areas" > Regardless, we're at the point where we need to seriously consider the long-term sustainability of the current global population level. Well, this sounds like the good old Malthus argument, but we're nowhere near carrying capacity of Earth. ... the problem is that the cost and environmental impact of certain lifestyles are unsustainable.
- Razengan 6y ago> When America faced down Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union, we were the big dog. I regret even clicking on this drivel.
- JackFr 6y agoI assume he meant facing them down at different points in time. I’m pretty sure Matt Yglesias knows that the Soviet Union was our ally against the Nazis.
- JackFr 6y agoHe comes close to, but never really makes an argument as why this should be a goal. Why is having the largest GDP any more important than having the tallest skyscraper or the most Olympic medals? Ultimately, what is the telos of a nation?
- nine_zeros 6y agoI've been traveling in New England. The sights of aging population are everywhere. Entire towns are run only by the old who may die in a few years. Where are the young people? They are in cities or suburbs of course. Rural America is decaying for sure. However, the fix is not to indiscriminately add more humans. We should make legal immigration streamlined and targeted. Have a target for the year and remove the bureaucracy so people can move in quick allowing us to reach said targets. But yes, country statistics competition wise, we are about to lose to China asap. Especially with the leadership we have at the top right now.
- Protostome 6y agoThat's a brilliant idea. I think the US should open its gates to people of all races which could benefit its economy. (from computer scientists to construction workers)