3 ms·
Peter Thiel explains his own opinions
- abstractbill 16y ago... not like the present, where technology is largely seen as irrelevant and specifically as bad I don't have the feeling this is actually true, but of course I might just have managed to surround myself with others who don't believe it either. I wonder how much of the general population really shares this view. People certainly seem to like the products of technology, like new smartphones and such.
- anateus 16y agoBut think about how products are positioned. I think his comparison with the 50s is a bit simplistic, but think about a product advertisement from those times: "This is the widget OF THE FUTURE!". It would be presented very differently now, much more about how it's the cool and chic thing. From a culture of the future to a culture of the past. As an side: he very carefully managed to avoid dropping into the quagmire of "it was so much better back then" by addressing a specific aspect, for which I'm glad. There's plenty to dislike about US culture in the 50's as far as the kind of forward thinking going on ("I'll have a jetpack to fly to work and the missuss will have a jet kitchen to use while she stays at home and raises our jet-children").
- kenjackson 16y agoInteresting this appears in the National Review. I wrote this a couple of months ago: The conservative right has started a grassroots movement to make traditional measures of intellect and achievement worthy of less distinction. A PhD? Who cares? Nobel Prize in Chemistry? Chemistry isn't that big of a deal, anyone can do it. Plain talkin' people who struggle with things like math and science -- those are the real intellects. Because being an intellect is being someone who can just relate to the every day man. Everything else is just a "hobby" that is no more worthy of distinction than being good at Call of Duty. Over 2011 expect a full court press on this. Academia, scholarship, science, math, etc... will all be attacked as not particularly interesting. Plain spoken populism will be the new metric for brilliance and the best this country has to offer. Peter Thiel is more subtle, but the subtext is there. Fully expect that this debate ends up being very partisan. The conservatives pushing the banner that college is a bubble. Small business is where real America is. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2135539 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2135539
- pjscott 16y agoI think Thiel made it very clear that this isn't about education (as such) and it isn't about the endless mainstream culture wars. It's about figuring out what people should do with their lives, given their particular set of goals. A lot of people take on large student loans and go to college because they feel like they're supposed to, and the debt prevents them from taking financial risk at a time in their lives when it could be the most useful to them. Other people do really well for themselves; one of my friends graduated with an electrical engineering degree, got married, and got a steady job in a nice part of Colorado, and seems to be doing just fine. One-size-fits-all recipes for life tend not to fit very well. People have different desires, different histories, different interests, and different circumstances -- why would we argue that everybody should (or shouldn't) go to college? That just seems so limited, more like political signaling than any serious attempt to improve things. There need to be more options that people take seriously. I'm happy just to see that people are talking about this at all.
- kenjackson 16y agoand it isn't about the endless mainstream culture wars Given that this interview takes place in a publication that is largely focused on the mainstream culture wars, you're going to have to do a much better job convincing me. Especially since everything he says in his interview reads like a conservative culture war advocate. He evokes Milton Friedman for heavens sake! I think the fact that you agree with his position, which is fine, may cloud you to why the National Review wants to run an interview with him. And couple this with the fact that I've seen this coming from various people on the right, makes me all the more skeptical. Even the person who posted the story is YummyFajitas - an extremely conservative HN member.
- pjscott 16y agoIf I'm reading this right, you seem to be pointing to everything except the literal meaning of his words, whereas I'm taking what he wrote at face value, and ignoring the political context. Would you say that's more or less accurate? I may be naive to be so trusting about the lack of hidden intentions, but as far as I can tell, Peter Thiel is hard to categorize politically and deserves the benefit of the doubt.