4 ms·
https://samharris.org/the-fireplace-delusion/ https://samharris.org/the-fireplace-delusion/ You should not burn wood at all. Woodsmoke is truly terrible pollut
by sneak 6y ago
https://samharris.org/the-fireplace-delusion/ https://samharris.org/the-fireplace-delusion/
You should not burn wood at all. Woodsmoke is truly terrible pollution that harms you and everyone around you for most of a mile radius.
It smells really nice but is utterly damaging.
- 01100011 6y agoThat is an informative article that leaves me wanting to disregard it because of the condescending tone. I guess I prefer facts separate from the moralizing. I wonder how modern pellet stoves with more complete combustion compare to traditional wood fires?
- strogonoff 6y agoIn addition to describing old methods of burning wood, when speaking about its health effects this article completely ignores the weather factor. Even with proper chimney construction, atmospheric pressure and presence or absence of inversion can cause smoke to hover at the ground for days—or quickly take it to high altitudes and disperse. I am not sure whether the research he mentions controlled for this factor. In particular, quotes like this: > It might be the clearest day of the year, but burn a sufficient quantity of wood and the air in the vicinity of your home will resemble a bad day in Beijing. strongly hint at atmospheric inversion, frequent in some areas and rare in others. (Also, “sufficient quantity of wood” makes the point completely meaningless, but that aside…) IMO recommending for or against wood burning should take into account typical weather patterns of a particular area, and ideally there should be a way to notify people when atmospheric conditions are not right for this. I agree that Sam Harris has a frustrating tendency to moralize, but I still subscribe to his podcast. There are good points raised in most discussions, if not by him then by his guest. Strong opinions is a double-edged sword.
- 7952 6y agoIn my country people leave their wood burner running all winter regardless of the weather. People are never going to turn it off just because of weather conditions. And there is moralising on the other side of the argument, it is just less explicit. The old fashioned "natural" manliness of chopping and burning wood is definitely considered virtuous by a lot of people. Maybe this is restricted to middle class though.
- strogonoff 6y agoThe existence of people for whom burning wood is the only way to heat their homes in winter now does not preclude the possibility of a future where people can choose to use thermoelectric facilities for cooking or (in winter) heating when weather allows, and use electricity from other sources (batteries or mains) at other times. (In my view there is hardly anything especially manly or romantic in buying fuel for a modern pellet stove. As far as I know unless one literally owns a forest one can’t legally go around chopping down trees in most countries. Chopping may be a good exercise though.)
- lapinot 6y agoThere's no debating that inhaling (any kind of) smoke is pretty bad. For the rest of the article i'm gonna have to call bs. 1. Outside air: We're not talking about cities. Burning stuff in dense habitation zones is stupid. Sibling comments have hinted at atmospheric inversion, which is a localized and largely exceptional effect. Also: it's not too hard to take that into account and have a fire at nights and during winter, periods during which people aren't too much out. 2. Inside air: Any well designed and well tended fire-place (and its associated well-dried wood) generates no smoke in the room. If it does you're doing in wrong. If you intend to heat your home you should go for a closed stove, if you intend to cook you should have a well ventilated open-furnace and learn to use it right. Source: my childhood home at the country-side heated exclusively (hot water was electric) with a stove in the living room and an open furnace in the kitchen. 3. Deforestation: we have too much wood. Apart from rain-forests, at "occidental latitudes" most forests are growing (at least i know for sure in france). In my country-side some farmer neighbor always had spare wood to sell, from cutting trees around their fields (of course you have to do it intelligently: not cut the younger ones, etc). A farm of a half a dozen hectares can be self-sufficient in heating wood (source: neighbors).
- dredmorbius 6y ago"Too much wood" is only an artefact of recent industrialised use of coal, oil, and nuclear energy. Through the 19th century, deforestation was rampant in Europe and North America, and remains a problem throughout much the rest of the world. Largely driven my small-scale fuelwood use. Industrial-scale charcoal-fired bronze, iron, and glass-smelting use prodigious amounts of wood fuel, multiples of the yielded product mass.
- lapinot 6y agoAren't you contradicting yourself with the industrial uses point? I don't have any strong refs but my understanding is that 19th c. deforestation was driven by growing population, which isn't a problem in europe for much of the foreseeable future. Btw there have been big advances in forest management and forest-compatible agriculture (agroforestry and intercropping in general).