4 ms·
If this list includes depression treatments, they are examples of treatments for which "high-quality evidence" of the sort that is demanded is impossible. The
by ncmncm 6y ago
If this list includes depression treatments, they are examples of treatments for which "high-quality evidence" of the sort that is demanded is impossible.
The only way to know whether a person has the version of the disorder that responds to a particular drug is to administer that drug and see. Psychiatrists try prescribing different drugs until they hit one that works, or give up. Imagine designing a randomized-controlled-trial for that.
If you need help: first, select a group already using the drug. Split them up and give half a placebo. See which get worse. But first, find someone unethical enough to run it, and admits it.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoThat makes a big assumption that there are multiple types of depression caused by different chemical imbalances. Not saying that's a wrong assumption (e.g. for cancer the analogous assumption that many different mutations can lead to similar cancers is true), but it is a big assumption, and there are plenty of psychologists who would disagree with it.
- doesnotexist 6y ago"Scientifically speaking, there never was a network of validated hypotheses capable of sustaining a full-blown, global chemical imbalance theory of mental illness. Moreover-and here we come back to Myth 2-psychiatry as a profession and medical specialty never endorsed such a bogus “theory,” when judged by its professional organizations, its peer-reviewed publications, its standard textbooks, or its official pronouncements." https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/debunking-two-chemical-imbalance-myths-again https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/debunking-two-chemical... In the general public, there's a logical fallacy that people seem to fall for when thinking about psychopharmacology. It seems that when it is learned that serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs)are used to treat patients with depression it is followed with some mechanistic explanation of a "chemical imbalance" resulting from "not enough serotonin." Yet people don't make this mistake when talking about opiods or pain killers. If you break your arm and the doctor prescribes Codeine we don't come to the conclusion that "you broke your arm and all your endogenous opoids came spilling out so we had to replace it with Codeine." Although Tylenol/paracetamol are useful for treating pain, we don't hear a lot of talk about Tylenol deficiencies.
- Jabbles 6y agoYou don't need to give people a placebo, you can test against a known good alternative. This is frequently used in just such cases, where an effective treatment is already known, and denying patients in a trial that opportunity would be (as you say) unethical. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_control#Positive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_control#Positive
- doesnotexist 6y agoThe article is based off someone scraping all the Cochrane reviews and doing ctrl-f for the phrase "high quality evidence"... unfortunately the headline makes great click bait but I think it's misleading as most people are not versed enough in medical evidence and come away with an incorrect impression as to the evidence supporting medical interventions today. Even an intervention with "moderate" level of evidence supporting it has already passed a bar far beyond what most people would imagine. As to your claim about antidepressants, psychiatry and psychopharmacology is abound in RCTs, many on treating depression with antidepressants. You are perhaps mistaking a common clinical approach (outside of clinical studies) for finding the best medical management for single patient with how clinical evidence is procured in the first place. There are more Cochrane reviews under "mental health" at 679 than there are under "orthopedics" at 478. Also, when RCTs are proposed, no matter if they placebo controlled or not, they are reviewed by IRBs and ethics committees.
- ncmncm 6y agoYet, we very frequently read about RCTs that failed to find any significant benefit from this or that antidepressant, insisting therefore that psychiatrist are a bunch of quacks and people with depression are malingerers. Those RCTs are administered by real people who are each either unaware that there is no way to get meaningful results from such a trial, or are motivated to produce meaningless results that can nonetheless be published to mislead.
- JimTheMan 6y agoThere are plenty of studies out there for whether a particular drug works or does not work in treatment resistant depression. So to answer your question they do test for that.