3 ms·
Examples of anti-hierarchical societies do exist (Catalonia, Paris Commune, etc). The problem isn't so much that hierarchies just arise naturally, the problem
by pydry 6y ago
Examples of anti-hierarchical societies do exist (Catalonia, Paris Commune, etc).
The problem isn't so much that hierarchies just arise naturally, the problem is more that these societies aren't very long lived because they're pretty useless at defending themselves with violence.
It's not totally uncommon to find an anti-hierarchical company. It is almost impossible to find an effective anti-hierarchical military.
- bccdee 6y agoAs far as I'm aware, both of those had hierarchical leadership structures. The Paris Commune was run democratically through universal suffrage, and the CNT-FAI had its own leadership structures. Now, these societies sought to minimize hierarchy, sure, but I think it's important to recognize that an entirely non-hierarchical society is essentially impossible.
- pydry 6y agoThey were without coercive hierarchy. There's a fundamental difference between having a "boss" and electing your "boss".