3 ms·
Our universe isn't perfectly described by mathematics. Parts of our universe can be described by mathematics on limited timescales while also assuming inherent
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
Our universe isn't perfectly described by mathematics. Parts of our universe can be described by mathematics on limited timescales while also assuming inherent randomness.
Math can't even predict the fate of the solar system out to infinity. Planetary systems aren't unconditionally stable, and the effects of limited precision - presumably relevant to any hypothesis of computability - make very long term predictions not just unreliable, but impossible.
This pretty much kills Tegmark's thought experiment, which is in any case a perfect example of begging the question - in spite of the increasing improbability of the examples.
Platonists need to explain if they believe that consciousness is possible on clockwork hardware. If Platonists actually believe that, they may as well dismiss everything that's happened in science since the days of Newton, because that's a very extraordinary claim with absolutely no evidence to support it.