3 ms·
I think the main criticism is that centralizing the “legitimate” use of force to, as you say, “keep everyone in line”, is that you get all of the downsides of a
by sneak 6y ago
I think the main criticism is that centralizing the “legitimate” use of force to, as you say, “keep everyone in line”, is that you get all of the downsides of a violence-based society, and none of the upsides of freedom: such societies still enslave, torture, steal, violate privacy, and mass murder.
Indeed, we’re witnessing an unprecedented wealth transfer right now in the US as a result of such centralization of authority.
I’ve never met an anarchist that believes that by abolishing the state that society will become entirely nonviolent. It’s just a sort of standard “who will build the roads?” straw man: Policing doesn’t need police, and social contracts don’t need a statehouse.
- JacksonGariety 6y ago> we’re witnessing an unprecedented wealth transfer right now in the US Indeed. And it must be regarded as infinitely baffling that everyone is shouting "abolish the police" instead of "redistribute the wealth" ...
- sneak 6y agoThe police are the ones who are practically preventing the redistribution of the wealth. Without them, 1/30th of the vacant residential stock in the US would be filled with 100% of the homeless people in the US, for example. (There are approximately 35x as many vacant houses/apartments in the US as there are homeless.)
- sdfin 6y agoWould you eliminate private property? Or are you suggesting something different?
- tehjoker 6y agoYes, both anarchists and socalists share a desire to abolish private property. The major differences are in their strategy and transition states.
- sdfin 6y agoYes. I don't understand why, in the case of socialists, do they believe that the gobernment can manage wealth and resources better than private owners. And regarding anarchists, I don't understand how would they distribute scarce resources.
- lr4444lr 6y ago...until the major REITs and large private landlord corps hire private security to kick them out, with extreme violent prejudice to send a message, because who're you gonna call to stop them from brutal and unlawful eviction anyway, once you get rid of the police? It's not like the homeless can afford attorneys for eviction court.
- JacksonGariety 6y agoExactly. If you get rid of the police, the wealthy elite will just hire thugs to protect their stuff.
- JacksonGariety 6y ago> The police are the ones who are practically preventing the redistribution of the wealth. Policing prevents, and makes possible, all sorts of things. It is a function of law. By abolishing policing you throw out the baby (the law) with the bathwater (laws that facilitate the concentration of wealth).
- sneak 6y agoPlease don't confusing abolishing police with abolishing policing. Calling a random member of society to do entirely untrained policing in the US would oftentimes result in better outcomes than the current police in the US: https://lawandcrime.com/crime/outrage-flows-after-prosecutors-charge-teen-with-murder-for-killing-her-rapist/ https://lawandcrime.com/crime/outrage-flows-after-prosecutor...
- yters 6y agowhat we really need to do is abolish the people, source of all our people problems. no people, no problems
- username90 6y agoUSA is one of the worst example though, there are plenty of societies which have well behaved police forces and still aren't anarchist.
- soperj 6y agoname one.
- username90 6y agoNorway. I live in Sweden, our police has gotten a bit worse lately but still very good. USA has problems, but you don't solve them by becoming an anarchy but by fixing the issues it has. For example instead of 3 months police academy maybe do 3 years like most of the rest of the developed world.
- soperj 6y agoI'm not from the USA, and I'm not advocating anarchy. A quick google search shows multiple incidents in Sweden where police brutality has occurred and then they try to cover it up. ie: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/may/27/sweden-punishes-rioters-police-stockholm-riots https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/may/27/sweden...