3 ms·
Sure, but that still directly goes against the argument that humans are naturally hierarchical, because they aren't. And there are ways to have agriculture and
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Sure, but that still directly goes against the argument that humans are naturally hierarchical, because they aren't.
And there are ways to have agriculture and industry and compounding scientific advancements without having rigid hierarchies, are there not?
- oblio 6y agoThey are hierarchical. All primates are. Agriculture just revealed the need for a level of social structure no other species on Earth could achieve before. Regarding your follow-up question, maybe there are ways to achieve the same thing with a radically different social structure. The problem with social changes on this scale is that they are extremely disruptive. I'd rather reform and improve iteratively than rewrite the whole code base ;-)
- sudosysgen 6y agoYou should consider the issues of iteratively improving the same code base, pushing to prod for hundreds of years! Primate dominance hierarchies are weak, accountable, and constantly challenged, and not even necessary in humans which exhibit other behaviors depending on nature. As a consequences, hierarchy is not necessary in humans and not inherent. That being said, there are ways to move into anarchism that aren't that disruptive as long as the dominant power structure doesn't decide to violently repress it. Syndicalism into market socialism into anarchism is a common one.
- oblio 6y agoI'd be curious where anarchism was applied on a large scale for more than a generation and the result was good. Regarding the code analogy, I'd rather have a million pushes to prod than one huge force push that rewrites history;-)
- sudosysgen 6y agoBut as I said, it's possible to transition to anarchy. You don't need to do it in one bit push. The issue is when the underlying code base is so bad that there is nothing else, but we can certainly try incrementalism. In theory, there's no reason you couldn't go towards and anarchic society via a million small reforms, but in practice you get executed for using your already existing rights if you state that your goal is to do such reforms.
- djur 6y agoIs it possible to transition to anarchy in a geopolitical environment of competing nation-states? How would an anarchizing state in the process of gradual self-dismantlement outcompete more centralized states in economic and military terms?
- the_other 6y agoThe same ways any small country survives more than a few years.
- djur 6y agoThe way most small countries have survived in the past century is to rely on the protection of a larger state with a powerful military and/or on international treaty organizations (UN, NATO, OAS, etc.) which derive their influence from those state militaries.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> And there are ways to have agriculture and industry and compounding scientific advancements without having rigid hierarchies, are there not? Sure, the absence of rigid heirarchies with strictly top-down authority in favor of fairly fluid ones with something like circular authority where the top of heirarchy is selected and changeable by the people subject to it is a hallmark of liberal society, realized to varying degrees throughout much of the world. But that's not what anarchism is about.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere are still ways to run agricultural and otherwise technological societies with minimal authority if any at all.