13 ms·
Charge more for app subscriptions
- dave_sid 6y agoVery good post. I wonder how much these percentages would differ between B2B and B2C apps. I’m not sure I can imagine many people paying anything like $10 per month for a non-business app (not including Spotify, I see that as a special case). I would understand it if the budget isn’t coming out of their own pocket.
- com2kid 6y agoThe two fitness apps I use are $60/year and $30/year. Headspace is ~$55/year and they have a ton of subscribers. Plenty of language learning apps are over $100/year. If the value is there, and especially if there is a direct comparable to a non-app based service, people will pay.
- dave_sid 6y agoThat’s interesting you say your fitness apps cost 60 and 30 per year. Would you say that’s another factor, and that yearly less frequent subscriptions and more appealing than monthly?
- loraa 6y agoNo one wants to pay for subscriptions and it's pretty BS that you can't just buy a basic app you need to pay more than its worth with a subscription.
- cercatrova 6y agoI watched a very interesting video about selling to consumers as opposed to businesses [0]. The key takeaway is that consumers' target price to pay is actually $0. Therefore, any price above that, even a 3 to 4 dollar a month difference, is seen as extremely annoying to them, because again, they actually only want to pay nothing. This is why you should, if not charging business, at least charge prices that are sufficiently high such that only those who see the value in them will pay, which are usually in a different class of consumers from bottom-feeders who look for the lowest price, ideally 0. An example is Superhuman, an email app that costs $30 dollars a month. Only those who see the value in a fast, keyboard-driven email app will pay that much. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEc-qGK5cjY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEc-qGK5cjY
- input_sh 6y agoIn an ideal world where people have a decent disposable income, those arguments might be true. In the real world, it's not that "people don't want to pay anything", it's that people have a small amount of money to throw at things for a marginally better experience. I sure like keyboard-driven apps, but I'm never going to pay as much as I pay for my entire Internet package for any online service. Hell, all of them I pay for barely add up to $30/month. Superhuman and similar are tools for rich people, equivalent to a Rolex or the latest iPhone. Those with less income are assumed not to be its target audience. I'd argue that they could double the price without losing more than a single digit percentage of current users.
- cercatrova 6y agoYes, it seems your comment is reinforcing my point. Consumers like you don't want to pay $30 and that's fine, you are not their target audience. You may like keyboard-driven apps but you don't like them enough to pay $30, so in terms of microeconomics, you don't believe you'll get as much value from the tool as you'd spend. Again, that is fine, because the company should only target customers who do realize your product's value. One may say that the takeaway is basically, target prosumers and rich customers who see the value of the product in order to make the most money. That they are price insensitive is also great as a dev, because, yes, you can increase the price multifold and not lose customers, which increases your revenue overall.
- crooked-v 6y agoThe comment you're replying to is talking about actual amount of money available for the consumer, not perceived value. Or, in other words: if I look at an app and decide that it's perfect and I'd really like to have it, but it costs $30/month and I need that money for gas to get to work or to put into my kid's college fund, I'm not going to get it. The kind of people who post on HN usually have enough money that just $30/month isn't a problem, but what if there's 10 apps that do the same thing? At $300/mo that's now a substantial budget item, and if I have anything serious to save up money for, individual apps are going to be the first thing to go.
- bitL 6y ago"Why you should avoid using subscriptions for your apps." User hostility 101.
- egypturnash 6y agoMan I dunno, for the sector they're in, folks are pretty likely to already be paying for a subscription to the Adobe suite, and honestly I think the whole "subscription" thing is gonna strangle Adobe in the future when there's a generation of artists who grew up using other tools that were buy once, use until upgrading something else breaks it, and/or were easier to pirate. Also I have a piece of hardware I bought from the Astropad folks and if the app suddenly stops working because they demand a subscription I'm gonna be pretty damn unhappy. Part of the problem, of course, is that app stores have completely killed "upgrade pricing". There's no good way for your existing users to give you money for "hey we added some new features and fixed some bugs" without bullshit workarounds like "okay the new version is a totally new app, go buy it".
- jrochkind1 6y ago> in the future when there's a generation of artists who grew up using other tools that were buy once, use until upgrading something else breaks it, and/or were easier to pirate. In the future when? Isn't that now? Adobe changed to subscription model in 2013. Everyone that is paying subscription now grew up with the buy-once model, right? In the future, people will have grown up with adobe's current subscription model.
- egypturnash 6y agoYeah I think it may be about now. And now that I think about it very few of the younger pro artists in my circles are using Adobe’s stuff, they’re using Clip Studio or Procreate for the most part.
- crooked-v 6y agoThe Affinity line of apps are also pretty great, and have (I think) full feature parity across desktop and iPad.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoAffinity Designer not having DXF / DWG import export... Is preventing me from using it in a professional capacity. I purchased Affinity Designer without checking for the feature, and people have been asking for the feature for at least 5 years. Edit to add the forum link I forgot to paste in: https://forum.affinity.serif.com/index.php?/topic/6756-dxf-or-dwg-file-import-in-affinity-designer/ https://forum.affinity.serif.com/index.php?/topic/6756-dxf-o...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThis analysis is very US/Euro-centric. Bumping the price from US$20 to US$100 might indeed allow you to focus more on your most dedicated customers. It also bumps the price way above anything that billions of people around the world can pay for such a thing. At Ardour, we have 3 subscription price levels: Regular: US$10/month Low Cost: US$4/month Developing World: US$1/month We leave it to users to decide which category to select. Maybe you don't care about people in Senegal or Bangladesh or the Phillipines. That's certain an option, but some demonstration that this has crossed your mind is probably a good idea. It may also be important that on a technical level, our subscriptions are not like e.g. Adobe's. Stop subscribing to this GPL'ed software and nothing changes except for your ability to get updates for free.
- OJFord 6y agoRegional price discrimination is nothing new, but I haven't heard of making it buyers' choice before - why aren't you using IP or some other method of determining region? The obvious answer is that it's defeatable, but if the alternative is then to make it a radio button (trivially 'defeatable'), that's clearly not it.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIt's not intended to be non-defeatable. It's intended to recognize enormous disparities in income worldwide (and sometimes even within the same city). The user/buyer who elects to use a one-time payment gets to pick their own price, too: the default is pre-seeded based on OECD data on the cost of a mid-prize restaurant meal for two without alcohol, combined with IP address. Our motto has been (thus far): it doesn't matter if everybody pays for it, it only matters if enough people pay for it.
- OJFord 6y agoI realise that, I meant that as the usual response that clearly doesn't apply to your case. What I'm not clear on is why you don't work out the correct region & pricing on the customer's behalf; why you leave it to honesty?
- dguo 6y agoWhenever I read "charge more," I think of the implicit assumption that service owners want to maximize total profit. While I can understand that desire, there's no law of nature that says we have to act in a profit-maximizing manner. A SaaS service could have a different goal: running a sustainable business that benefits as many people as possible. So they could choose to charge a deliberately low amount such that more people can afford to or are willing to pay for it, while also charging a high enough amount that the business is financially sustainable.
- EduardoBautista 6y agoI can’t see how charging less would help with running a sustainable business. I would imagine charging more would help with that.
- Kaze404 6y agoParent never said that. Charging less helps with the goal of having a sustainable business that benefits as many people as possible because it lowers the barrier of entry.
- zepto 6y agoMaybe, but it’s also possible that if you charge too little, people subscribe but don’t benefit, because they don’t use the service much. Subscribing doesn’t necessarily imply benefitting, but the higher the price, the more correlated these are likely to be.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoSome people go way out the their way to avoid toll bridges. Especially, if the bulk of their trip is otherwise toll free. For me, if there is a free website app paired with a pay-to-play mobile app, I will never buy (or subscribe to) the mobile app because I consider that a bait-and-switch. If the whole stack was pay-to-play and I want the service offered I will pay.
- seanwilson 6y ago> Looking at the estimates for revenue per 10,000 visitors clearly shows as well, we would make 2x as much revenue at $100/year than we would at just $20/year! Maybe I missed it, but it's worth pointing out that while in the table the one-time cost makes less than the yearly pricing plans, that's only for the first year - presumably the yearly plans come out ahead the next year and even more the year after as long as the user retention is decent. For my paid Chrome extension (https://www.checkbot.io/ https://www.checkbot.io/), I've experimented with yearly only, then quarterly + yearly, then monthly + yearly plans. I think quarterly plans are worth exploring (I don't see them often) as it means users get longer to evaluate the service before they decide if they're going to renew. They can be a pain to be clear about in pricing tables though.
- valuearb 6y agoThe higher revenues for onetime purchase show the weakness of subscriptions vs the old upgrade model, and I wish Apple would understand it. Subscriptions carry the fear of paying for something you won’t be using, or being nickel and dimed for years on end. Upgrades are a much simpler purchase decision. Am I using the app? Is it offering a good value? Does the upgrade provide new features I want or need at a reasonable price? Some customers will say no to one of those questions at first, but eventually change their minds. Like subscriptions this model matches revenues to usage, so engaged customers support future development. iOS would be a much better platform with easy upgrades vs. easy subscriptions.
- Valkhyr 6y agoThis. With very few exceptions (content subscriptions (e.g. Netflix) and services that have a server-side component core to its functionality (e.g. Dropbox)), I avoid subscriptions like the plague. With applications, I don't choose between more or less expensive subscription, but I'll chose your competitor who sells upfront.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dkersten 6y agoThe way I see it: unless you’re putting in a bunch of monthly resources for me (in terms of content creation or server resources), you have no business charging me a recurring fee. If it’s essentially an offline app (or easily could be) then I’m either paying up front or not at all. I’ve passed up on many apps that I would have happily paid for (in some cases up to about $100), but was unwilling to pay a subscription of any cost.
- eddhead 6y agoES Explorer, I'm looking at you
- ywei3410 6y agoWhat are your feelings on applications which have a server-side component which isn't necessary to it's functioning? For example JetBrains products with their plugin store or Unity with the asset store?
- m3kw9 6y agoSubscriptions for purely software updates seem like a steep price hike over buy once and get updates for a long time. I really don’t like how devs are under the guise of we need to make a living and start charging subscription for such. I won’t buy that unless is totally indispensable
- dwighttk 6y ago> The first thing you’ll notice is that people are much more willing to make a one-time purchase. This X 100 I would rather pay you $50 with a major update every year that costs $50 than $50/yr subscription. Because if the resubscription comes up and things are a little tight I lose access to the app. Or if I don’t use the app I don’t have to worry about accidentally autoresubscribing
- GordonS 6y agoFor desktop software, and mobile apps without a backend, I agree. For everything with a backend though, I just don't see how it's a sustainable business model to allow customers to keep using the backend in perpetuity. Of course, a lot of consumers know knowing about the tech that's involved, so as a software engineer I have a different perspective here.
- dwighttk 6y agosure, but don't tie in a backend if it isn't required (e.g. adobe) sell it as a separate service.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- makecheck 6y agoUntil it stops clearly rewarding scammers, I cannot support subscriptions in any way. From the very start, these criminals figured out some great ways to trick people into auto-renewing subscriptions at exorbitant rates for garbage apps [1]. I especially love how they reached the “Top Grossing” lists (I sure never have...must be nice to not have any morals). [1] https://techcrunch.com/2018/10/15/sneaky-subscriptions-are-plaguing-the-app-store/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/10/15/sneaky-subscriptions-are-p... Also, I just plain want to make things that lots of people can enjoy. Subscriptions certainly limit your audience so why is that better (and why should that be the only option or even the preferred one?). I know developers who asked for this in 2007 but can we please have “free trial, pay at end of trial” and “paid major upgrades” as standard, store-supported options, at long last? There was never anything wrong with these models and they are also great ways to make a living.
- Valkhyr 6y agoThe way to fix app "subscriptions" is not to charge more (or less) but to fix the customer-hostile structure of app "subscriptions". The big issue with app "subscriptions" is that they don't actually work like subscriptions. Before the digital age, "subscription" used to mean (and for physical products it still means) that you get regular delivery of something as long as you pay. If you stop paying, you no longer get more stuff, but you get to keep whatever you already received. You don't have to return your back issues of the newspaper when you cancel your subscription. Arguably TV subscriptions have always been an exception, but functionally they're not because you can record TV. App "subscriptions" are different. Developers like to emphasize how they fund sustained future development of an app, but the reality is that when you cancel you usually lose access even to current features (you arguably already helped pay for). The way app subscriptions should work is that you can perpetually keep using whatever version of the app was current when you stopped paying (Jetbrains actually does this, and I salute them for it: https://sales.jetbrains.com/hc/en-gb/articles/207240845-What-is-perpetual-fallback-license-?_ga=2.179586276.1564311569.1599521489-1376937852.1598939461 https://sales.jetbrains.com/hc/en-gb/articles/207240845-What...). The current model is really "app rental", and it's inherently customer-hostile. Playing with the pricing does not fundamentally change that.
- nodamage 6y agoJust to clarify, with the Jetbrains model you don't get to keep the current version, your fallback license is for the version that was available 12 months prior to the date you decided to stop paying. (Presumably this is so you can't upgrade for a month, then cancel, and end up with a perpetual license for the current version.)
- stordoff 6y agoThis is roughly how the collectorz.com desktop apps work. Once your service plan expires, you lose the ability to update and some cloud features, but you can always use the version you currently have (or update to the last version that was available within your service plan). If I open Movie Collector, which I had a paid subscription for but let lapse, and try to update, I get: Your current version: 18.4 build X You can update to version: 19.5 build X (Note: your update plan expired on 2019-XX-XX) If you renew your update plan, you will be able to update to version: 20.6 build X
- gnicholas 6y agoIt looks like this is all based on survey data, which I have found to not correlate particularly well with how people actually behave. Am I misreading this (or not giving survey data enough credit)?
- lebaux 6y agoMy biggest issue is broad generalization, SaaS is not homogenous. I suspect the author never meant for anyone to take it as universal truth, rather his own observation of his speck of SaaS.
- semireg 6y agoI’m an indie dev that wrote a useful Electron app for designing and printing labels (both rolls and sheets), data import, rendering batches of images, etc. My competition is either free (DYMO/Brother) or $500 commercial software for expensive printers. So how do I price? For a year I had my price at $47.99 one-time and did OK. A month ago I segmented my licenses/users into Personal (same price of $47.99) and Business ($147.99) licenses. Business license has the ability to print barcodes. Revenue increased w a slight decrease of units sold. Then last week I launched a Business subscription at $14.99/month. Everyone is still buying the one-time licenses. I don’t blame them... I generally avoid subscriptions. Soon I’ll be releasing a Shopify app/integration and I’m really curious how that user group will respond. As far as I know, merchants are already used to monthly costs so it just becomes the cost of operating their store. I need a pricing consultant. Check out my pricing page at https://label.live/download https://label.live/download
- tonyedgecombe 6y ago>Everyone is still buying the one-time licenses. I'm not surprised, everybody can multiply $15 by 12 and see that doesn't add up.
- semireg 6y agoCan you help me understand how you, as a user, would prefer to see it add up?
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIf something costs more to rent over the next 12 months than buy outright then I am going to buy it outright.
- HatchedLake721 6y agoNow test removing one time price for businesses and keep monthly pricing.
- throwaway4good 6y agoI recently downloaded "Jambl" which is a music/synth app for iPhone based on a TikTok ad. It immediately pushed me to start a 7.99 GBP a week subscription. About 550 USD a year.
- throwaway4good 6y agoMusic Ally Startup Files: Jambl, the music-making app for non-musicians https://musically.com/2020/02/12/startup-files-jambl-music-making-app/ https://musically.com/2020/02/12/startup-files-jambl-music-m... "The rationale for aggressively pushing a £7.99-a-week subscription (the same pricing as sister app Beat Maker Go) whilst showing freemium users unskippable ads is that, by pushing away all but truly determined users, Jambl can get feedback, iterate and make its app super-sticky – then shift to full-on growth."
- GordonS 6y agoAren't they only going to be left with about 3 lunatic users, and perhaps 2 very rich ones that don't notice they're paying for it? $550/y is a lot for consumer software. Windows OS, O365, nope, I can't even think of any other consumer software priced that high!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- londonatil 6y agoI believe that both the app store and Google play store charge 30% fees for all app purchases except for subscriptions lasting over a year, which are 15%. That further incentivizes developers to concentrate on the subscription model.
- jwr 6y agoPricing subscriptions higher has more side effects: * you get users who care more about your app * you get users who will not place irrational demands ("I paid $0.99 for your app, now implement this feature or I want my money back!") * you get to focus on features that matter and long-term development, without having to implement shiny cruft just so that a "major version number upgrade" is justified * you have a sustainable business I've reached a point where I am worried if an app I use regularly does not have a subscription model with reasonable pricing. Experience shows that this means that sooner or later the authors will lose interest and abandon the app, or go overly broad with features. I've seen this happen so many times that I'm actually wary of even starting to use new apps at this point. As for the "but it's too expensive" problem, well, perhaps you don't need all those apps after all? There aren't that many apps that I use regularly and I'd much rather limit the selection and then pay for those that I use and need.
- taigi100 6y agoAnd here I am, in EU, thinking a very long amount of time before committing to even a 5$ subscription.
- alexruf 6y agoPersonally I like apps which provide both - a subscription and pay once model. I have no problem paying monthly for an app I use on a daily base. But I don’t want dozens of subscriptions for all my apps to run in parallel. The problem is that a lot of apps with subscription models don’t provide enough value to justify a monthly payment fee.
- billpg 6y agoI use a podcast downloader/player daily. I paid something like £5 maybe ten years ago for it. Around a month or so ago, one of my feeds had weird description text that caused the download button to be bumped off the visible area, meaning I couldn't download that episode. I took a screenshot and reported it to the developers. When filing the bug, I wondered about that £5 all those years ago and I imagined we'd both be happier if I had taken out a yearly subscription instead. The developers would be motivated to keep me happy because I'd stop paying if I didn't get my bug fixes done. In the end, they promptly fixed the bug and pushed out an update by the end of the day without taking any extra payment, so I'm not sure what point I'm trying to make.
- srg0 6y agoThere is a problem with in-app subscriptions which is rarely brought up - - apple/google cut. OK for a $2 purchase. Not OK for recurrent payments. If it is indeed a valuable service, it should have a web site. More often than not online subscriptions will be priced more competitively. See Babbel subscriptions in app and online.