3 ms·
The guy is missing several critical points, but raises another good one everybody else forgets. Missing: The Novichok family consists of 3 used and 9 known two
by rurban 6y ago
The guy is missing several critical points, but raises another good one everybody else forgets.
Missing: The Novichok family consists of 3 used and 9 known two-component agents, which are scientifically known since an Iranian paper published the formulas. They are quite trivial to produce, even for a lay student.
The good point: potence.
Since the Novichoks are so potent, they usually kill within minutes or at least the patient will not awake from the coma.
Which renders the whole Skripal and Nawalny affairs moot. Since Novichok was designed for military use, it needs to be very potent to be able to deliver it effectively over enemy territory.
In the secret services, i.e. criminal usecase it doesn't not need to be that potent. You don't need to kill tens of thousands soldiers, only one. Just the use of a two-component agent will not kill the killer, it is much safer to use. So the new usecase for these agents changed. Military abandoned it, because it was ineffective. Secret services still like to use it, because it is effective.
Now to the blame game. Russia developed it, because they heard that americans and british developed such a new, secret two component nerve agent. So they came up with their own variants. We don't know the formula of the US and UK agents, not even their names. We just know that they exist because the designer of the Russian variant deflected to the US and wrote a book about it. Most likely they are the very same, Russians just found the same.
So the Skripal attacks could have been done by everybody, and it certainly wasn't Novichok. Looks more like fish poisoning. As assumed by the doctor who treated them. You don't awake after two weeks from Novichok poisoning and need to shield them from the public. You only need to shield them if you are having something to hide.
The Nawalny attack now looks like a GRU attack with a very low dosis, but this doesn't fit the description with the tea cup.
So it could be a weak Novichok variant with an extremely low potency so that the patient will survive. As similar GRU attacks before. Just fry their brains a little bit. It's still safer to use.