3 ms·
You're both fixated on this "Eternal September" argument, which is a total mischaracterization of everything I've stated. I'm not talking about people, I'm tal
by echelon 6y ago
You're both fixated on this "Eternal September" argument, which is a total mischaracterization of everything I've stated.
I'm not talking about people, I'm talking about companies behaving badly.
I want the entire world on the Internet. I want everyone creating more and consuming things that better fit their interests. I'm a creator! I want people using my stuff!
But at the same time I want our data and our tools to be open. I want portability and the ability to integrate how I want. We had some semblance of that, and now it's gone.
The web is eroding!
Mobile is locked down!
Our data is stuck in silos!
We're being tracked!
Diversity is gone!
Interoperability is gone!
These things happened.
The DOJ should break apart Google, Apple, and Facebook. They haven't been good stewards of the Internet.
I've gotten nearly a hundred upvotes in this comment thread, so I don't think I'm alone in this thinking.
And I don't mean to call either of you out. I just don't think you're seeing why I'm frustrated.
- bogidon 6y agoThe internet grew and so did its capacity of making people money. In a world which cares a great deal about money, it makes sense the culture would slowly get shifted by industry to keep developers focused on what makes the money, which is apparently not skins. It’s the filter on ideas of capitalism applied at scale and it’s not unique to the internet (eg Cookie-Cutter houses). It‘s interests are aligned with maximizing access though, but yeah, I get the frustration, we lose a lot in that process. Maybe we can think up something better...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago>I'm not talking about people, I'm talking about companies behaving badly. Your main claim was that the "old web" has been destroyed. The web is not eroding. It has expanded dramatically, and now includes huge amounts of stuff that were not part of the (say) 1994-2000 version. It continues to contain large amounts of stuff that are directly connected to that earlier stuff, albeit in massively greater quantity and quality. Mobile is locked down. Nothing to say about that. Mobile is not the web, it's just the platform that most people interact with the online world on. Nothing more (or less). Data is not deterministically locked in silos, although many people take the easy path toward certain functionality (e.g. email) that has that result. But this still a choice. Ditto for tracking, though arguably less of a choice. You can do a lot to stop it, but you shouldn't have to. The software/IT/web world is massively more diverse than it was in 1995. The available material, the participants : way, way more diverse. Interoperability was never there: we had the Unix wars, Unix vs. Windows, mac vs everyone else. We had Intel vs PowerPC (soon to be revisited as Intel vs ARM). Unless you've been using GNU since 1986 (I have), your tools weren't open. Google, Apple and Facebook are doing bad things. They have not destroyed the internet that you loved, they've made it harder to see.