4 ms·
Oof, GPU by Imagination Technologies. Here's hoping their close brush with death opened them to the idea of open sourcing their code.
by monocasa 6y ago
Oof, GPU by Imagination Technologies.
Here's hoping their close brush with death opened them to the idea of open sourcing their code.
- phkahler 6y ago>> Oof, GPU by Imagination Technologies. My first thought as well. On the other hand... baby steps. We need a chip like this very much. If the first ones are slow or too proprietary that may be OK, it is still pushing the RISC-V ecosystem in the right direction. It will help validate a lot of software which will enable more open designs by having things ready to go.
- ansible 6y agoI've recently purchased a Sipeed Maix Bit, which is based on the Kendryte K210 (RV64GC dual-core), just so that I can start messing around in the RISC-V 64-bit ecosystem. However, the K210 has just 8MB of on-chip RAM, limiting the applications. It ships with MicroPython, and you can run microcontroller Linux, which is a fun little hack. However, I'm primarily interested in Rust development on the RISC-V. For bare-metal programming, the K210 is enough for me to get my feet wet. Thanks to the wonderful community, you can already run gdb for source-level debugging of Rust on that platform, with the addition of a $7 USD JTAG adapter. That said, as long as the PicoRio board (even without a GPU) is available for less than $100 USD, I am totally buying one as soon as they are available for order.
- stefan_ 6y agoThey managed to pick the one mobile GPU vendor that has zero open-source drivers for their chips and a reputation for horribly messy and unstable proprietary code. Another board for the landfill, forever doomed to some 80s throwback Unix timeshare shell application.
- monocasa 6y agoIn IMG's defense, the way that their drivers and firmware are micro optimized for the specific IP core version and use case by the host software was one of their competitive advantages. It's one of the reasons why their cores were some of the fastest and most efficient for the years that they still had plenty of capital rolling in to support that model. You'd expect that kind of thing to be brittle when you don't have source access, but the drivers themselves were remarkably clean when I spent some time reversing them. It's just a shame that they're so afraid of open source too, because the above really compounds that pain.
- snvzz 6y agoOof indeed. I'd rather unaccelerated graphics. Hell, take any display solution from opencores. But don't give me proprietary garbage and especially not PowerVR. I'm OK with no graphics as an alternative. Hell, I could always use some USB display solution.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> I'm OK with no graphics as an alternative Then you'll be fine with the first version of this, since it's exactly that.
- snvzz 6y agoYeah, I noticed. And hopefully by the time the 2nd version comes, they'll have understood who they're selling these to... or there'll be alternatives.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoYeah, I'm hoping that the delay before the second edition is enough that they can change course on it, too. Either way, better to have more riscv options than fewer:)
- rjsw 6y agoThere is a press release by Imagination Technologies stating that they are partners in the project, would be a bit difficult to pick a different GPU.
- incompatible 6y ago"but the memory PHY, USB 3.0 PHY, GPU, and other I/Os will still be closed source"
- monocasa 6y agoI read that as the HDL rather than the drivers since they call out the memory PHY.
- throwaway021331 6y agoI've never had the need to connect any SBC to a monitor. A lot of people use them as servers, sensors and so on.
- MegaDeKay 6y agoThe Beaglebone has the same problem, which is unfortunate. It would be sweet to have a completely open source stack on that thing that included accelerated graphics.
- DominikD 6y agoIt's up to chip manufacturers, not IP provider, to release code - and none of them did.