6 ms·
> I posit that much of what we herald as "innovation" is just what you'd naturally come up with if you work on the problem long and hard enough. It was the inv
by dragontamer 6y ago
> I posit that much of what we herald as "innovation" is just what you'd naturally come up with if you work on the problem long and hard enough.
It was the invention of tri-state logic that made address multiplexing easy to do.
Yeah, with tri-state logic (high voltage, low-voltage, and high-impedance state), its easy to implement. But before the high-impedance state was formalized, its less obvious how you're supposed to hook up multiple chips onto a single address + data bus.
Someone had to invent "Chip Select", as well as how the transistors, voltages, and currents flow under such conditions. Its certainly easy to "reinvent" after you've been introduced to the concept, but it probably wasn't easy to think up first.
- kens 6y agoAs a historical note, there are several approaches for hooking multiple devices to a bus before TRI-STATE® logic. Early IBM mainframes (such as the IBM 1401) used AND-OR gates for the bus. Each signal onto the bus was gated by an AND gate to control who was talking to the bus, and the AND gates were connected by wired-OR. Another common approach was the open-collector bus, for example in the Xerox Alto. The gates connected to the bus could pull the bus low but not high. Pull-up resistors pulled the bus high. In some cases, multiple devices would deliberately talk to the bus at the same time, OR-ing together their values. The downside of an open-collector bus is it's relatively slow to transition high, since you have a low-current resistor pulling it high. Tri-state drivers, on the other hand, can provide a solid current both high and low. (TRI-STATE is a registered trademark of National Semiconductor, interestingly enough.)
- dragontamer 6y ago> open-collector bus Ah right, and that's still used by I2C if I remember correctly (a low speed bus that's surprisingly common). I didn't know about IBM's AND-OR bus before. But now that I think of it, the open-collector bus is the exact opposite of AND-OR. Open-collector is common today because modern chips (CMOS) can sink more current than they can source. I don't know if TTL (or whatever IBM Mainframes used back then) had different characteristics which made the positive-variation more useful.
- stephen_g 6y agoNational Semi merged into TI in 2011, so I assume the TRI-STATE trademark is owned by them now. I would say the word ‘tristate’ has basically become just about completely genericised by this point though.
- FullyFunctional 6y agoAren't you mixing two things? TRISTATE was required to hook up multiple chips _data_ lines, yes, but not the address lines, which are input-only. If the innovation was sharing the data bus, then, sure, that would make more sense. FWIW, even the 4004 (1971, predating the MK4096 by three years) used multiplexing and I'm sure it was a known approach prior to that.
- dragontamer 6y ago> Aren't you mixing two things? TRISTATE was required to hook up multiple chips _data_ lines, yes, but not the address lines, which are input-only. If the innovation was sharing the data bus, then, sure, that would make more sense. You're right in this instance. ------------ The innovation therefore, was coming out with a 16-pin RAM chip when everyone else was coming out with 22-pin RAM chips. Looking up the history of the time, Intel, and other big companies, were betting on 22-pin RAM chips to deal with the addressing issue. The innovation was realizing that you're strobing RAS (Row Address) and CAS (Column Address) in separate cycles anyway. By using those separate cycles, you only needed 6-pins to address, even on bog-standard address busses. Sure, the Intel chip may have a 16-bit address bus, but the MK4096 didn't care. Wire up the bottom 12-bits, 2-pins to each input address pin, and you're set. Seems brilliant to me. ------- I keep looking at the datasheet and the main thing that annoys me is that its wasteful TTL. But I guess that was the late 60s / early 70s for ya, CMOS wasn't invented yet so I guess TTL was what they used.
- FullyFunctional 6y agoThanks. As always, context is everything and this is certainly more than was implied by the blurb. Hopefully we can rest it here. The fundamental chase of bandwidth-per-pin hasn't stopped. Two recent examples: Eton RPC DRAM manages to essentially run the whole protocol over the data wires using just 22 pins for a 16-bit DDR bus. Another: GDDR6X finally introduced PAM4 (four voltage levels per pin = double the bandwidth). Now we just need to combine these ideas ...