3 ms·
I don't understand how all the people here, who all want to be the next Bill Gates and make a ton of money selling software, services, or Juiceros, think it's "
by fortran77 6y ago
I don't understand how all the people here, who all want to be the next Bill Gates and make a ton of money selling software, services, or Juiceros, think it's "ok" to steal content. (The same content that they probably deny they watch because it's not hip enough.)
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoThinking about your comment is bringing up a number of interesting threads of thought. Bill Gates made a ton of money and wasn't necessarily following either law or moral guidelines to do so. The success enjoyed by Bill Gates was hard earned. Success is a destination at the end of a journey that is too hard for a lot of people. Bill Gates' software is some of the most pirated software ever. Bill Gates is one of the richest people ever. Can anyone become anywhere near that scale of rich without being morally or ethically bankrupt? What crime 'piracy' in comparison to the business practices of the highly successful / profitable / rich? I don't know the answer to those questions, and I don't pass judgement as it's subjective, but they're the places my mind went in relation to your comment.
- pwinnski 6y agoBill Gates is your example? One of the worst examples you could have chosen, because he both engaged in piracy and was one of the top "victims" of piracy all the while he was becoming the richest man in the country.
- Rapzid 6y agoAnd didn't MS at the time prefer people to pirate Windows and Office over not using it because it contributed to the ubiquitousness of those products?
- michaelmrose 6y agoStealing has a specific meaning. It is nonsensical to describe failure to follow copyright law stealing. Nobody calls exceeding the speed limit stealing velocity nor jaywalking "stealing the street". Rich people convinced other rich people that it would be a good idea to let rich people decide which bits I'm allowed to transmit to you in order to maximize the revenue of people who for the most part are in the business of licensing creative work not actually doing it. With zero chances of influencing the law on this or most other issues I can either choose to be a slave to it or not. Only slaves and cowards obey their masters even when they aren't being watched. I jaywalk too when its safe to do so. "Find me in New York for this quarter!"
- jshaqaw 6y agoI am a tv producer. Stealing is if I invest years of blood, sweat, and capital into a project with the paradigm that in a free market exchange you can pay in some form to view it or not and happily find some alternative way to enjoy your time. Nobody is forcing you to watch what I make and you won’t die if you don’t watch it. The creators like myself you valorize don’t exist in a vacuum. If distributors who finance the projects upfront with risk capital don’t get paid then there is nobody to pay me for making content and thus content does not get made. Financing the speculative production of a movie or tv series is inherently high risk. Let me flip the script a little michaelmrose. What do you do for your money and why should you not have to do it for me for free?
- echlebek 6y agoYou have a good argument about why copyright violation is wrong, but you didn't respond to GP's arguments about why it is not theft.
- michaelmrose 6y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/theft https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/theft Definition of theft 1a : the act of stealing specifically : the felonious taking and removing of personal property with intent to deprive the rightful owner of it Much like violating copyright isn't similar in nature to commandeering ships on the high seas its not much similar to the taking of real property in that the owner isn't deprived of anything and in fact is wholly unaffected and absent from the transaction. Actual property is the necessary resolution of the inherently rivalrous nature of property while Copyright is mandate that I limit what data I transmit to another party so as to avoid transmitting any patterns of bits that could reasonably be argued to be owned by any entity on the premise that this limitation will create an intangible good that can serve as an incentive to encourage creators to trade in it. If congress contrary to the rest of our interests grants you sole ownership of the color red I wont be a thief if I opt to paint my house that color. Really this is a tired subject having been debated endlessly since the 70s. Anyone still using it is apt to have staked out their position and decided they care more about the emotional import of the word thief than reasoned argument.
- lioeters 6y ago> WSJ: You watch physics lectures and Harlem Globetrotters [on YouTube]? > Gates: This social-networking thing takes you to crazy places. > WSJ: But those were stolen, correct? > Gates: Stolen's a strong word. It's copyrighted content that the owner wasn't paid for. So yes.