6 ms·
We've lost so much since the 90's and 00's. Most people are using less configurable computers: phones. We can't easily install the software we want on our dev
by echelon 6y ago
We've lost so much since the 90's and 00's.
Most people are using less configurable computers: phones.
We can't easily install the software we want on our devices (iPhone especially, but Android also to an extent). Add to that the fact that we have to go through a distribution channel that takes a 30% cut. It's gross af.
The social media platforms took over from websites. Nobody really bothers with personal websites or blogs anymore since the majority of the population get their news from social media. Why spend effort building for the long tail?
Forum communities are dead because of social media. Facebook pages and subreddits are not the same.
There's one search engine, and it has a pretty big moat. This search engine built a browser and is now trying to destroy ad blockers via extension capability removal and web bundles.
It's pretty obvious that Google is trying to kill the web. AMP, steering away from semantic web, etc. They want everything to be Chrome.
Firefox doesn't have as much user share because of aforementioned browser.
We invented some cool protocols along the way (blockchain), but also lost a few that were really great (bittorrent, DHT).
IRC is pretty dead. Now there's Slack and Discord. Riot is a pretty distant third.
Apps and websites got SUPER BLOATED.
A few things have improved, though: Git is pretty freaking sweet, and Rust is the language of the future.
It's like when Link wakes up in Ocarina of Time after retrieving the Master Sword. Except in our case, everything's suddenly shiny, but feels plastic and artificial. We've discovered we're now renting everything and craftsmanship has withered away to a world of composability and integration.
It's a simple story: billions and billions of dollars chased after capturing and exploiting the average human user. Each company it super simple to adopt their platform. To do so they had to destroy the competition and create a moat. These negative externalities coupled with high concentrations of users to platforms has left a wake of destruction.
The indie, free and open web got knee-kicked by the giants.
- spectramax 6y agoI mostly agree with you. It’s sad. The only thing I disagree is that iPhone, while closed, is really important piece equipment in your life. It’s got your walking gait, browsing history, photos, videos, notes, passwords, social media accounts, health records, bank info, geo location, driving habits, where I work and how I commute, where I jog, etc. It’s ridiculously dense. This kind of a device didn’t exist in the year 2000. So, while 90’s tech would be awesome on the surface, I am glad Apple is in the driving seat to manage my phone’s security. App Store is amazing, shitty software that spies on you doesn’t make it through (chrome extensions anyone?). Treat 30% as a privacy fee. You’re glad there is a T2 security chip on your device. And you’re glad Apple pays $400k a year for several top notch security engineers that work there. This cannot be achieved by a bunch of Winamp hooligans and open source crusaders. Replace Apple with your fav phone manufacturer. Everything else, I agree. The internet has become a pile of shit.
- anthk 6y ago>It’s ridiculously dense. This kind of a device didn’t exist in the year 2000 Pocket PC's existed.
- spectramax 6y agoDid they have a camera? Gyro, magnetometer, accelerometer? Did it contain my call history? Did it know where I am? Totally unfair comparison.
- anthk 6y agoSome recent ones bundled a GPS unit, and they were not blent with smartphones until 2008? but they where good enough. You talk as if before the iPhone we had -nothing-. And that's not true in any sense.
- echelon 6y agoIf the W3C had focus, we could have developed a cross-platform native application runtime that worked over HTTP. You could visit a website and a lightweight, sandboxed app could be downloaded. Google kind of did this with "Android Instant Apps". It'd have all the same permissions and sandboxing guarantees that apps distributed over the stores do. The OS could even collect telemetry on the kind of requests these apps made to help quash bad actors. It might have even prevented Javascript from growing into what it is today. We'd have a strong division between what is app and what is document. (I'm not bashing the Javascript/frontend folks! I just wish we'd had a dichotomy rather than stuff everything into HTML.) I think WASM might stand a chance of doing some good here. It'd be nice if there was agreement between Apple and Google to build a cross-platform device SDK. They won't. We need to defend HTML and our browsers from growing into the Frankenstein's monster Google is pushing for. If we lose that, we lose the war.
- pantalaimon 6y ago> shitty software that spies on you doesn’t make it through (chrome extensions anyone?). Treat 30% as a privacy fee. https://objective-see.com/blog/blog_0x4E.html https://objective-see.com/blog/blog_0x4E.html
- hkon 6y agoYes, funny thing though, you can watch a youtube how-to video for almost anything you want to accomplish. Facebook groups are sitting on so much information which previously would have been accumulated in forums, unavailable and totally useless except to serve ads for the members of said groups.
- anthk 6y agobhahahhahaha. Not even close. FB groups are mostly a bunch of conspiranoids and retards. And sure a 30 minute video with shitty poses is better than a damn written guide being read and done in less than 10 minutes, even 5 as I am a able to quicly parse it. Even usenet and IRC are far more superior for highly technical issues. Back in the day I had lots of info in fora and IRC channels instead of FB being blocked to outsiders and worse, full of trackers, add and being 90% of it, noise.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y ago> FB groups are mostly a bunch of conspiranoids and retards. Depends what groups you're on. I don't see them in any of the groups I'm in. > And sure a 30 minute video with shitty poses is better than a damn written guide being read and done in less than 10 minutes, even 5 as I am a able to quicly parse it. Definitely true, but not something I've ever had a problem with. I was confused a bit by some of the instructions for the auto bed leveling kit I got for my 3D printer, searched YouTube, and found a 6 minute video that was quite succinct. > Even usenet and IRC are far more superior for highly technical issues. Because generally it's only highly technical people on those platforms. > Back in the day I had lots of info in fora and IRC channels instead of FB being blocked to outsiders and worse, full of trackers, add and being 90% of it, noise. Forums and IRC channels still exist.
- StevePerkins 6y agoMost of this is nonsense. Most of what you're describing is simply an extension of Eternal September. "We" haven't really lost any of these things. It's just that newcomers don't care about them so much. And that's okay. Why would I be upset that that some teen or 20-something, who primarily uses the internet to post and browse selfies on social media, does so from a phone rather than a IBM/Lenovo ThinkPad? Their main use case is Instagram or TikTok. A ThinkPad makes no sense for them. But I can still buy one. Social media platforms "took over" in the sense of having more eyeballs. But so what? Few if any of those eyeballs are really interested in the things that I'm interested in from websites, blogs, etc. Moreover, websites and blogs are still around, and just as populated as they ever were. It's just that there's a bigger population on social media sites. There ARE multiple search engines. DuckDuckGo even has good policies. True, none of them may be as good as Google. But pretty much ALL of them are better than Lycos, Infoseek, AltaVista, and all of the old-school competitors who lost to Google. The only thing on this list that's a halfway decent point is Firefox user share. Just to the extent that browser engine monoculture gives Google a lot of power. But as long as the engine is open source, and there's a possibility of more privacy-conscious players leveraging it (e.g. Brave, Vivaldi, etc), then I can live with that. The "positive" bit about Rust being "the language of the future" gives me the impression that you're mostly mourning geek culture being delegated to a side subculture, instead of being the dominant culture of the Internet itself. To an extent, it is a bummer to no longer be at the forefront of the hype wave. But to be honest, now that I'm middle-aged I don't so much care about being at the forefront of the hype wave anyway. As long as I have my crufty greyboard corner in the Internet's basement, I'm happy. And that doesn't really seem to be going anywhere.
- echelon 6y ago> Most of this is nonsense. > Most of what you're describing is simply an extension of Eternal September. "We" haven't really lost any of these things. It's just that newcomers don't care about them so much. You're missing my point. I don't care that the tech stack changed. I care that everything is locked down and inherently inflexible. Everything has become a rental and we don't have autonomy in the choices.
- 6y ago
- dpc_pw 6y agoI feel you. Come to Urbit. It's not ready yet, but the hope was not lost.
- rawoke083600 6y ago>It's pretty obvious that Google is trying to kill the web. Won't it mean then that Google kills it self ?
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoYou can still use all of those things, so what have you lost?
- trekrich 6y agoapple taking a cut is gross?! Servers and bandwidth cost money.
- Ygg2 6y agoTorrents died? When?