5 ms·
Might want to FOIA / Privacy Act request them for the information in your file. It should make for interesting reading. The person who'd be authorized to say
by patio11 16y ago
Might want to FOIA / Privacy Act request them for the information in your file. It should make for interesting reading. The person who'd be authorized to say "no" to that has very, very different motivations in life than a ground-level security screener. For example, they're paid to avoid bad PR, and "The Privacy Act, which was established to prevent government abuses of power like the secret files the FBI kept on folks, does not prevent us from keeping secret files on you" is the definition of bad PR. They would also have to commit to that position in writing. Every bureaucrat learns very quickly that things which are not written down never happened. The events described by those tweets? Never happened. Get a signed logbook entry, though, and you have instant chain of evidence going back to God Almighty.
This is, generally, one of those "letters on paper can be used to hack bureaucracies to one's advantage" kind of things.
c.f. http://www.cbp.gov/xp/cgov/admin/fl/foia/reference_guide.xml http://www.cbp.gov/xp/cgov/admin/fl/foia/reference_guide.xml
The above is mostly motivated by an enduring interest in the inner mechanics of complex systems, not by any particular feeling with regards to Wikileaks.
- iuguy 16y agoI suspect that homeland security does not fall under FoI but I could be wrong
- patio11 16y ago1 + 1 != 3, Customs and Border Protection is indeed subject to federal law. They publish a list of requests (with details elided) on the Internet: http://foia.cbp.gov/index.asp?ps=1&search=&category=FOIA_Logs http://foia.cbp.gov/index.asp?ps=1&search=&category=... Again, you could imagine them asserting one of the exemptions to the Act, but that would require them committing to a damaging position in paper. That is a major purpose of the exercise. The existence of that piece of paper would be a news story. (Man Claims Feds Out To Get Him On The Internet is not a news story.)
- iuguy 16y agoI don't think the feds are denying that they're out to get him. He's connected to the Wikileaks cable leak, the US government position is that this man is linked to what Hillary Clinton called, "ot just an attack on America's foreign policy interests ... it is an attack on the international community"[1]. [1] - http://hillary.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2010/11/29/clinton_wikileaks_disclosure_is_attack_on_the_international_community http://hillary.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2010/11/29/clinton_wi...
- rmc 16y agoyes but all those things can just been seen as politicians blustering. Politicians are very good at twisting words to say something while implying another thing. You get a bit of paper from the government saying "You there, you are not entitled to this", is worth way more.
- djcapelis 16y agoIIRC, he has done both. They refuse to release the contents or even tell him the name of the right file to ask for. The EFF and ACLU have both tried to get something to happen here...
- mtex 16y agoNo he hasn't. He refuses to do either because the government told him it cannot be done (riiight, as if the government never lies so as to discourage people.)
- avigesaa 16y agoAlso, check out the DHS TRIP program: http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/customer/redress/index.shtm http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/customer/redress/index.shtm. It's intended for this sort of thing. If nothing else, it may force someone to commit something to paper.
- pieceofpeace 16y agohttp://www.exquisitetweets.com/tweets?eids=eqt3bK9L1E.equdE5Igj8.equjFUYMxM.equunSrA96.equCze0DXU.equKkjGTC1.equM9wJJv2.equQJD8Dcb.equZBWohCT.equ7xm9arQ.eqvwgwlvIO.eqvMBtk8s0.eqvQUsu0Zx.eqvT74Lriu.eqvXEyMNzg.eqwgPKYFRl.eqwnDO4580.eqwrITBTY4.eqwFo79nem.eqwKW5rqhg.eqwM5rUpOu.eqwX9Hr7GS.eqxbeyCo1s#tweet23 http://www.exquisitetweets.com/tweets?eids=eqt3bK9L1E.equdE5... "I would really love to know the contents of the CBP file on me. It's too bad that they refuse to disclose it via TRIPS or any other system."
- tedunangst 16y agoTRIP is primarily for cases of mistaken identity. DHS has identified the person they intended to identify in this case.
- mtex 16y agoPeople, like I said in the other thread, I have already asked Appelbaum why he refuses to file FOIA requests with various DHS agencies, I have asked him why he won't launch a TRIP procedure with the DHS. Appelbaum called me a "stalker" for asking pointed questions, and later admitted on Twitter that he will not bother with FOIA requests and TRIP, simply because the G-man told him it was pointless to. ...now, this kind of defeatism is just so baffling to me. So, if I ask the government: "can I sue you?", and the government says: "No, of course not, you can't sue me, I am your government, I am unsuable", what, I should just go ahead and swallow any ole thing the government claims about itself? As if the government never lies? Ofcourse the government is going to lie and say "no, you can't sue", so as to discourage you. People, let me give you a piece of advice, from personal experience: whenever the government says "you can't sue the government", go ahead and do it anyway. You might be surprised as how easy it is to sue your own government. Don't let yourself be discouraged by government goons who lie to you and say it cannot be done.